Erik Selden
Google
Olive Garden knows how to cook Italian food better.
After seeing the excellent reviews, and hearing about the risotto was prepared tableside in a giant cheese bowl - I was excited to go to Tartufo. The restaurant has an interesting vibe, as it is in an old restored house, had live music, but when you go in only half of the tables were full.
I was immediately disappointed though, when a I learned they only did the tableside risotto on weekdays because their kitchen was understaffed and the chefs didn't have enough time to leave the kitchen to come to our table. The service and waitstaff were average to above average, but you could tell they were understaffed also as the hostess doubled and took our drink order, and our server also doubled as the valet. Not a knock to the staff, they just need to hire more people.
As for the food I got the chef's tasting:
Meatball: Average. The seasoning was pretty good, but the meat was way too dry and didn't taste juicy. It tasted overcooked, and they used a cut of meat that had almost no fat in it. At least it was healthy?
Balsamic Vineargette Salad: No complaints here, I enjoyed this salad.
Pappardelle: Very tasty seasoning, except the noodles were too al dente.
Risotto: I felt the truffle oil overpowered the other flavors, and as the most expensive item on the menu I wouldn't order this again. I was disappointed they were short staffed and couldn't make it tableside as advertised on their website and menu.
Filet: Best item on the menu. They know how to do steaks well, and I really enjoyed this part of the dinner. Perfect medium rare, juicy, had a nice sear on the outside, and salted it just right.
Tiramisu: Excellent, no complaints.
Summary: It's a nice restaurant that had a few bright spots, but it still has a long ways to go. 3/5 stars.