The Butcher Shop

Steak house · San Diego

The Butcher Shop

Steak house · San Diego

3

5255 Kearny Villa Rd, San Diego, CA 92123

Photos

The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by Yelp
The Butcher Shop by Yelp
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null
The Butcher Shop by null

Highlights

Classic Chicago steakhouse with retro vibe, prime rib  

Featured in Eater
Placeholder

5255 Kearny Villa Rd, San Diego, CA 92123 Get directions

butchershopsandiego.com

$50–100 · Menu

Reserve

Information

Static Map

5255 Kearny Villa Rd, San Diego, CA 92123 Get directions

+1 858 565 2272
butchershopsandiego.com

$50–100 · Menu

Reserve

Features

payment credit card
Tap to pay
reservations

Last updated

Aug 15, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

Where to Feast on Steak in San Diego | Eater San Diego

"This traditional steakhouse has been around for decades with its leather banquettes, dark wooden bar, and photos of Rat Pack stars on the walls. Regulars know the prime rib is the star, whether in a sandwich or an entrée. For sharing, turn to the tomahawk steak, which easily feeds two paired with a side like duck fat fries." - Helen I. Hwang

https://sandiego.eater.com/maps/best-steakhouse-restaurants-bar-san-diego
View Postcard for The Butcher Shop
@eater

Where to Eat Steak in San Diego

"When one walks through the doors of this old-school restaurant, serenaded by 1950’s hits and enveloped into the dark interior, it feels like a step back into time. This classic Chicago-style steakhouse is perfect for both a decadent family meal or a special night out. Regulars know the prime rib is the thing to order." - Jackie Bryant

https://sandiego.eater.com/maps/here-are-10-iconic-san-diego-steakhouses-to-try
View Postcard for The Butcher Shop
@eater

Where to Eat Steak in San Diego

"When one walks through the doors of this old-school restaurant, serenaded by 1950’s hits and enveloped into the dark interior, it feels like a step back into time. This classic Chicago-style steakhouse is perfect for both a decadent family meal or a special night out. Regulars know the prime rib is the thing to order." - Jackie Bryant

https://sandiego.eater.com/maps/where-to-eat-steak-in-san-diego
View Postcard for The Butcher Shop

Ginger G

Google
We went because of the great reviews to celebrate a birthday but were disappointed. The host was very scattered and confused. We had a reservation on Open Table and he didn’t check our name and we had designated a special birthday. It took us awhile to get seated and he was just going back and forth and just seemed very befuddled. Our waitress must have had too many tables because service was extremely slow. We had to ask for water 3 times before we got it. The food itself was very good. The steaks were good and two of us got fish. We also ordered dessert which was good. The steaks were a little too done compared to what was asked, but the fish was very tasty. We started with the parmesean bread and that was very good. The food is good but the experience overall was not exceptional. The waitress uniform was very skimpy for a steak house while the male waitors wore long shirts and long pants it seemed demeaning to the female staff. The boys should have to wear short shorts if the girls have to.

Jeff Cooperhouse

Google
Ate an excellent dinner at The Butcher Shop! We started with the bone marrow which was fantastic, my favorite dish of the night. They also serve garlic bread which was very good. For entrees we had the seasonal catch which was Chilean seabass and the 10 oz house cut prime rib with Caesar salad and whipped potatoes. We also ordered great cocktails, the Regal and Butcher Shop Old Fashioned. The service was excellent, professional, friendly, and quick. Love the movie star ambiance and old school feel. Recommend for anyone who loves steakhouses.

Rachel P

Google
Lovely place for a date night or special occasion. The atmosphere has nice ambient lighting with candles and wall lamps. Husband ordered the tomahawk steak, which is HUGE! I had the prime rib. Everything was perfectly cooked and delicious. Service was fantastic and very attentive.

Henry Monzon

Google
The prime rib was perfect. I recommend the vanilla gelato for dessert. Our waitress Jacqueline took good care of us. This is a great old school steak house. I do recommend a reservation.

Jen Ruhman - Valenzuela

Google
Old charm restaurant, delicious food, great service, reasonable price. I really enjoyed my dining experience. The old vibe was my favorite. Great place I highly recommend!

Lauren Barnes

Google
We walked inside and it blew me away, it’s beautiful! Service was outstanding. Our server was Ashley and she was so kind! We ordered bone marrow and 2 steaks. The loveliest meal we’ve had on our trip. Cannot recommend this place enough :)

Pamela Branigan

Google
We had their delicious Prime Rib, and my husband had the surf & turf! Lobster Tail was delicious! Ambiance was relaxing & beautiful! Highly recommend! Also, the garlic bread is amazing! Our server Claudia was the greatest! Fast & friendly!

Avishek Sarkar

Google
Lovely place to go for nice meal and drinks. Very old charm decor and ambience with photos of famous actors and singers hung up all throughout the restaurant walls. The food was excellent. Must try the Salmon! Jacqueline was our server and provided superb valuable service. Jacqueline is very knowledgeable and told us a little about the history of The Butcher Shop and also about the menu. The place has a Full bar. Must try the cosmo! Will go back again for sure.
google avatar

Cerena P.

Yelp
This place was fantastic! First off the ambiance was gorgeous it's very old Hollywood, it was also very dimly lit and romantic inside. Food was outstanding, the complimentary garlic bread was fresh and delicious. Calamari was a win, breaded so nicely and the sauces it came with were so flavorful. My mixed seafood pasta was one of the best seafood pastas I've ever had. Seafood was fresh and delicious and the sauce was incredible. Others at the table were very happy with their meal as well, stating that the steak was cooked perfectly. Service was great the entire time and our plates were taken away in a timely manner. We came for our anniversary and because of how gorgeous this place is I think having rose petals on the table, or a little something for those who mention a special occasion on their reservation would be a really great touch. Overall I think the price point was worth it for the great atmosphere, excellent food and wonderful service. Can't wait to come back!
google avatar

Elliot J.

Yelp
Beautiful classic steakhouse decor and ambiance; all wood, linen and red leather. Do Not judge from the outside! I'm was very happy to find they still serve prime rib, and an excellent one it was. Steaks were all top quality and well cooked with a nice char and some smoke. Mushroom side was really excellent, other sides good. Prices are fair for this level of quality. Just do be aware the all female waitstaff wear a revealing uniform with very short skirts. None of them seemed self-conscious about this and the service was professional and prompt, but it can feel a little odd. I joked with our table - my wife and another couple - about why the men (bussers and food runners) didn't wear shorts & tight t shirts.
google avatar

Taura G.

Yelp
We attended a retirement party here and it was wonderful. They have a very large private banquets/reception/events room here. There is enough room for about 200 people and the space is great. There are servers who do an excellent job with quickly getting entrees to each guest and the food is still hot on the plate. The table service is also efficient as they collect your eaten plates and dishes at the right time before the next courses are served. Excellent food, wonderful serving staff, and overall great venue. I appreciated that they have a full PA system with microphones, podium for speeches, and a bar in the room for drink service. This event was non-alcoholic beverages, and it was perfect. Great job!
google avatar

Tyler S.

Yelp
I'll add my food photo but my camera lighting didn't come on. I needed a steak to build up protein for a knee replacement. I can't go long without a steak anyway. I can't eat at those franchised steak places. Food is terrible. I was raised in finer foods. I usually go to Ruth Chris. My go-to being from the SF area. After a meeting, I saw this place. The steak tasted incredible. Cooked perfectly. Everything was delicious. The Bearnaise sauce was good. Get the raw horseradish to add. The garlic toast came with a garlic oil to spread, if you didn't want butter. The service by Eric was perfect. We found a red wine that fit my taste. Ambiance is crazy good. Like a few restaurants in New York from the old days. I will certainly go back.
google avatar

Genie N.

Yelp
Veronica was our server, attentive and friendly for quite a busy evening there. Old school, Hollywood vibe, plush dark booths, dimly lit, harkening back to yesteryear. We ordered Brussels sprouts as an entree and they were delicious with small amounts of bacon. I ordered the prime rib, medium rare. The meat was tender, juicy, perfect! Hubs had the ribeye and scarfed it, lol! We shared a crème brûlée and we were both a little sad when it was gone, yummy!!! Come hungry because the portions are big and say hi to Veronica!

Adrian J.

Yelp
Yahaira was awesome great service! Food was great! Any issue we had she handled with a really positive attitude!
google avatar

Valerie M.

Yelp
I can't believe i have never been here! Old school but in a cool way. Red booths, think Chicago steak house. Really cool, laid back vibes. Bigger than it looks inside. Private rooms, dining room with fireplace. Killer bar area. Happy hours with incredible food. The value is insane. 3 Sliders piled high with perfectly cooked steak, au jus and horseradish sauce. Well poured cocktails will keep you coming back for more. Veronica pours some mean drinks. They're busses Grayson is amazing. Such a gentleman, so polite and helpful. The waitresses were all so nice too. We did eat in the bar but they were all friendly when picking up drinks. Even the other regular patrons at bar were so nice. Valet out front. My new favorite cozy spot with incredible food!

Laura W.

Yelp
Quick and conveniently located steakhouse without the high dollar paid parking that you would get if you went downtown. For me and my husband was just okay. Not sure if we would go again. There are better steakhouses in San Diego.
google avatar

Mike R.

Yelp
Been quite awhile since I've been here. Went with family members on a weeknight for a nice pre-Christmas meal. Remember and love the old school feel. This is a tale of two but combining for a single score. On very positive notes the drinks and service were fantastic. Mai Tai and Old Fashions were great. There was a slight mix up on one of the sides I ordered and I had barely started to mention it when the server whisked it away and said they'll get the right one out right away (which they did). We encountered 3-4 servers during our meal and every one of them was superb! On the downside four of us were in a back corner booth (we're not tiny people) so it was a tad tight for four. I had the filet and two ordered Prime Rib. Overall, while everything was cooked perfectly, for our taste, they were under seasoned. My Filet was tender and juicy but frankly lacked some flavor. Similar comments for the Prime Rib. Note that the Artichoke Crab Cakes are generously sized and fantastic! Now, would we go back; yes of course. We would hope for more flavorful meat while enjoying the great service!
google avatar

Ben A.

Yelp
Food was barely edible. Ambiance was old school and a little cool Ordered a hamburger, bun wasn't toasted, burger meat was ok but flavorless, and French fries tasted like they were frozen My mother ordered the prime rib and it was terrible. The cut of meat was very fatty and tasted bad If you want to go to a dive steakhouse go to Bullys instead
google avatar

Tammy R.

Yelp
Server was friendly but never offered another drink after first one was served. Lobster Mac and cheese was sour and my wedge salad was served on romaine and not iceberg. I hate to complain but for the price will not be going back. Horrible experience.

John W.

Yelp
YahIra was phenomenal!! Great customer service she made our evening very personable!! As someone in the industry I'm not easily impressed but she left an exceptional impression on us !!
google avatar

Christos K.

Yelp
Stopped with some friends for lunch. I hadn't been there for a couple years. It looked closed from the outside. Once you walked inside it was a different story. It reminded me of the old time steakhouses going back to the 50's and 60's. Great atmosphere. It was clean and service was excellent. The food was very good and portions were descent. I definitely recommend it
google avatar

Chun P.

Yelp
I've been dining at The Butcher Shop for almost 20 years, though my recent visit was the first in about 2 years, with the new ownership... Not Changed: -Same upscale vintage, Americana decor, with red leather booths, white linen table clothes, and elegant decor. -Same great food overall -Friendly service all around from the hostess to the waitress and bussers. -The Garlic Bread is still amazing, and FREE! The Garlic Spread is YUM! Changed: -Prices have skyrocketed, as everywhere, but I knew that before hand cause I'm a OCD about looking at menus in advance(see my 2009 review!) -Soup or Salad is no longer included with the steaks...it's $8 extra now. -Choice of side no longer included with the steaks -But other entrees such as the Prime Rib, Salmon, Porkchops, and Lambchops do come with sides. -The new female waitstaff uniforms are "interesting". If your female partner is the "jealous" type, you may want to another dining establishment. $16 Chargrilled Caesar Salad...lovely! Deconstructed and nicely charred, the fresh crouton slices were great too. Big enough for 2 people. $95 Porterhouse 28oz...perfectly cooked to Medium, with a nice sear and char taste...tender, juicy, beefy, and delicious! The wife and I planned on taking some home...but we ended up devouring the entire thing. Better while it's fresh? We also paid $3 for a 3 sauce sampler... $12 Grilled Asparagus...Good! $12 Loaded Baked Potato...Good! $10 House Red Wine Glass...Good enough for unclassy guy like me! $FREE Cheesecake slice dessert...cause it was my birthday! Despite the much higher prices, I'd still rather go here than one of the corporate chains like Flemings, Lou & Mickey's, or Morton's. I'll be back here eventually on another special occasion.
google avatar

Joe B.

Yelp
This place is inconspicuous. I am a transplant from LA and have lived mostly in downtown. This place was not in my radar but now it is one of my favorites. The ambiance is cozy and very appropriate for the culinary experience. Wood, red leather seats pristine white table clothes, dimmed lights and decor that tells you the history of the place: glam, Hollywood stars and exquisite cuisine. The service staff is friendly and very savvy in their recommendations, as well as very helpful in navigating the menu and refilling any drinks. Last but not least the food. The top sirloin is heavenly. The chimichurri is made in house and couldn't be more authentic. I know you probably are doubting my palate due to the fries, but even then we're fantastic, with an all organic ketchup. This meal was one for the books and I would love to recommend you to try them!
google avatar

Shirley F.

Yelp
Food was superb.service was excellent. Ambience was warm and cozy. I little loud from the bar. I loved it. Great experience.
google avatar

Evan G.

Yelp
My family and I came to The Buther Shop tonight to celebrate my brother's birthday. Now I hadn't been here in nineteen years, but this is where my brother really wanted to go. Upon walking in, you almost go back in time as you are presented with a decor that is reminiscent of the old mafia days. Red leather booths, dark wood walls, and brown carpet. It even had a vintage smell in the air. We were greeted by the hostess and were seated within minutes of walking in the door. After being seated, we were greeted by our server roughly ten minutes later. We ordered some waters and drinks and while we waited for those to arrive, I looked over the menu. Upon opening the menu, I took notice that the prices they were charging for their steaks were on par with some of the most high end steak houses in San Dieho. We are talking $95 for a porterhouse, $75 for a 16oz prime rib, and $220 for a 48oz tomahawk steak. With prices like these, I was expected prime cuts and an absolutely superb steak. My family and I placed our orders, which were the porterhouse, the salmon, and lamb chops. The salmon and lamb chops came with sautéed vegetables and mashed potatoes. After placing our orders, we sat there and enjoyed our drinks until they ran dry. We didn't get refills until our food had arrived later, and even after the food arrived and we were topped off on our drink, we didn't see our server until it was time for the bill. Service over all for our table was a 2 out of 5 stars. The food arrived roughly fifteen - twenty minutes after ordering, and I have to say...it was a letdown from the moment they placed the plate in front of me. I ordered the lamb chops, and the overall presentation was that everything was just thrown onto a plate. A big dollop of mashed potatoes, the lamb chops thrown on top, and the vegetables. The potatoes were okay, but the vegteables....I don't know where to begin. For one they were overcooked which you could tell by the fact that what I assume was cauliflower was gray, they were cold and overall tasted as though they were yesterday's vegetables that they heated back up tonight. The lambchops were cooked to the temperature that I requested but lacked flavor. Needed salt, and the chimichurri on top has zero flavor . The overall reaction around the table was pretty much the same. The salmon dish lacked flavor and had the same old tasting vegetables and the $95 porterhouse just mediocre and definitely not a prime cut. Overall, it was a very disappointing dinner. For the prices that The Butcher Shop is charging, I was expecting service to be on point, but more so, the food to be quality. It just felt like I went to a local diner and ate. Can't recommend this place to anyone out there, and I personally don't see myself coming back. For the price, you're better off going to other notable steakhouses in San Diego.
google avatar

Brad G.

Yelp
Excellent service Great drinks from the bar Food was prepared perfectly as ordered Lots of seating inside. The have reservations available if you want to be seated quickly. Host stand is staffed with super friendly people. All the employees seemed to be happy to be there and that just helps with the service and experience! Plenty or parking around the building. Easy to get to from the freeway. A must visit!
google avatar

Tina K.

Yelp
I've come to The Butcher Shop in Convoy with my mom for their Thanksgiving buffet two years in a row, and we absolutely loved it! The spread is amazing--crab legs, poke salad, turkey, prime rib, a variety of thanksgiving sides, lots of desserts, and even a drink included. The food is fresh and delicious, and the cozy steakhouse vibe makes it feel so special. Plus great service! A perfect spot for a memorable Thanksgiving!
google avatar

Hector A.

Yelp
The atmosphere, quality of service and food are top notch. I'm from Riverside and so look forward to dropping in on my way down south. Thanks for making every visit memorable.
google avatar

Jim M.

Yelp
Good french onion soup! Steak bites tasted old, I should've tracked down my waitress because the busser, when asked if I was done with them, even though they were barely touched ,I said, yeah, they weren't good. He just took them and threw them out. Good old school ambience
google avatar

Randall B.

Yelp
Overall a very nice experience. The bar was crowded and far too loud for any enjoyment. The dining room was quiet and relaxed. Our server was fantastic. All four meals were delicious. We had two porterhouse bone in, an 8oz filet, and a surf and turf. All were 5-star. Not cheap by any means but a total delight.
google avatar

Debra S.

Yelp
We hadn't been to The Butcher Shop in a while and were disappointed with the changes under the new ownership. The atmosphere felt inconsistent, with a mix of old-school charm and flashy celebrity-themed pictures that didn't quite mesh. The waitresses' new uniforms seemed tacky, and while our server was friendly, she was clearly inexperienced. The food was good but not particularly memorable, especially for the price. What really left a bad taste in our mouths was the refusal to honor a $200 gift card from the previous owners. While we understand the policy, a small gesture--like a complimentary dessert--would have gone a long way in making up for it. We've dined here many times over the years, but after this experience, we're not sure we'll be back
google avatar

Tim T.

Yelp
Very good food and very great service. The restaurant is very dark. On top of the food in the service the drinks are also very good. Make sure to bring your wallet. Even though the wallet was a little thick I still would probably recommend this place to anybody.
google avatar

Keith G.

Yelp
rude service didn't tell us about the special on Valentine's Day, she spilled water on the table didn't even acknowledge it. We picked up the ice off the table through in the cup, and she just filled it with water, even replaced the water. Also, steak was burnt when we requested well done I know this review is kind of late but just wanted to do it. My son was in the hospital. That's why we chose.
google avatar

Jen R.

Yelp
Old charm restaurant, delicious food, great service, reasonable price. I really enjoyed my dining experience. The old vibe was my favorite. Great place I highly recommend!
google avatar

Kim P.

Yelp
Love the filet and the Caesar salad. Definitely try the bread pudding and creme brulet.
google avatar

Kev M.

Yelp
First time here and what an amazing experience. I arrived at around lunch time and the parking lot was full. The decor was smack g and the lighting was perfect. We had a great and attentive server. I ordered the filet mignon which was great. Can't wait to go back for drinks next time.
google avatar

Charlotte B.

Yelp
Everything was amazing here!!!!! (except one thing that I'll explain) I'm very surprised by the poor reviews here. We rarely ever get our steak/meat the way we ordered it, but tonight they cooked it perfectly. We ordered two sirloins which were again cooked perfectly (medium rare and medium). The Brussels sprouts were roasted very nicely & the flavor of the buttermilk chive whipped potatoes were great. One of the only complaints we had during our experience was the temperature of our sides dishes and sauce when it came out. It seemed to have been sitting out too long. The owner gave us a free dessert for that and the cheesecake was tasty as well. Our server was very attentive, friendly and helpful. The ambiance on the inside is very old timey, but it's classic. The outside definitely needs an upgrade and you would have no idea the kind of place it is by just passing by. We will be back!
google avatar

Danielle L.

Yelp
Took my parents here on a weeknight. They enjoyed the ambiance, and overall old school vibe. The restaurant was empty in every room except for one in the back - where there was a very large birthday party. Unfortunately, this is where they put us. The birthday party was very loud, to the point where it was almost impossible to have a conversation. As we were waiting a very long time for between our appetizers and dinner, we asked to be moved. They moved us to a different room where we were the only people in the room, directly under very cold air conditioning units. While it was nice they were able to accommodate us, I was freezing. As for the food - oysters should not be warm. Other than that, it was rather quite enjoyable. Our waitress was very nice, if a little overwhelmed. They seemed to have some issues with their overall vibe - hopefully it was just an off night, but an investment in their back of the house could do them a favor.
google avatar

Hannah H.

Yelp
The food was good, service was friendly and attentive. However, my quip with this place is the uniform that the waitresses (all appear to be females in early-mid 20s) wear. Imagine a steakhouse crossed with a Hooters and this is it. Extremely short skirts and low cut v neck shirts? I didn't expect to see so much "cheek" everywhere while eating an expensive meal with my date. For the price point of this place it makes no sense really, so think twice if you're thinking of coming here for an intimate date night as I could see it being an awkward situation for some. BUT, our waitress was very sweet and did a great job so I'm only taking a star off for the makes-no-sense ambiance. The mai tai that I ordered was delicious and strong, I wanted to get another one but didn't want to be stumbling out. Haha. Overall, this place is good but could market itself more clearly as either a risque, man-driven steakhouse or an intimate, classy steakhouse. As it is not possible to be both IMO.
google avatar

Rory R.

Yelp
My first time here in over a decade, and the food was just as good as I remember! The parking lot seemed small, but we managed to find a place. The decor inside was kind of retro with somewhat dim lights (appropriate for a steakhouse), red leather, etc. The prices are average for the cuisine. The food was amazing and everything was cooked perfectly! The only reason they're not getting five stars is because of the uniform that the servers wear - short, silky skirts that are like 8" above the knees. Believe me, I normally don't mind that at all, but it's not a good look when I'm at a nice dinner with family and friends.
google avatar

Chad H.

Yelp
The food was delicious had the chicken fetachini and side of glazed Brussel sprouts it was worth the wait I would go back again. The service was excellent the waitress made sure we had everything we needed. The restaurant had a great setting alot of old school pics of actors
google avatar

Katie W.

Yelp
Butcher Shop steak house is always fantastic We had a 7 pm reservation and were seated early Our waitress T was very friendly, professional and answered all questions we had regarding the menu options New York steak was amazing melt in your mouth! The calamari was some of the best I have ever had Flemings potatoes were also a hit! The bar makes great drinks, I recommend the whiskey sour My family will definitely be making it back to Butcher Shop soon. Again, great atmosphere, professional staff and amazing food.
google avatar

Avelino C.

Yelp
There's a lot of traffic on the freeway so I decided to stop on the way and have some dinner and let the traffic get better. I came to this restaurant and I sat at the bar. It was completely packed and happening. I ordered the sliders which were really good and also some mussels which were also excellent. I was very impressed by Eric, the bartender and the rest of the staff. They all seem to get along so well and they were having fun but at the same time they're extremely professional.
google avatar

Alexander F.

Yelp
Really wonderful dinner. I loved the atmosphere and service. The filet, spinach salad, asparagus and duck fries were great. We really were very happy with our evening. The crème brûlée was awful though, very hard custard with the texture of wax and the wine glasses should've been polished before we sat down because they looked filthy BUT overall, great dinner
google avatar

James T.

Yelp
Made an impromptu stop at the butcher shop for dinner and had a blast. The ambience is amazing. The lighting is perfect, the leather booths are perfect for couples or groups. The steaks are perfect and they have an excellent selections of wines. Our server, JC, was attentive and very friendly. We will definitely be back.
google avatar

Karmen P.

Yelp
Today is thanksgiving: the butcher shop put on a very nice holiday buffet. Prime rib, turkey breast, sweet potatoes . Delicious pear salads. Strawberry spinach salad and All the trimmings. I love the vibe inside. An old school steak house, dark and cozy. Old Hollywood photos on the walls, Fire going.., Loud bartender in the back and red shiny booths. Total "Saprano vibe". The buffet was 90.00 per person. Can't say it was worth 90.00.... (However I did not have any of the crab legs or oysters. If I did it would have been). I feel the price was a bit high considering we were serving ourselves and it didn't come w a cocktail or Champaign. Nonetheless, The spread of food offered was generous. We had such a nice afternoon. Plan on coming back for Happy Hour next to that fire. :-). Cheers.
google avatar

Jeff H.

Yelp
My wife and I arrived on a Friday afternoon with no reservation. We were seated about ten minutes later. After giving our order for an appetizer, I asked what top shelf scotch was available. The waitress stepped away for a few minutes and returned with my request. When she began stating the Macallan selection, she said 12 and 16 year. I asked if it was 12 and 15 or 18. She said, "I'm not sure, but I know a shot is REALLY expensive!" Why would I ask what top shelf scotch is available if I weren't prepared both to hear the answer and pay the price? Furthermore, no one does "shots" of scotch, and I own an extensive selection of scotch. The food and service were otherwise very good, and a tip was left, accordingly. Train your staff to stop judging patrons that don't "look wealthy ". (This review is not provided with the intent of obtaining a free meal or the likes. It is meant to induce change.)
google avatar

Anthony M.

Yelp
this was a nice spot. It was not quite what I expected when I walked in, more of a hole in the wall kind of feel to it, but then when you walk in, it opens up into a nice establishment. The food was delicious and the people were very friendly. Be sure to give this place chance.
google avatar

Lindsay Y.

Yelp
Don't spend your money here unless you like severely undercooked steak, rubbery overcooked lobster, flavorless "seasonal veggies", chewy risotto, and dry salmon. Worst $300 we've ever spent. I would have taken pictures but it was so god damn dark in there that I wouldn't have been able to do so without using flash, and I wasn't about to draw that kind of attention to myself. Also, this isn't Hooters, folks - the short skirts and low cut shirts don't belong on your waitresses in a so-called "high quality steakhouse". What even is the angle there? Apparently this is a nod to uniforms of decades past - and that's where these should stay - IN THE PAST. My dad's birthday dinner was completely ruined. He lamented that before Covid, this place used to be really good, so he was excited only to be completely let down. My husband and I felt terrible, and we were upset ourselves because the food was so ass. I couldn't even finish my dinner. Total joke, don't recommend, and we will never go back. Spend your money at Eddie V's or Ruth's Chris and get substantially better food for the prices this terrible place is charging.
google avatar

Donna S.

Yelp
This is a steakhouse in a cozy old world atmosphere with ambivalent hospitality, but great food. The servers in incredibly short skirts who come out flaunting their bottoms are the most out of place part of this restaurant. I thought I walked into an old charming steakhouse, but it seemed more like an upscale formal hooters, but instead of excessive chest showing, it was the bottoms. The service my first time there was wonderful, but my second time was met with passive aggressiveness. With my first visit, my server was just the best ever. She offered sincere recommendations and was very attentive. After leaving, I noticed a discrepancy with what was charged versus what was shown on the menu. I mentioned this at my second visit so that it can be rectified for future patrons. I wasn't trying to get a refund but still got some weird conversation from it. After receiving the check from the 2nd visit, I noticed I was double charged for a drink, so I brought it up. The check was returned with a refill charge of 50 cents instead. This seemed pretty petty as I had just mentioned the overcharge from my 1st visit and didn't make a big deal about getting the difference back, and now I'm being nickeled and dimed. If you do decide to eat here, the prime rib is highly recommended. It was incredible. The lamb, although ordered medium rare, came out rare, but I couldn't tell until i got home because the restaurant lighting was dark. As for service, it's a hit or miss. My first visit was great and had me coming back, but my second visit is what will keep me from returning to dine in. I'd probably do takeout next time. I would also highly recommend that you look over your check for any extra charges since it happened to me on both occasions.
google avatar

Julia F.

Yelp
Old Chicago style steak joint. The steaks are always on point. I got filet medallions with blue cheese on top and truffle fries, husband got a porterhouse, and our son got the salmon. All was very good. My complaints are that the waitresses wear costumes that are so revealing that you see butt cheeks. I just think it's very strange in today's time that that is acceptable. My other complaint was when we were initially seated, they tried to shove us in a room that was already almost completely full of people. We would not have been able to have simple conversation in this room. We asked to move to a different table and were accommodated.

Elizabeth S.

Yelp
Went there for Fathers Day w reservations for 2pm didn't know it was Buffet only. And it was going to be over at 3pm. Ham and eggs were cold, bacon salty, no orange chicken or mashed potatoes, Mac n cheese was burnt due to it sitting there. The beef was sliced extremely thin I had to ask for a second slice. The food was horrible. Myself and my party did not see any fresh food be brought out the entire time. The staff served themselves at the end which is fine but would've been more professional if they could've waited til we left. I was prepared to spend money but for a good meal. Not $90 for a barely there, cold buffet.
google avatar

Craig W.

Yelp
The Butcher Shop is a classic San Diego steakhouse. It has a very cool, old school vibe: red leather booths, photos of movie stars everywhere, Sinatra playing on the sound system, and a (fake) roaring fire when it's 80 degrees outside. And still, half the guests are wearing baseball hats at dinner or are wearing t-shirts, shorts, and sneakers. Sigh. Now, the food is not amazing but ranges from decent to very good. So keep your expectations in check. The drinks are large and boozy. The bar is very cool. There's hardly anything on the dinner menu other than steak or prime rib. The potato skins appetizer is terrific. The French onion soup is very satisfying. The garlic bread was a little dry and boring but came with a cup of warm, roasted garlic for easy slathering on top. The side of asparagus was nice and fresh. For the main course, the beef tenderloin medallions is outstanding. It is beyond tender and comes with bleu cheese on top. The sirloin was, sadly, a little tough and flavorless. Our server was excellent and knew the menu inside and out. She was also friendly and very attentive. There's free parking behind the restaurant. It can get a little tight but there are other businesses nearby and I imagine you can borrow their parking spots, if necessary. Mostly hits, a couple of misses, but overall, it's a fun experience. Now, take off your baseball hat when you're inside a restaurant, especially a nicer one, and enjoy a nice meal.
google avatar

Brandon T.

Yelp
WOW! HIDDEN GEM IN PLAIN SIGHT! Absolutely great service from every one of the staff that we have interacted with... for example, today we sat at the bar and Nea was helping us. Very attentive but not too much where you're feeling like you're being crowded, always available to get you what you need or maybe even offering things you didn't know you needed (but we did). She gave great recommendations and was interested in what we had to say and the questions we were asking... All of the staff here are the same way. You know It's the real deal when Executive chef Brian walks around and checks on you and your meal. That goes for you as a first-time diner here or if you're a regular and you just feel like old friends. Ultimately, you can just tell he wants you to have a great experience here with your food and the staff and the ambiance and everything else... AND he is excited about what he's making. Whether it be the tomahawk steak and monster, 22 oz lobster tail, or the oxtail or any of their steaks or prime rib or soups or anything else. EVERYTHING IS AMAZING. Coming to The Butcher shop gives me a real old school feeling with mellow vibes where you can enjoy the ambiance and socialize with work friends or enjoy time with your family or come here with a date and be able to smile and hear each other talk. Bonus with the fireplace in a dining room! Ultimately I always leave here with a feeling of gratitude, And that's how it should be. I love everything about The Butcher Shop. Trust me... You will too.
google avatar

Melissa B.

Yelp
I take my husband here every year for his birthday and it never disappoints! Our server Berlin knocked it out of the park and brought her A game! Especially bringing other girls to sing happy birthday to my husband!

Kenny J.

Yelp
Went there for prime rib, and had ONE option, not multiple sizes or cuts, like the other menus on line?
google avatar

Pam B.

Yelp
New Year's Eve celebration - I arrived a 20 minutes early and the hostess said she would seat me closer to my reservation time. My two friends arrived about 10 minutes later and we were still asked to wait to be seated. We sat in the bar area and at 5:30 the hostess yelled "Pam!" Our table was in the back corner of the restaurant. We were dressed in sparkles and several staff commented on how nice we looked (probably comparing us to the dude is his worn out jean jacket two booths over.) My friend ordered the rack of lamb and it was a beautiful presentation but the meat was RAW. My other friend ordered the tenderloin medallions. I had the Bibb wedge and the lobster mac-n-cheese (yum!) The highlight of our dining experience was our server Yahaira. She said she has worked at The Butcher Shop for three years. She is competent, friendly and efficient!