Teresa's Cafe and Next Door

FANTASTIC AND UNIQUE MENU - We are so glad we stopped in to give Teresa’s Cafe a try. We absolutely enjoyed everything, and especially the eggplant dish. Thanks for a great meal!

I had been here before with co-workers and enjoyed it so I made a reservation for myself and my husband. Like other reviews noted, since we were a table of 2, we were seated at a tiny table right inside the drafty door. I asked if we could have one of the empty booths and they said no, after 5 PM, they cannot give them to parties of 2. I asked to moved one table over near the wall (further from the door) but no, they had a party coming in later they needed that table for. So, basically the message I received was, even though you are here now, we are more concerned with accommodating others that are coming later? Fine, we agree to take the cold table. I see from other people's reviews, they have had the same experience. Also, like other reviews have posted, we saw 3 people fall coming up the steps in the 1.5 hrs we were there. One went down really hard. This has to be an ongoing issue. The food was good, our server was nice but honestly, the overall experience was lacking given how cold we were as well as the concern we had for those that tripped. A night out is supposed to be an enjoyable experience and it just wasn't. We won't be back any time soon.

Really good local restaurant, with adjacent bar. food was great. Lamb meatball and rabbit loin appetizers were tasty. I had pasta with locally foraged mushrooms, delicious, friend had a tower of ribs. Great selection of local, regional and Belgian beer. De Garre (IYKYK) and Pliny on the same menu... fantastic .

Had a great experience on Saturday night during the Wayne Music Festival. They got us seated outside quickly. Had this very refreshing and tasty dark rum Jamaican drink that was a specialty drink this month. Went with cornmeal and rice flour coated artichoke appetizer that was incredible along with these baby potatoes in butter, salt and parsley...simple and delicious. Went with the classic chicken parm with linguine in a fresh tomato sauce - I loved the panko breading giving the chicken a nice texture and the fresh mozzarella. Great meal!! 😁

If you want consistency and excellent food this is the place to go as they have been killing it for years! Drinks are always excellent and food is quality especially escargot, scallops, steak, salads, and burgers. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 3/8/25 still excellent~~ love this place! 6/5/25-great place to celebrate 53! Monkey 47 yum

Ordered out from here for the first time… so yum! The tiramisu is prob one of the best ive ever had & i got the gnocci & a side of meatballs. Im pretty picky about tomato sauce & meatballs and both were really good. My husband is also picky about his burgers and he loved it from here. For how much i ate id normally feel overstuffed but i love that it isnt giving me the itis like other places that overload with salt. Will definitely order from here again!

Really good food. But they need to fix the step in the entrance to the dining area. My mother took a hard fall after exiting the dining area and we watched another person almost take the same fall right after. There needs to be a sign or reeling.

The food was amazing. The bacon in the BLT was super smokey, the fries and artichokes were phenomenal, my mom's duck sandwich was perfectly cooked-- everything was so nicely seasoned. Solid beer list!! Our server was awesome and Greta at his job.