Sweet Lucy's Pies

I just went for the 1st time because I saw a Pic of the butterscotch pie so had to go. Everything I hoped for. The crust is perfect. I also got one of these savory pies. What a surprise! The only problem is, I dont know which pie I liked the best. Definitely recommend!

My dad wanted a pie I couldn’t find ANYWHERE around town for his 60th birthday- a coconut chess pie. I called Sweet Lucy’s to see if they could help with a special order and she said “I’ve never made one, but it should be no problem, I’ll figure it out!” and boy did she! We all loved this pie: perfectly baked, flakey crust, and the coconut was such a treat. I will absolutely be back for seasonal pies this fall!

I ordered some mini bite sized pies for our firms monthly birthday celebration and everyone loved them. We ordered the following flavors: lemon blueberry, salted wildflower honey and chocolate chess. The lemon blueberry was everyone's favorite. The crust on all of them was phenomenal. When I went in to pick up I also got my husband and I some strawberry buttermilk slices (which she ended up giving them to me on the house after I insisted on paying) AND THEY WERE TO DIE FOR! Lindsey was very easy to work with, I am so happy to have found this sweet gem and will be back for more!

Absolutely fabulous. Got the Mother’s Day brunch pack and the charcuterie board and it is absolutely delicious.

Thanks Lindsey! Came in yesterday for a bday pie for my hubby. He loves.pecan pie. At.firat the cashier said they didn't have any, but then Lindsey pops out from the back and says I froze some right after I made them last week, would that work? Well, the pie was fantastic, so yes it definitely worked. Thank you

Instead of a cake at my wedding I wanted a "wedding pie"! Sweet Lucy's did fantastic job! The bride's pie was wonderful (and beautiful) and the guests loved the mini pies! If you don't hire Sweet Lucy's - or at least go there - you're missing out! :)

Love the cookies here. Especially the chocolate chip cookies. But they have been lacking with their hours. I live 30mins from the bakery, my last 2 trips have been dry trips because their hours keep changing and they’re always closed. They are now ONLY open on Fridays 2pm - 6pm

Cute little place with AMAZING pies!!! Sad I live so far away, but glad too...I would be here all the time!