Danny S.
Yelp
I'm prefacing this review by saying that I have only dined at one other Michelin star restaurant...Le Bernardin. So I am basing my review on that. I was holding this restaurant to a lot higher standard with more expectations. Also, I love to eat, but am not sure I have the most sophisticated palate. With that said, we really wanted to try a special restaurant while in Japan. For those of you who have visited Japan before, you will know that it is pretty hard to make a reservation. Restaurants there are not known to be friendly to foreign visitors. They aren't big and don't have lots of seats. And most don't speak english. So the main ways you can go about making dining reservations is via hotel concierge or third party concierge. My friend booked via TableAll. We just wanted to try a Michelin star restaurant and found Osaka to be easier. We were initially ecstatic to have gotten a reservation at Taian (a 3 star). HOwever, after doing some research, I wasn't sure what to expect. Meal price, including Tableall fee was around $200 per person. Most other 3 star restaurants were going for a lot more. This should have been the first sign. We got reservation for Thursday night at 8pm.
Ambiance/Location: We took a cab and he dropped us right in front of the restaurant. There is not English sign for it out front, so I went based off of pics I saw of it. The restaurant had only 1 table (set up for our party of 4) and bar seating (maybe 10-12 seats). Aesthetically it was very simple and decorated in typical Japanese fashion. Restroom was very clean.
Service: Excellent throughout. The main server spoke decent English. Everything was explained properly. For the most part, the service was great, just not sure if it is 3 michelin star worthy. For example, water was not served until requested (not sure if this is a Japanese thing or not). Meals were not brought out together (they would serve us 1-2 at a time and then go back to the kitchen for the other plates). The timing of the food was pretty good. NOt too slow, not too fast. Cool aspect was that sake glasses were all different and we got to pick our own glass. YOu are allowed to take pics of the food, just not of anything else. Server was very friendly. Chef and server walked us out (pretty neat). For anything other restaurant, I would have thought that service was fantastic, just not sure if it is 3 star standard.
Food: My expectation of it was to be blown away...and I was not. Food overall was great, but once again, I wasn't floored by it all. IT was a typical Kiseki menu. The previous reviews hit most of the dishes right on the head. All were unique with good flavor. There were a couple of weird items that my colleagues didn't like. I tried everything and really had no bad things to say about it. I appreciate trying the new items. They had these small fried fishes that you ate like fries...pretty good. There was a soup (egg drop with seafood) that was pretty good. Very clean flavors. I loved the sushi/sashimi. The fish was sea bream i believe. IT was a tad difficult to understand the explanation of the server. I loved the fact that you could choose your entree. I just did't like the fact that there was an upcharge for the beef (wagyu?) and fish dish. We tried the beef (cooked perfectly and was pretty damn good), short ribs (also cooked nicely), and sea bream. The fish was flaky and well seasoned. The biggest disappointment to me was the rice. I was expecting big and bold flavor (from either beef marrow or something), yet it was bland. Dessert was a fruit jelly of some sort and that was good as well. The sake selection was ok, and was priced fair. We didnt try anything else.
Overall it was a great dining experience, just not sure if the 3 stars are justified. I would not need to return, and would recommend trying another restaurant if you can get reservations.