Richard W.
Yelp
THE BUCKINGHAM CLUB AND HOTEL, OUR NEW "SECRET WEAPON"
I have contemplated pulling the trigger on a stay at this property for our last six or seven trips downtown. I just never could bring myself to do it. It just seemed too "upscale" to be available for the prices that were being offered on the travel sites. There simply HAD to be something wrong, some dark secret.
I finally did it during this trip. I booked a room with BC&H for our second night downtown...mostly because I did not initially know that there would be a second night until after I had already booked the first night elsewhere and then could not figure out how to easily add a second night at the same rate...after I had decided there would be a second night.
Confused? Good! I am not sure that I should be writing this review anyway. If you take me at word, I'll likely be competing with you for future bookings because, spoiler alert, I DO plan future bookings!
Before I see if I have enough words left to editorialize on a topic that is "germane but tangential", let me first get to the actual review.
There are six primary reasons that we will stay again at BC&H, assuming that the rate continues to be inexplicably low. The first five are: view, View, VIew, VIEw, VIEW, VIEW!!! Come on! We ALL love to look at Chicago from the upper floor of a "skyscraper". Why else would we pay the ridiculous prices and stand in the long lines to pack the Lounge on the 96th floor of the JHC! Chicago is a pretty city. Imagine if you could have that sort of view from your own, private room?! If we did not have reservations at some great restaurants and the need to eat, we would have never left the room! We didn't even have a "good" view! We were facing south. Great view of the LaSalle Station Metra tracks directly below us! Though Shedd and Adler were visible to the left. Nonetheless, still breathtaking, especially at night!
The sixth reason is the aforementioned Metra LaSalle Station. That is where we enter town when we are being responsible and using PT. How convenient is it to be able to take your bags about 500 feet from your train to your hotel? No humping them to hale a cab. No trying to force them into the El! Clearly, if you are not riding the Rock Island, this is not quite as germane to you.
There are other reasons to stay. The room was spacious. The bathroom was almost palatial in hotel room terms. The bed was reasonably comfortable, though that is obviously subjective. Oh, yeah, and the view was great!
So, what might be viewed as "less than ideal" at BC&H? It is staffed in a bizarre though perfectly understandable way. Most of the day there is nobody at the desk. However, there is (probably) always a person at the adjoining building security desk and he/she can and will page a person to come to the hotel desk. In our experience, it was a pretty quick turnaround. However, if you are going to have need for a concierge (not sure that they even have one) or even just friendly advice, this is probably going to be annoying. I cannot comment about room or other services requiring a staff but I am guessing from what I saw (and from reading some other reviews) that BC&H will not be your ideal definition of a "full service hotel"...but did I mention the view? Since we live "in" Chicago and we come downtown largely to eat, we really don't require any of these services.
We did experience one "unacceptable" outage at BC&H. It involved bag check. Our bags were left sitting in plane view in the lobby of the building all day after our checkout. Granted, they were left against a wall that was "behind" the desk area. Though, it is relatively easy to walk behind the desk area since it sits pretty far from the wall. (Though,) maybe the building security person would not allow this since (, "granted",) the desk area (at least for the building itself) is, theoretically, staffed all day long...bathroom breaks? Excuses aside, checked bags should be...well...checked!
Conversely, this service seemed to operate more conventionally at our check in. We transferred from our first night property to BC&H before check in time. The desk person would not check to see if a room was open despite our early arrival (maybe 1:15-1:30pm with a 2pm check in being stated). This is something that most places WILL do in our experience but maybe she knew that it was not an option. Nonetheless, we were able to check our bags and they were duly squirreled away, presumably somewhere behind lock and key. They were at least not visible and had to be retrieved from somewhere unseen before we went to our room.
In short, we really enjoyed our stay at BC&H and we will definitely use it again. In fact, my constant companion has already proposed that it become sort of our "standard" place and has looked to see what the rate would be when we come down to C2E2 in April, a Christmas present from her to me! Yeah. We're also dorks. So what of it! :)
So, sorry, no space to cover "germane but tangential"!