Daniel B.
Yelp
Earlier this year, I gave a less than stellar rating to their sister restaurant located in Westmount Square. I'm really pleased to say that our dinner experience at the Monkland branch last Saturday night was a marked improvement.
The Monkland Taverne has a vastly different vibe from the Westmount version. The room is smaller, cozier, and teeming with energy on a Saturday night. Part of the appeal here is that reservations are not accepted. If you arrive before 7pm, you should be fine. We walked right in and were seated immediately.
Service started out very strong as we ordered some wine and appetizers. They gave us a perfectly tailored wine recommendation which we enjoyed with the warm mozzarella appetizer which was nothing short of epic. It's essentially a large ball of fresh cheese on an oversized slice of grilled bread topped with sautéed greens, nuts, and other assorted goodies.
The only misstep of the night was the broccoli and blue cheese with candied pecan appetizer which was drenched in an extremely acidic and tart dressing. I didn't see much blue cheese. More importantly, the dressing on the broccoli was so bright and over-salted that each bite was painful and unpleasant. Usually, I won't say anything, but when the waiter came by to ask if we were enjoying everything, we sheepishly told him that the broccoli was inedible. He didn't hesitate in offering to replace the dish with something else and not charge us for the broccoli which was a nice touch.
As a replacement, we chose the salmon tartare which was served in a nice large portion (as it should be for 24$) on a bed of avocado. I had been disappointed earlier in the year when we ordered this in Westmount and they decided to replace the avocado with cucumber. Unless you're making pickles, cucumber is a lesser vegetable as compared to the avocado. There exists a vegetable hierarchy. If you don't agree, just ask Mandy's about their latest specials. (Spoiler alert: it's a 23 dollar salad)
For mains, my wife had some sort of mushroom pasta which she reported to be amazing. I'll take her word for it as I don't eat mushrooms. I had the burger with extra cheddar for 22$. This is one epic burger, I tell you! Gigantic, meaty, layered with sweet pickles, juicy......I cannot come up with enough apt adjectives. It is a crime that this burger is absent in every well known list of Montreal's best burgers. Mind you, for 22$, it should include some fries, which it does not. Those will run you another 7$ bringing the cheeseburger and fries combo to an impressive 29$ before tax and tip. I suppose this is better than the Westmount chapter where they won't even serve you the burger at all after lunch time. Even at a "fancy" restaurant, a burger and fries shouldn't cost a penny more than 25$ at the upper limit.
As the night wore on, the restaurant quickly reached capacity with a line forming at the door. This coincided with the service and attention from the waiter slowing down. It's wasn't a big deal as we were having a good time. As a whole, you really get a nice neighbourhood vibe at this establishment. The prices are a bit too high, but they aren't suffering one bit for it...at least not on a Saturday night.