The Amish at Columbus Market

The place is amazing. Even the parking lot is filled with the sweet scents of bakery.. You get inside and you face the DONUTS 🍩🍩, pastries, all the varieties of breads, pies, cookies, you name it. They are all fresh and warm, just made. I recommend this market to everyone. We drove 2 hours to go there, all worth It. In the summer i want to visit green dragon farmers market

OMG! Their BBQ Wings are amazing! My wife had the BEEF BRISKET, AMAZING! Defintely recommend them, definitely worth waiting in line, baked goods are amazing! Oh, don’t forgot the Pepperoni pretzels! 6 Stars!!!

Donuts are amazing , blueberry fritter was okay it was dry for me, soft pretzels are sooo delicious! Pecan caramel chocolate are good but pretty pricey. Love the dairy products , cheesecake strawberry was delicious

Incredible food of all kinds to take home or eat there! Can easily spend too much because everything looks and smells sooo good. Friendly service at every counter. You'll go back again and again!

My second time I’m here. I don’t know what happened to my first review. I drive over an hour to get here when I do go to New Jersey. The donuts are really filled and are large. I got 2 dozen this time. Pickles are a winner. They are opened Thursday, Friday Saturday. But check to make sure because you would think they were open longer. Definitely worth the trip here.

This is a nice market. They serve hot food and to order sandwiches. They have a large variety of meats and salads plus so much homemade items. It gets very busy and they are only open certain days. They are worth checking out.

Amish Market is hands down one of the best places I’ve ever visited for baked goods. Their bakery section is absolutely outstanding—everything from their soft, fresh breads to their rich, fluffy donuts is made with such care and quality that you can taste it in every bite. The variety is impressive, whether you’re in the mood for something simple and comforting or a little more indulgent. You can tell they use fresh ingredients, and nothing ever tastes mass-produced. It’s the kind of place where you’ll want to bring something home each time you stop by. If you love bakery products, Amish Market is a must-visit.

Great chicken parmesean meatballs frozen . ADD YOUR Own sauce homemade and Viola!! Delicious

I been coming here every since I wad 5 years old. Now I'm 25 plus more years lol. Which is a long time. Especially the Amish place. Omg Chicken coop too. But they are really expensive.. those jo jo are delicious.

Sugar-Coated Raspberry Jelly - The raspberry jelly has a wonderful, sweet flavor, and every bite is filled with it. I usually complain that jelly donuts never have enough filling, but this one might actually have a bit too much. Boston Custard - The rich chocolate icing paired with the smooth custard filling is a perfect combination. Toasted Coconut Ring - I liked trying a donut without a custard or cream filling. It's topped with chocolate and toasted coconut, but unfortunately the chocolate is so rich that it overpowers the coconut--I could barely taste it. Toasted Coconut Custard-Filled - A great choice for anyone who loves coconut and the classic custard filling of a Boston Cream donut. It's packed with filling and very heavy--definitely not something to eat in one sitting!

I used to come here every weekend years ago and since I was coming from the New York area, I knew this was on my way home so I changed my direction in my GPS and instead of heading home, I headed to my favorite place. Some things have changed in there. It was very crowded as usual. They have great little kiosk in there with baked goods candies pickles donuts you name it! I saw that they had a place where you can get tomato pie! I just didn't have any more bags or money to try it but I will the next time I come because I will make it have to maybe come here at least once a month and if you don't know, get to Stoltzfus BBQ! The line is still wrapped around the place people will wait in line for at least 20 to 25 minutes to get barbecue from this place. They have chicken sausages, ribs, When I tell you, you won't be disappointed. great barbecue! They offer different sizes in their sizes are OK. Yesterday I tried their coleslaw for the first time and I did not like it. The lemonade is good. FYI, you can call ahead before you get there and pick up your barbecue without having to wait in line. Overall, this place is awesome. bring bags, pack patience and wear comfy shoes!! You definitely will leave with some great items and across the parking lot they have a place with produce. you can buy plants also. Enjoy

I was walking around and looking for a place to eat when I saw that this place sold pumpkin spice frappe. Daughter and I liked it a lot and she said that it was one of the best ones that she's ever had. Service was friendly and quick. Will return when in the neighborhood to try other items on the menu.

To each their own, this place isn't for everyone lol. Some people love it, some people hate it. But They have EVERYTHING YOU NEED in one spot. I've been coming here my whole life. I go for the Amish Donuts and pretzels, the fresh produce across the way and the flowers in the back. I recently bought a dress for a wedding from here too!!!

This was a very cool spot. I didn't get to get the full experience due to visiting on Good Friday however I did get to stop by a few shops and snag some cool items for great prices. I was shocked to see some name brands for such reasonable prices, from Bath & Body works to makeup brands you love. You never know what you'll find here. They also have some great produce if you live nearby and enjoy fresh fruits and vegetables.

High prices some product okay clearly not real farm market. Some fruits, plums are crap. And its hard to fiquire price per lb to see if so called deal okay

Come for the farmers market - stay for the Amish goods. My friend and I made a trip down here early on a Saturday. It does get really packed, but I'd say there's always a parking unit if it's a little farther away. We came mainly for the Amish market and it did not disappoint. We live farther away, so we didn't think about bringing a cooler, but honestly, they have such great deli selections and meat selections that I would think about bringing one in the future. Their barbecue section is unreal. I ended up getting it barbecue chicken sandwich to try and it was delicious. The pickles are to die for. I got two huge containers of them and will be slowly crying as I eat the last of them. The bakery section itself is insane - they have everything from cookies to croissants to biscuits to bread to pies. It's dangerous. The showstopper here quite honestly is the pretzels. I didn't think an Amish pretzel would be the highlight of my day, but I was wrong. They have regular, but they have these stuffed pretzels that are ridiculously good. I got stuffed with ham and mozzarella cheese and it was great even the next day. Just warmed up in the microwave for a couple seconds. The quality of their food really shows especially their meat quality. It's worth making a day trip over here to come and check out the shops and hit this market. Don't forget to take a wander around their candy section. It's insane.

I didn't get the outdoor farmers market experience because it was later in the day but some of the shops inside are pretty cool (the candy store and sports store was great, the expired grocery store was pretty gross). Definitely an experience though!

Every-time we come we witness people with dogs of all sizes walking on the black asphalt burning their paws. Today it is 93 degrees out. A small dog was yelping and hopping up and down lifting each paw begging the owner to lift it. IF YOU CANNOT WALK BAREFOOT because the ground is too hot - then it is TOO HOT for your dogs. The market should NOT ALLOW DOGS due to owner neglect time and time again. I am pretty sick to my stomach over this. And yes I have and did today tell the owners: too hot - pick up the dog...but I am unsure if they understand. I have motioned the same and they just stare at you.

Everything sold in the market is amazing. Breakfast is good the bakery is fabulous their homemade pot pies are excellent. It's worth the trip there

Used to come here long long time ago. I was shocked they were even still around. They have some cool stores and the typical vendors as you'd see at a flea market-like place. But have great food throughout.

The market was huge both indoors and outdoors and offered a variety of options for consumers. A bit outdated but for the most part a place everyone should visit. We enjoyed the Tomato Pie the most.

the food, fresh, raw, cooked, etc is all just mouthwatering and perfectly priced. atmosphere is pleasant and staff is extremely friendly and knowledgeable.

Has so many different items to choose from, such as food, clothes, furniture, carpet and many more. The different bakery items are fantastic.

Todo con las 3 b, bueno bonito y barato .se las recomiendo me gustaria hir a vender. Frutas a esa flea market .

Variety of specialty shops and restaurants. Great prices on produce! Variety of Amish style foods to eat there or buy in bulk to make at home. When we went there wasn't any outside vendors however inside there were enough to make it worth the trip. Hubby and I ate at a Amish restaurant, we ordered at the counter and took the food to a common eating area. We both ordered the ham/bean soup! Actually the small was enough for a meal because it was so hearty! Hubby also ate the bbq chicken sandwich which he thought was tasty! I had a piece of beef sausage which was delicious!!

This is the best find in the area. My boyfriend and family members told me about this market (specifically the Amish market) but I didn't understand the hype until I was there. Amazingly fresh and delicious options. I've already brought my sister, best friend and goddaughters here (and I live in north jersey). I will continuously come back and go out of my way to come back! Love Columbus' market.

Exceptional market with great stores, nice people, and amazing food. The bakeries are exceptional and it offers many different small business which you need to check out!

First off , if you want to rent an outside table , the older guy who collects the money at the gate is not only rude but you can always count on him making a rude or even a nasty comment, Not only that but he is also a very cocky, a bully and he thinks he is above everyone and is quick to ban you from the flea market. Unfortunately its impossible to find his superior or anyone at all for that matter, to complain to. So potential vendors beware...

It's always a nice sized crowd. Bayure Herbs is my destination. From Seamoss, Bladderwrack, burdock, dandelion, and soursop, if you need it, he has it. Truly nature's best. There are so many wonderful stores inside and deals on the outside. I've been going to Columbus for years, and now I take my children every weekend. Go find your hidden jewel or set up a table.

This is on our recent village to the Amish market. There's one girl behind the counter that has no clue what the foods are. We ordered chicken breast. We got chicken legs we ordered baby back ribs. We got regular ribs which we don't like. Came all the way home a 2 Hour Dr. with this crap threw it out. Watch what they're packing you.

this place really has gone downhill. trash is everywhere all the time, selling fake products, selling expired and improperly stored food. the "vintage" vendors leave before noon and leave behind the things that aren't even worth trying to sell again in garbage cans. the produce market re-sells costco groceries and has things that need refrigerated baking in the sun, and the refrigerated items are moldy.

[1114] 10/2020 This Market has tons of parking and is easy to find. I visited this place years ago and really enjoyed the variety of shops. There are indoor shops which get crowded fast and TONS of outside shops. Some under an awning and some out in the fresh air. We found some good deals. Plenty of friendly people. We had tasty Chinese food. I'll definitely be back. Early in the day because it can get busy.

Lots of great things to see and good food to sample, biggest con is that it's outside and very cold ... bring your winter jacket and gloves!

Love the Columbus flea market. Place is huge with lots of vendors and plenty of bargains. Love to walk around and spend hours there.

If for nothing else, go for Kate and Als pizza and the amish bakery. Spent only $42 and has baked goods for days. The boston cream donuts are ridiculously filled not like supermarket doughnuts. Both pizza and amish food mart are cash only.

It's nice shopping in a casual, friendly atmosphere. The Amish Market has the best food and baked goods you can find near the joint base. Some good and less costly options various ethnic cuisines and mom and pop stores for home goods, car and recreational activities.

Wow, what a selection of all types of food, everything from Amish desserts, Butcher shops, shakes, pizza, fried chicken, potato wedges (jojo), Korean, Chinese, Smoked BBQ meats. I really think you need about 5 days just to try most of the good stuff here. In addition you can find various knick nacks as well as antique furniture. The food portions are generally large and very good value. The fried chicken and Jojos at Chicken Coop wasn't as crunchy as I hoped but its still very tasty. You can buy the chicken and sit at the Chicken Coop Cafe right next to it. Mac and cheese was very good although you need to add your own salt and pepper to taste.

Columbus Market is huge! Organized chaos is the perfect description. So many indoor and outdoor vendors. The quality of the new products being sold in the outdoor flea market isn't exactly high end but then again that's not what a flea market is for. A lot of counterfeit brands being sold too. They defintely have whatever you can imagine - clothes, accessories, tools, toys, electronics etc. Inside there are so many types of food being sold to satisfy every palate. I love everything the Amish people make. It's so fresh. Plus there's seafood, Mexican food, soul food, candy and snacks etc... You name it. Can't forget the cbd shop inside. Overall it's a fun experience if you don't mind crowds.

As farmers markets go, I drive a longer way to get to this one. It's worth it. Gets busy inside on the weekends. Still worth going.

What? It was entertaining, sheesh. OK, wish I thought and realized ahead of time that coming on a Sunday would mean missing out on all the Amish stuff. I came early, just after 9 AM, to avoid the heat. Parking was easy, no big crowds, and I was outta there pretty fast. This is a classic flea and indoor market. Don't come here unless you are OK with seeing 5 different vendors all claiming to be selling genuine bamboo pillows at 5 different locations. Lots of junk, oh my god, so much junk and crappily made things, but half the fun is making fun of the junk. A fellow Elite told me to not miss the shish ka bobs sold in the parking lot, so I grabbed one to try. To be honest, I wasn't that impressed, but that was just me. Perhaps should've grabbed the beef instead of the pork version. The lemonade was pretty weak but hit the spot to cool off on a hot day.

Great farmer's market! We've found really great deals on plums, peaches, and other fruits here. They also have a fantastic Amish market with many different stations, including a pickles station. I usually will eat pickles, but I don't love them. However, I absolutely love their red hot pickles and can't wait to be back for more and to try their other pickle flavors. Their cheeses and crab dip are also delicious. We went for the first time in October on a weekend and although everyone was wearing a mask, it was still very crowded, so we haven't been back since. We do hope to return to the Amish market again at some point next year though!

Went here for the first time a few years ago and had a pretty bad experience. Vendors were overly pushy and one even moved racks around to block off the door so I couldn't leave with my baby in her stroller. Went again a few times more recently and had a much better experience.

This is probably my favorite place to go when I'm stressed out and just spend $600-$700 on some stuff that's gonna make me happy. I always bring at least $1000 with me, because there are a lot of great people there. One of my favorite places in the entire world I have been there at least 100 times probably much more since I was a kid and I am in my late 40s now The last time I was there I was buying some old baseball cards off of this really nice seller. I noticed that the seller next to him that sold swords just happen to have an antique Turkish/ottoman saber. I am a history major, and I have noticed some markings on the sword that we're dating and recording which battle it was used in. So I asked the overweight, sweaty, illiterate dealer, if he knew he had an authentic museum, peace saber. He leans over to me and says, "I am very busy, I don't have time for nonsense and play!" if he knew I had $1000 on me and I was interested in this sword he would've been nice. But when he just saw I looked like I was a kid that probably didn't have any money. I am in my late 40s but I look like I'm in my 20s so people like him mistake lol me for a broke kid rather than a man, that has been buying and selling everything since I was 17 and maybe earlier. I called a dealer I know in Philadelphia and told him about the saber. He rushed over to Columbus flea market as fast as he could, and brought the saber for $17. Now usually if we find a big money item really cheap, we give the original owner 30% as long as 30% reaches $100 or more, If not, we just give them a $100 bill. This is to create a relationship with someone so if they do get something else good he will call us first. We got the saber appraised at $20,000. We sold it to a local collector for $17,550. That means that the sword dealer was to receive $3510 but he was nothing but rude. So we went together the following week and asked him if he had any more Turkish/ottoman sabers because we just sold the one we bought from him for $17,550. We even bought a video on my phone showing us handing over the sword and receiving all that money in cash! He was so angry, but we were so satisfied. That was one of my best days of Columbus flea market. Always remember manners well get you everywhere and rudeness is never acceptable especially in sales. It lost him over $3000 and every time we have been there since we just stand there and look at him until he notices us and loses his mind with anger while we laugh like we're watching an overweight, rude, ignorant man, try to sell $20 swords, to the public as decorations. He blew his one big shot by being a jerk.........

Overall everything about this place is amazing expect Roman Jewelers! The most racists people I ever met. In the sign it say we sell Gold, silver and diamond. I was trying to sell something Diamond he said no we don't sell that. Then my mom ask I have some gold jewelry. The lady said NO and just ignore her and walk away. Just because she was wearing hijab (head covering) we try get the man he kept saying no we don't sell. Why not just say we don't sell or buy from MUSLIMS. The other lady kept walking and help someone else who came behind us. I never ever seen this but this place is disgusting. You definitely lost customers. They don't like Muslims or any hijab is! May God punish you all! Have to rate you but ur definitely worth -0

Absolute must see if you're near central Jersey. The Amish market has a variety of stations from fresh baked goods (donuts, cakes, breads, prepared where you can see), a cold cuts section, a hot buffet bar section, a breakfast spot, and chocolate & candy station to name a few. People rave about their Lemonade and bakery items. This is only in the Amish section, if you continue through the warehouse there is so much more! Vendors galore! From a pet store to food vendors, to collectors stations its all great fun. NOTE: Amish market is closed on Sundays. During the summer the place triples in size with the outdoor flea market which attracts hundreds of great vendors and good finds. You will have a great time listening to music, meeting interesting people, and trying new foods.

Love this place for the pizza, the low prices, the good produce and the atmosphere. The people are so nice. You can literally come here to find anything you want/need. I've been coming here for as long as i can remember.

Trash everywhere, getting hit in the legs with garbage as we are walking through the flea market. The vendors are throwing trash on the ground and it is seen consistently through the various piles of garbage. They clearly do not care about the environment as trash flies over the fence into the surrounding area. Vendors also selling illegal items. Very dirty and sketchy market. Will not ever be going back

I love this place so much that I don't even know where to start with the review. The mix of vendors is awesome. The food is awesome. But my favorite part is probably the overall weirdness. We saw a guy pushing a cart full of pet skunks a few weeks ago.I'll leave it at that...

A wide assortment of deli meats/cheeses, butcher area, bakery, candy etc. You'll definitely find something for yourself here! I frequent here weekly. Highly suggest the deli counter with the barrels of pickles. Half sours are the best there in my opinion (although pricey). Bakery area is to be desired. Everything kind of tastes the same with similar mushy textures. A lot of the time they're selling the frozen donuts just thawed out, no bueno! The BBQ area is always filled with an insane line, so probably safe to say it's relatively good, but have not tried that myself. They have a wood and house area with home decor and small handmade wooden furniture pieces as well. Open Thursday-Saturday

Nice Market, alot of stuff, ample parking, both indoor and outdoor vendors, nice way to spend a Saturday

There's a hidden gem in Columbus, NJ and it's Delaware Valley's oldest and largest flea market called Columbus Farmers Market. Inside this market, you'll find the most incredible and talented Amish food vendors that can prepare amazing, hot food like their killer baby back ribs, veggies and mac & cheese. This is also my go-to Amish dessert place when I'm unable to head towards Reading Terminal Market in Philadelphia where, I may add, is also a hot spot for Amish baked goods! You must see their freshly baked goods and the chocolate shop! There are lots of things to see both inside and outside the market. I can easily spend half the day here especially during the summer time where all the veggies and fruits are out on display!

Many food products out of date, past expiration date & still being sold. Breaking the law & people's confidence in shopping here no longer trusted

Exciting and huge. We tried Louis Hoagie Shop... this place could be a good mine. It's filthy and the food is really bad. We thought it would be like the Reading Terminal in Philly but it was so bad. Looking forward to going back & trying some Mexican

If you are a collector : THIS is a REAL FLEA MARKET with something for EVERY TASTE ! It's BIG ! Come on a nice SUNDAY with LOTS of cash and a hand truck -- you're gonna go home with a LOT of stuff !! Just DO NOT come here with NON-FLEA market people because they will NAG you to leave before you have looked at everything! YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED. This is FIVE STARS and ... the food choices here are also good ! Oh, and they sell POT as well here for your stoner friends.

Columbus is always a great place to find a good deal, grab a bite to eat, and walk around. We love walking around looking at the different vendors and foods, great place to walk off all that great food. I've been coming to Columbus for most of my life and it hasn't changed. We'll definitely come back, for the great deals, good foods, and amazing people.

Outside various areas with good produce & a lot of variety of clothing & accessories. Amish section opened on weekend!

Love this place. We come here at least once a month. On Saturdays the Amish Market is open. They have amazing food. We never leave the place without buying something from the vendors.