That's Italian Too

I stopped by this Italian deli and ordered an Italian sub. It was really good — fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with quality ingredients. That said, it was a little different than what I expected. Instead of the traditional lettuce, tomato, (sometimes banana peppers) and oil, it came with chopped tomatoes, white onion, and pickles. Not quite the Italian grinder I grew up eating, but still delicious in its own way. Overall, I’d give it a solid 7 out of 10 — mostly because I can’t help but compare it to the classic version I’m used to. Definitely worth a try if you’re open to a unique take on a classic!

Best Italian sub in the country as far as I’m concerned. Cannot find anything as good anywhere else. The staff is super friendly, feels like home when I go here. Must go if ever in the area!

Great place for sandwiches and deli. Attentive staff. Take out only.

Very impressed of the old school Italian sub made the way I was brought up on! Highly recommend & 10-10!

The best Italian sub I’ve had in all New England. Will be going here a lot more

Been hearing how amazing this place is so I wanted to try it out for myself and wow, I’m impressed. This was by far THE BEST sub I’ve ever had. All of the ingredients used were fresh and delicious. I’m excited to go back again soon!

So , our family absolutely loves That's Italian too . It's our favorite deli. I would have given 5 stars but unfortunately some of the employees either need more training or need to take their job seriously. Unfortunately some of our deli meat was not sliced how we requested it and I was just sold an EXTREMELY stale loaf of French bread( which has never happened before) unfortunately we picked the food up about 30 minutes before closing so by the time I got home, cut the bread and tried to call ( about 3:50) they didn't even answer the phone. We have been shopping here for over 40 years.. I definitely recommend coming here but go order in person instead of calling the order in . Btw always get the scala roll if the have it!!!!

I ordered a meatball sausage with provolone and it was delicious. The only thing I would change is go light on the sauce and ask for a little on the side to add as I ate it.

Old-school and in the best way. I've driven by this place hundreds of times, and I never thought to stop in. But today I did, and I was blown away by how great the subs are. Unlike a lot of sub shops that get overwhelmed with an enormous menu, this place keeps it simple. No pizzas, no appetizers, just subs. The bread is fresh, the meats are fantastic, the toppings are delicious. And, the price is reasonable. There's no place to sit down, and maybe that's a good thing because it's the same setup as another great place a few towns over (Mae's Sandwiches in Marshfield). You pick up your subs and go. This is my new go-to sub place!!!!!

Easy to drive to, has parking. Greeted when you come in the door. The meatball sub was bussin (that means good as hell) so good that I forgot to take a photo, sorry!

Always my favorite place for an Italian. Fast and friendly service. My go to take out when in Weymouth.

The best subs ever. Fresh and delicious. The salads are fresh and made to order. N place is better than That's Italian Too!

Love Thats Italian Too!!! Everyone is so pleasant and helpful. I have been eating at this establishment since the late 80s. Not 1 bad experience!!! Always fresh!!!

Best subs in Weymouth. Amazing roast beef, tuna salad, Italian subs, turkey, meatballs, chicken salad etc.. I have been going here for 24 years and nobody in Weymouth makes a better sub sandwich.

My Italian sandwich was and the Hubbs really enjoyed his chicken salad sub . He said the roll was real fresh! Place is very clean and the staff were really nice when I went in to pick up food

It's an unpolished gem on Whitman Pond, nothing fancy at all. It's a place to order your sub, maybe grab some chips and a bottled drink, the. Wait a very short time for your grinder to emerge from behind the counter, well wrapped and bagged. Staff have always been friendly and informative to me. I've had many different sandwiches here, and they've all been good. The bread is excellent. The meats, cheeses, and dressings seem good. Chip selection and drink variety is okay, not great. Something about the unpretentious vibe of this place makes me like it. Great stop before a picnic.

Pretty basic sandwich shop. No hot sandwich's/subs on the day I was there. I feel like I could go to the supermarket deli and make my own for cheaper. Customer service was decent. Not sure if I'd return.

Food OK. BLT sub reminded me of Subway, a little bacon and lots of veggies. People were super nice & friendly. Prices OK. First visit, big surprise, no tables, only take & go. Parking lot small and narrowly spaced. Ambience basic.

I was leaving Weymouth this morning, so I got an Italian sub last night and had them wrap it for traveling. That means all of the toppings, the onions, the peppers, the oil vinegar, everything, including the seasoning was in a plastic dish with a lid. This thing was absolutely amazing. Awesome job by the crew! Fantastic sandwich. I love going there every time I am home. I ate half of it for lunch somewhere in New York and I just ate the other half for dinner and Roanoke, Virginia.

Love the Chicken in any way it comes~I thought I made the Best Italian Chicken, But this place is #1 in my eyes and the best and freshest Salad!! That's Italian Too!!

Love this deli, they use excellent meats. The roast beef is to die for, so tender, just melts in your mouth. Good price and value for the quality.

Most reviews good or bad are long. - Short and sweet best Italian sub I've had in recent memory. Give it a shot!! Can't wait to go back!

Chicken salad is my go-to every time with a side of marinated mushrooms. Sometimes I'll get some prosciutto or macaroni salad. Everything is very fresh.

Unbelievable get the meatball sub It would take me a book to describe my experience with that's Italian having ordered for Saturday employee lunches for 50 and when I say there was never an issue problem I'm not kidding Awesome service great quality food nothing at all but great things to say!!!

Recently had the meatball sub, which has been consistently great every time I come here. Service is excellent and responsive.

That's Italian Two is one of my favorite sandwich shops! I travel up from the Cape for their Italian on a bulkie. The staff is super friendly and each one makes a great sandwhich. Fresh cold cuts freshly sliced for your sandwich. My husband always gets the roast beef....Uber fresh. Their rolls are always fresh too! Don't hesitate to try them!!!

Once again my turkey with lite cheese, mayo and lettuce is made perfectly. Delicious to the end. Thank you

This was my first and last time at this place for several reasons 1. It's very dark inside. 2. The girl who waited on me was extremely unpleasant "you all set?" And yupped me through my whole order... which was an Italian sub... that's all. 3. When she was done make it she slammed it on the counter. 4. By the time I got home 10 mins later it was completely soggy because of all the pickle juice she poured on the bottom. ( suggestion put the pickles on top so they don't soak the bread. This girl is the main reason for my score she acted like I was causing a huge in convenience by making my sub. It was also completely soggy by the time i got home. Such a disappointment!

First time visit - went with The Wife & adult daughter. Not a disappointment - warmly greeted upon entering, just before lunch. We ordered 3 large subs (Italian, sausage, & pastrami), plus Cole slaw, potato salad, tortellini salad, and a canoli for dessert. Very efficient staff - more than one worked on our order. One slight error - wrong type of bread for one sub, but otherwise well executed order. Flavor: I had the sausage - mild taste, which is how I like my sausages. The provolone cheese melted perfectly on the meat, with a nice sauce. Fresh roll. I would give this review 5 stars for this sub. The Cole Slaw was "eh" - nothing special. Potato salad was above normal, but not amazing. Best was the tortellini salad. The canoli was very good - I split with my daughter, who, after tasting it, wanted the whole thing. I will definitely return to try other subs.

Only place to go for an Italian sub in weymouth, tuna is also so good! Highly recommend!

Entering with a mask, I felt like I did not matter. The person @ the counter, TOLD me "to go stand behind that guy." I felt so bossed around. Not going back. They favor the local working men who run you practicality over to get in the door.

Best Italian sandwich on the South Shore! Super fresh ingredients and the small on a bulkie roll is the perfect size!

Best spot to get a sandwich in Weymouth, friendly staff, been my favorite spot to get lunch for over 15 years!

TGIY because otherwise, I would steer the ol' whip right on past this, what's a nice way to describe the facade, um... Murder shack. Murder shack will do. It's dark, windowless (causation!), lakeside non-murder shack is a deli and drinks counter with an UTZ chips wall that extends in to oblivion, and two yuge pickle jars for good measure. Some guy ordered a salad when I walked in, and one of eight people behind the counter snickered and said, "Grab a salad from the coolah and I'll make it Greek for ya." Needless to say, order a sub. Or a sandwich - the options are a bulkie or a sub roll for a buck or two more. Above all else, heed my words: get. the. sub. Even if you aren't hungry, this 14" piggity-packed torpedo (in my case, the Italian loaded) is easily worth two meals, bringing the price of a one sub, one half sour pickle, one bottle of sodie pop, and one bag of Dirty Potato Chips (Jalapeño Heat ftw) to a paltry $12. That's $6 a meal, or approximately 5 calories per penny. Per cent? Oy. The meat's Thumann's, which my stave off the Boar's Head faithful, but do not judge lest ye and yer liverwurst be judged. My sando was packed with flavor, featured salami, mortadella, pepperoni, gabagool, bippityboppity (halp David Brooks!), and included a healthy portion of hots and sub dressing, which leads me to my second block of words to heed: eat. quickly. My wrappings and paper bag were near disintegration in the fifteen minutes between payment and afternoon delight. Juicy like squirting out the side with each bite juicy? Something like that. Anyway, this deli doesn't win any points for ambiance, but it's a deli not a disco, so grab your sandwich and go. Price, value and flava, it's a total (shudder) hidden gem. And functional murder shack cuz ya hunger is dead.

Eh. Just ok. Ordered a small Italian with everything. It came on a bulkie roll (bummer, but my fault for not reading the menu). Take a drive to EuroMart in Hingham or Tutto Italiano in Hyde Park for a mind-blowing Italian.

My husband and our friends and I came to this deli to grab subs for takeout. They had so many options it was almost overwhelming! They had a long list of subs, with freshly cut meats and cheeses, and several vessel options - hoagie roll, white or wheat wraps, and rolls. In addition, they sold a variety of homemade items such as stuffed peppers and various salads (ham, egg, potato etc). There was a section on the back wall containing individualized bags of chips and sodas to go. I ordered a turkey wrap which was large in size, fresh tasting, and overall delicious. The prices are very reasonable, the employees are accommodating, and the food is fresh and good! There is limited parking available and it is challenging to get in and out of the lot. There is no seating inside so be prepared to grab and go. I recommend getting takeout here if you are craving a sub and are in the vicinity!

I wouldn't normally do this, but this is a severe level of negligence. I nearly chipped a tooth on a special buffalo chicken sandwich today. Two gigantic chicken bones were left in the mix. Tasted decent, but I don't wanna risk dental bills for a decent sandwich.

Ya know man I used to love this place. They used to make huge subs. It was there main goal was to give you a sub worth it. I paid 30 dollars for 3 subs. This is what they serve you now. The new young girls who work here have not a clue what they're doing or what this establishment has stood for. A sub that's worth it. If I wanted a sub full of condiments I would have gone to Maria's sub shop in scituate. I'm sick of it. The older workers always make a great sub but the young kids suck. Straight out. I will not be going back here until someone teaches these newcomers how to make a sub. Stick to your word and make a consistent sub. I get one from the older workers and it's nearly a 10 pound sub stacked with meat. These new kids are garbage. Fix your ways that's italian or lower your prices. I'm not paying 10 bucks a sub for lettuce.

My wife and two friends stopped in here for a take out meal. We had no idea what to expect other than they had some great prices for sandwiches. This place is a small deli that also offers sandwiches. No place to sit inside, but they do have some drinks in a fridge and chips along the wall. I ended up ordering a chicken salad sandwich and our group ordered some stuffed cherry peppers as well. The sandwich was delicious and filling enough. For the price its a very nice deal! The stuffed cherry peppers were solid as well. They were stuffed with cheese and ham and had a little bit of spice to them. Overall a very neat little deli with some tasty sandwiches. I love the price for the quality, simplicity, and quantity given for the sandwiches.

It's a below average, Pizza and sub shop. Nothing really bad but nothing really good either.

Even during a pandemic, they had brisk service and were really welcoming to a first timer. Luckily when I went some people waiting for their own orders helped me decide what to get. I grabbed an Italian sub and it was probably one of the best I've ever had. Soft bread, piled high with meats, lettuce, tomato, pickles and hots, and red wine vinegar. Man, that sandwich was just a perfect blend of salty, sweet, sour, and umami. The value was great too! Definitely go try it if you're in the area. If the patrons are any indication of a place... I felt like everyone I spoke to was so excited for me to try something they love. Just the kind of good vibes and welcoming spirit that we could all use now.

Went here on a road trip, great meatball sub, kids loved it too. Classic hole in the wall.

This is the standard all Italians are held up to. Fresh product, pleasant and fast service. This is a true gem for an awesome sub!

Best subs in Weymouth. No competition If you like a nice Italian sub stuffed with everything this is your place. Never skimps on the deli meats

One of the best Italian subs I have ever had . OMG you have to have one . nice big subs just about over stuffed with Tomato ,onion and pickles and hots !

Wow. Been a customer for 20 plus yrs. Always recommended to everyone how good their subs were. But today when I picked up my ham and cheese sub with mayo I noticed it was light in weight. When I got home and unwrapped it it literally had less than. 2 Oz of ham and no mayo!! Really disappointing, maybe they were having a bad day or like some reviewers have said things have changed and not for the better

Best Italian sub!! And very friendly. This is where the locals go. They also have the big pickles we all love

I rather go to d'anglos than here. Sub was nasty over did with the hots and dressing. The bread was blah. Order it to go and my sandwich was soggy.

Arrogance at it's finest Been to this place twice before, first visit i got a roast beef sub and it was actually really good but the second time i came in, i was ordering my sub from an older man and when i left the store i realized he got my order wrong. So before i even took a bite i took the sub back and asked if he could add the remaining missing ingredients i ordered, to my sub. The old man reacted in a way you would've thought i accused him of murder, he then started raging about how he got my order right and threw my sub into the trash can and told me to get out. I didn't even give him the time of day to be as negative so i told him to have a good day and walked out... Safe to say I won't be coming back to this classless establishment.

My favorite sub shop of all time. I grew up in Dorchester and know of many good places. I have never had anything that wasn't amazing here and getting food catered from this spot is a good move. Nice people fast service. Go there.

After searching high and low for the very best Italian sub on the south shore, I have found it. Every sandwich I have ever got from here is consistently perfect, and service is always friendly and fast, even during the lunchtime rush. I don't live in Weymouth anymore, but I will make a special trip just for a good sub.

Stopped in here last weekend on a whim and looking for a great sub. To our delight and surprise, That's Italian Too did not disappoint. The subs were tasty, fresh and not at all expensive. Their menu is large and I can't wait to go back.

10/10 would recommended to anyone in the nearby area. Picked up subs for my friends and I, a turkey sub, pastrami, meatball and an Italian...all of which get 5 stars from us!! Everyone was very happy eating these subs beach side. And everyone working was extremely nice and very efficient!!

Best meat and sandwiches ever!! No Msg and everything at a great price !! Delicious Italian and prosciutto sandwiches!

I have had the Italian sub on a bulkie roll, was pretty good plenty of meat. today I had the ham and swiss. loaded with meat and very good. i am very picky about my sandwiches so I have to make two minor gripes, the ham was not the best quality, it was boiled ham, and for some strange reason they put the lettuce and tomato on the bottom part of the roll under the meat. this is my go to sandwich place for now,. can't go wrong. will be trying the corn beef and swiss on dark rye soon. Oopppps, went back and noticed they have baked ham too

I'm a sucker for a great sandwich. Something about a tasty sub bring back childhood memories of going to the corner deli and getting a sub with everything tasty on it. Now the search for a great sub in Weymouth is over. They place is small but easy to get to. Plenty of parking (small lot but never filled up), and everyone that works there is very attentive. Fresh cut meats, Utz potato chips (Salt & Pepper chips are ridic), and plenty of choices for sides and drinks. The owner is a great guy that always seems to be working the register and is very appreciative. If you're getting a sandwich at Subway and know that this place is just down the road, you shall be flogged. Stop in here and don't be disappointed.

This place is terrible. Awful costumer service they were rude slow and didnt ask me for my order for 5 minutes. And when i did finally get the food i found chicken bones in my sub.