Dave M.
Yelp
After checking out the menu, I was looking forward to try this new venue on Main St. Unfortunately for Tavern On Main it's a swing and a miss. I know they just recently opened, but the first warning sign was an empty establishment on a summer Sunday late morning on Main St. Aside from us there was only one couple at the bar, no one seated in the rest of the place. It'd be easy to let that go in a fairly new place, but all things considered, it's Strike One.
We started by ordering one of their signature drinks, the "Cajun Bloody Mary" and were later told they didn't have the Shrimp or the Andouille Sausage because they were "still frozen" (excuse me?) What I ended up with was an undrinkable $14 Bloody Mary with a lemon (?) and cheap vodka, nothing else. (Note: we were offered a pulled pork slider as a "make up" to the lack luster drinks, to justify the price I guess, not really what we wanted, but ok). Still, that's Strike Two.
The brunch menu looked interesting, but by now I was already suspicious. I ordered the "Short Ribs Benedict", oh boy. The short ribs weren't a problem, but they we're topped with eggs "over easy" (as the menu indicated) which did raise an eyebrow since most traditional Eggs Benedict concoctions are served with poached eggs (my guess is they can't poach an egg). The eggs were horribly undercooked, with runny egg whites (yuck), and the short ribs were smothered in brown gravy, most definitely from a can. Apparently undercooked "eggs over easy" is the norm, as my girlfriend's "Breakfast Burrito Bowl" had the same runny egg whites issue. We assumed it would be served with scrambled eggs, our mistake for not asking. Neither of us could finish our meal, so with that, it was Strike Three.
I'm sure they want to succeed, but when the manager walked by and asked how things were, I said "eh", he just walked away rather than probe my response ... Why even ask me if that's how you manage? They are a far cry from what the menu claims to offer and apparently don't really care. Avoid for now. Plenty of better options on Main St.