Lisa M.
Yelp
The Tarnished Truth Distilling Co. is a growing local distillery. They produced 10k bottles in their 1st year and 55k in their 4th year this year (2021). I made reservations for my spouse and I for the tour ($21.47/adult) a couple weeks in advance as a surprise for his birthday, and we had a great time and tried some excellent spirits!
-- The Distillery & Tour --
The distillery is located on the bottom floor of the Cavalier Hotel in what used to be the laundry facilities. It's a small location and a small team, and they clearly put a lot of passion and knowledge into their work. We enjoyed the 20 minute tour and getting to learn more about the process. I definitely learned a lot! There is then additional time spent in a guided tasting in their private tasting room.
-- The Sips --
(Prices current as of Dec '21)
* Bourbon Mash Moonshine (90 proof; made of 70% corn, 18% wheat, 12% barley):
Unaged. This is their "before version" of their whiskey, which is still aging. This has a slight burn but not like cheaper spirits that burn with ethanol. ($25.99/375mL, which is $0.07/mL)
* High Rye Straight Bourbon Whiskey (86 proof; 60% corn, 36% rye, 4% barley):
Aged 3 years. Great aromas developed during the aging process. This whiskey gives you the sweetness from the corn and the spices from the rye. It's not as sweet as most bourbons and not as spicy as most ryes but rather is in-between. Would be good in cocktails. ($39.99/375mL, which is $0.11/mL, or $59.99/750 mL, which is $0.08/mL)
* Old Cavalier Reserve Single Barrel Straight Bourbon Whisky (86 proof; 84% corn, 8% rye, 8% malted barley):
Aged 11 years. Single barrel means they only open one barrel at a time, and this is their most premium product. The higher corn and lower rye content results in a lot of butterscotch flavor. It's smooth and well rounded. This is a limited product exclusive to their distillery (whereas their other products are distributed outside and throughout VA). My spouse's favorite. ($54.99/375mL, which is $0.15/mL, or $99.99/750mL, which is $0.13/mL)
* Old Cavalier Bourbon Cream Liqueur (32 proof or 16% ABV; their High Rye spirit blended with cream and sugar):
Made with their 3 year aged High Rye Straight Bourbon Whiskey. Their "answer to Baileys" (which is 17% ABV), it's similar to Irish Cream but richer and bolder in taste with caramel and vanilla notes. Sometimes they are unable to keep it in stock (the pandemic has made it challenging to get things delivered). Definitely tasty. ($29.99/750 mL, which is $0.04/mL)
* AVA Vodka (80 proof; 100% corn):
Triple distilled. Has a pretty clean taste, but we found it to be not as smooth as other pricier options. Great quality for value. ($19.99/750mL, which is $0.03/mL)
* Fourth Handle Coastal American Gin (90 proof; 100% corn vodka redistilled with botanicals and pink peppercorn):
Very floral and smooth. I don't usually like gin, but I enjoyed this. ($34.99/750 mL, which is $0.05/mL)
* Coastal Cocktails (7.5% ABV)
Made using their spirits, these canned, carbonated cocktail options include Grapefruit, Orange Crush, Vodka Cranberry, and Whiskey Lemonade. The AVA Vodka is featured in the vodka cocktails, and the 3-Year High Rye Straight Bourbon Whiskey is in the lemonade cocktail. I love that they're made with real juice! The ABV is low for a "cocktail," which can generally range from 7%-37%. Available at most grocery stores. ($12/355 mL, which is $0.03/mL)
-- Takeaways --
Their spirits are smoother than many, especially those at comparable prices. Lots of pleasant aromas. We also learned a lot, like that the flavor and color comes from charred barrels, which are one time use. We would definitely recommend a tour and tasting!
-- Pandemic Notes --
They have a sign posted that says 6 feet, but with 12 people attending the tour squeezed into the small space, there was no way to social distance. Masks were not required.