Rachelle B.
Yelp
Finally tried here for lunch on a sunny Tuesday in January, on the recommendation of a work friend. Very happy with the decision! I had looked at their menu online before, which changes daily. This visit was spur of the moment so I didn't have a chance to look in advance at the food options. It didn't matter, because they apparently always have at least one vegetarian option (for those like me). The first thing I noticed when entering the door, was a cute knife, fork & spoon actually set into the cement step. This property used to be an old garage years ago, converted into the restaurant, and they added a further extension to the outside for more seating. There are still a couple of garage doors left in place for atmosphere. Natural, bright lighting in the windowed exterior section, with a cozier, darker interior dining area. Probably 15-20 tables in total with capacity for 40 or 50? Chalk menu boards all over the place. Casual, modern style with lots of wood, bare light bulbs, industrial metal items such as a little robot by the kitchen, topped off with a Boba Fett helmet atop a coat rack. Definite conversation pieces to say the least. The Smoked Tofu sandwich (house smoked tofu, shiitake mushrooms, roasted carrot hummus, greens & sprouts, Boulangerie La Vendeenne focaccia. $11) was delicious. The bun was soft, the tofu had a bit of crunch to it for texture, and the flavors perfectly complemented each other. The portion size was good as well, not huge, not small. A side of triple cooked chips ($3) were great, sliced as wedges and are already one of my favorite 'fries' in the city. Apparently the Brooklyn Burger (6 oz. Nova Scotian ground beef, Brother's smoked back bacon, PEI old cheddar white bun, St. Ambroise beer mustard-mayo, pickle) was excellent as well. The mustard-mayo is served on the side and I ended up dipping my chips in it, instead of it making it onto the intended burger. Service was very friendly and prompt enough where you could probably squeeze in lunch here in half an hour if you work within a few blocks. Luckily, we had the hour so didn't have to rush.
Have been back probably a dozen times since and it's consistently good. The daily lunch cup of soup ($6) that I tried was some kind of pureed carrot miso with crunchy bacon pieces and was delicious. The Waldorf salad (lettuce, roasted apples, shaved fennel, yogurt dressing, pickled grapes, walnuts. $11.25) was fresh and plentiful to the point where I couldn't finish it after just my cup of soup prior. My friend had the Meatloaf sandwich (12.75 Oulton's pork & beef, smoked tomato glaze, PEI old cheddar, sauerkraut, Thousand Island sauce, caramelized onion focaccia) and said it was delicious with tons of flavor. The potato wedges are always very hot and delicious. The Fried Chicken (buttermilk brined chicken breast, honey butter glaze, pepperoncini slaw, lettuce, roasted garlic aioli on a stone hearth bun. 12.75) was very good with lots of flavor, quite large with almost two small breasts. The bun started to fall apart while I was eating it, so if you don't like messy food, you may not like this, but overall was enjoyable. Their Halloumi Hero wasn't bad (seared halloumi cheese, grilled zucchini, chichurri marinated crushed chickpeas on a toasted baguette. $12.50) - it was filling and flavorful, just not my favorite thing on the menu. The Market Cobb salad is pretty good (for a salad...lol) with confit chicken, Oulton's bacon, hard boiled egg, local cheese, market veggies. $16) - mine had green beans, a mixed of greens and beets, with parm substituted for the blue cheese, at the mention of the server, which I appreciated. The house salad another day ('shaved root vegetables, marinated kale, house made crack pepper ricotta, toasted pumpkin seeds, maple sumac vinaigrette' $11.50 according to the menu) was quite good, lots of flavor, light yet satisfying.
I'll continue eating here anytime for lunch or supper. Wish they had breakfast!!!!