Rowan L.
Yelp
Found this place on Yelp and though we'd go there for a cocktail after eating at a nearby restaurant. Right across the steer from Taste, another good restaurant so I'm familiar with the area.
From the street it seemed a bit meh, but hey, we decided to give it a shot. And we're glad we did. The decor and vibe is pleasant, kinda speakeasy style in an unpretentious way, with upbeat and fun music playing, but not so loud you have to yell or even talk very loudly. It's small but there was one table left, so we snagged that.
The bartenders are also the waiters, and in our case the gentleman was there quite quickly, was immediately very friendly, and he was clearly very knowledgeable about their extensive menu of whiskies and cocktails.
We ordered two cocktails and a beer. The beer was a Kolsch, which is a very good crisp German beer served in the proper German glass style (I've been to Germany many times, so I was impressed by the attention to detail). One cocktail ordered by my friend was the Tootsie Roll. I expected a sickly sweet milky chocolate kind of thing which i would not like, but it was more like a 1920's cocktail and was actually not too sweet and nothing like what I expected (in a good way) other than it did taste like a Tootsie Roll but had the kinda old school punch of a cocktail made with simple, quality ingredients. The other cocktail, a BoB (Boubon on Bourbon) was their twist on a Old Fashioned, and was excellent. My only very minor niggle was I prefer Old Fashioned cocktails to have a piece of orange peel in the drink, which this did not have. The menu stated that it had flamed orange peel but I could not taste it (when done right, the orange peel being flamed spits a tiny amount of orange peel oil on the glass rim which tastes great - couldn't taste it here so I'm making an assumption it might have been an error). Having said that, it was still an excellent drink which I enjoyed very much so only take that as a niggle and nothing more. I'm sure I could have spoken up and it would have been dealt with but the three of us were having such a good conversation I didn't want to interrupt the flow.
So, the key question - would I go back? Hell yes. I see me going there again for sure.
I rated it 4 stars (if I could do 4.5 I would) only because of the BoB mentioned above. I will go back and update this review. My hunch is it will be updated to 5 stars. Enjoy!