Roberto L
Google
As someone who has dined extensively in Baja California Sur, I walked into Tatanka with high expectations, only to leave deeply disappointed. The evening began with service that can only be described as painfully slow. Even by La Paz standards, the delay was excessive: menus were dropped off and forgotten, and it took over 15 minutes—only after we insisted—for someone to take our order. Throughout the meal, service remained inattentive. We poured our own wine, staff never checked if we needed anything, and the general execution was disorganized. To make matters worse, we could clearly hear someone in the kitchen literally shouting, “I need these plates out to the tables, now!”—a sign of poor coordination behind the scenes that reflected exactly what we experienced at our table.
The only redeeming dish of the night was the Rockefort Oysters—flavorful, well-prepared, and a glimpse of what Tatanka could be if the rest of the menu matched that standard. Unfortunately, everything else fell flat. Entrées and mains arrived out of order, with the main dishes hitting the table before the starters. The tartare of the catch of the day arrived without bread or tostadas until we asked—an amateur oversight for a restaurant in this price range. Worse yet, the tartare itself was bland, dominated by mayonnaise, with fish that tasted neither fresh nor handled with care. It had the unmistakable texture of seafood that has been frozen, thawed, and refrozen. Heavy, unbalanced, and ultimately inedible.
The lobster mac and cheese was equally disappointing—a monotone dish lacking richness, tasting more of shrimp than lobster, with nothing memorable about it. The lobster burger was dry, uninspired, and poorly composed, with the lobster itself indistinguishable under heavy seasoning and limp vegetables, and a bun that was dry and slightly tough. Worst of all, the potato wedges served alongside were soggy, oily, and rancid—like they had been fried in recycled oil. These, too, were left uneaten.
Tatanka positions itself as one of the most expensive restaurants in La Paz, and with such steep prices one expects quality ingredients, thoughtful execution, and attentive service. Instead, what we experienced was mediocre food and inattentive staff—standards far below even the seafood sold from street vendors, which often offer fresher and more satisfying meals at a fraction of the cost.
We decided to dine here based on a glowing recommendation from El Arturito on TikTok, but after our experience it’s hard to believe those endorsements are genuine. What we encountered was a restaurant living off hype rather than delivering on quality. Sadly, for a place with such potential, this was one of the poorest dining experiences I’ve had in La Paz.
Verdict: Not recommended.
