Tasty Bagels

Bagel shop · Bensonhurst

Tasty Bagels

Bagel shop · Bensonhurst

1705 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11214

Highlights

This cash-only gem serves up delicious bagels and classic sandwiches, known for its vibrant rainbow bagels and the mouthwatering pastrami lox.

1705 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11214 Get directions

tastybagelsnyc.com

@eater

"Bensonhurst: Bensonhurst bagel shop Tasty Bagels closed on April 2 after 40 years in business, Brooklyn Paper reports. The bakery announced the closure in a post on social media. No reason was provided for the closure, but a lengthy caption reads, “All good things come to an end.”" - Luke Fortney

NYC Restaurant Closings, April 2023 - Eater NY

View Postcard for Tasty Bagels

@eater

"Tasty Bagels of Bensonhurst held its last day in operation on April 2. Since 1983, the bagel shop was known for being open 364 days a year — with the exception of Christmas." - Emma Orlow

Manhattan Bar Holywater Wants Its Stolen Mermaid Art Back - Eater NY

View Postcard for Tasty Bagels

@eater

"Tasty Bagels is offering free delivery, including to Staten Island, for a variety of menu items like bagels, breakfast sandwiches, heroes, salads, cream cheese, and cold cut packages. Orders can be placed via phone at 718-236-1389 (extension 302), by email at tasty86@gmail.com, or through Instagram direct message. The bagel shop is updating delivery options on Instagram daily." - Carla Vianna, Eater Staff

NYC Bagel Delivery and Coronavirus: 18 Shops Still Open - Eater NY

View Postcard for Tasty Bagels

Jose Castro

SerpAPI

Cash only but worth it. Went in since I was in the neighborhood. Got a beautiful pastrami cured lox on everything with scallion cream cheese. The flavors were amazing not to mention they make sure you get what you pay for. Man I wish someone in Jersey did bagels and lox this good.

John Cruz

SerpAPI

For about 2 years straight I've visited here with out missing a day. Every morning I would get the classic, Bacon egg and cheese with a few modifications here and there. But let me tell you sandwich lovers something. I have looked all over for a good sandwich, and Tasty Bagels is it. I don't mean it's a fancy tik tok "guys you HAVE to try this secret sandwich with a secret sauce", This place offers a nice deli style Brooklyn sandwich. It's good, it's to the point, makes you want to get a bag of chips and a soda and just take a walk around the neighborhood. If you're looking at reviews to try to place, go in, say what's up to the amazing staff and pick something off the menu and enjoy.

diana Johanson

SerpAPI

I use to love going to tasty but lately I don't know. They don't have things. They mess up delivery orders. I get being busy but also listening to people's orders is a thing. I want to keep giving it another try but it might be time to move on and travel to bay ridge. :(

Joe Indrajit Connolly

SerpAPI

Very busy, but the services were fast. I would go here again. Suggestions prepare a list, it will be faster. Inside is small, but line moves quickly.

Addel Moustafa

SerpAPI

Been buying bagels from here for years. Since moving out of Brooklyn, everytime I'm visiting or driving through I always make a stop in to get my bagel fix.

Fred Alluso

SerpAPI

What began as a promising stop for a good bagel was quickly derailed due to the quality of the jalapeno cream cheese. They are using jarred pickled jalapenos which impart too much acidity and then completely overpower both the bagel and the cream cheese. All I tasted was that acrid pickling juice and not the bagel or the cream cheese. On the up side, the coffee was great. I'll give them another try with either no cream cheese or something more traditional.

Ekaterina Zaiva

SerpAPI

OMG!!!!! THE BAGELS THE DO IS MAGICAL!!! They only accepting cash- so be aware of it. But they do have an atm, but if you walking with Apple Pay as I do- you gonna have a problem. Bagel with salmon cream cheese and avocado is to die for!!! Thank you!!!!

J. C.

SerpAPI

Good bagels, nice chew and texture. Sandwiches are full as usual at a deli or bagel store. Go early since they are not open 24hrs and they tend to run out of popular bagel flavors early.

@eater

NYC Restaurant Closings, April 2023 - Eater NY

View Postcard for Tasty Bagels

@eater

"Tasty Bagels of Bensonhurst held its last day in operation on April 2. Since 1983, the bagel shop was known for being open 364 days a year — with the exception of Christmas." - Emma Orlow

Manhattan Bar Holywater Wants Its Stolen Mermaid Art Back - Eater NY

View Postcard for Tasty Bagels

@eater

NYC Bagel Delivery and Coronavirus: 18 Shops Still Open - Eater NY

View Postcard for Tasty Bagels

Jose Castro

SerpAPI

John Cruz

SerpAPI

diana Johanson

SerpAPI

Joe Indrajit Connolly

SerpAPI

Very busy, but the services were fast. I would go here again. Suggestions prepare a list, it will be faster. Inside is small, but line moves quickly.

Addel Moustafa

SerpAPI

Been buying bagels from here for years. Since moving out of Brooklyn, everytime I'm visiting or driving through I always make a stop in to get my bagel fix.

Fred Alluso

SerpAPI

Ekaterina Zaiva

SerpAPI

J. C.

SerpAPI

Good bagels, nice chew and texture. Sandwiches are full as usual at a deli or bagel store. Go early since they are not open 24hrs and they tend to run out of popular bagel flavors early.

Tasty Bagels

Photos

Highlights

Postcards

You might also like