That's Amore Pizzeria

First time in the restaurant, and on a positive note, we found the food to be good. On the negative, the food was tepid at best, and it took a couple of hours to actually get food. Clearly they were overwhelmed by their success, and will need a great many adjustments to maintain a steady customer base.

Hidden gem right in the middle of Metairie! Absolutely delicious food, quick service with a friendly smile, and generous portions. Easy wheelchair access and parking. Can't ask for much more than those!

Chicago Deep Dish was incredible!! Word to the wise, call ahead of time. This particular pizza will take 45 minutes to bake to perfection!! You can pre-order. Great service too!! The Great Chicago vs. NY debate right at your table!! (Chicago all day for me!!)

We decided to try the deep dish pizza here while running some errands in the area. We got a 7in veggie (it takes 45 minutes and you can pre-order) so we asked the waitress if we could go run another errand and come back. No problem! We returned about 20 minutes later to our table as we left it. The pizza was yummy and SO FILLING. Do not underestimate the size! We also ordered the gumbo, it was thick and delicious, and the sweet potato fries, crispy and not floppy like most establishment. The staff was wonderful and packed up our left overs. She even gave us some cookies before we left! Lovely place and we will return!

We come here often and usually the owner is here. He a super nice guy and usually no problems. However tonight we sat at the bar like usual and 10 min goes by and we had to ask for a menu. The bar tender was rude so I read of the appetizer and drinks we opted to grab a pizza to go. Atmosphere is horrible tonight. However the pizza is usually really good so hopefully the front attitude does not reflect the back tonight

Cool little mom and pop Italian restaurant outside of NOLA. Service and Atmosphere were both great. My one nitpick that I have is the New York style pizza. It was “meh” at best. However the Chicago Deep Dish was to die for. It tasted identical to the real thing!

★★★☆☆ Visited That’s Amore Pizzeria in Maurice, Louisiana on a Friday night while in town for Father’s Day weekend. It was our first time trying the place, and overall, the experience was just okay. Service was mediocre—nobody greeted us with drinks when we sat down, and our server only came by maybe twice the entire time, even though there seemed to be extra staff helping. We ordered the cheese sticks and spinach dip as appetizers, but both were underwhelming. Nothing to brag about—definitely felt like something to skip. My sister wasn’t impressed with her pasta either. Maybe we just ordered the wrong dishes since it’s a pizza spot, but when appetizers and pasta don’t land, it doesn’t inspire much confidence to try again. With so many options out there, especially in surrounding areas, this place just didn’t stand out. Probably wouldn’t return.

I've been meaning to leave a review for a very long time about That's Amore. My wife and I, really our entire family, has been coming here for years. It's gotten to a point where we make it nearly an every two weeks ordeal. The place is lovely. Such a friendly, inviting atmosphere. Darren and Debbie are always friendly and greet every customer and personally tend to them. You can tell they really care about their business. Natale also does a phenomenal job and takes very good care of us when we come to visit. The food is incredible, and we've tried so many items on the menu and haven't been disappointed. I wish I knew all of them by name to give them a shout out. This location in Metairie will always have us as customers.