The Cookie Jar

Bakery · Cumberland County

The Cookie Jar

Bakery · Cumberland County

1

554 Shore Rd, Cape Elizabeth, ME 04107

Photos

The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by Ellie G./Yelp
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null
The Cookie Jar by null

Highlights

This charming family-owned bakery in Cape E serves up a delightful array of fresh donuts, pastries, and custom cakes, all in a cozy vintage setting.  

Featured in Eater
Placeholder
Placeholder

554 Shore Rd, Cape Elizabeth, ME 04107 Get directions

cookiejarbakers.com
@thecookiejarpastryshop

$ · Menu

Information

Static Map

554 Shore Rd, Cape Elizabeth, ME 04107 Get directions

+1 207 799 0671
cookiejarbakers.com
@thecookiejarpastryshop

$ · Menu

Features

takeout
delivery
payment credit card
Tap to pay

Last updated

Jul 5, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

"This Cape E institution is comforting with its vintage feel and classic pastry menu. Cake doughnuts come in a variety of flavors from the classic chocolate glaze to seasonal favorites like apple and pumpkin." - Kate McCarty

17 Delectable Doughnut Shops in Maine - Eater Maine
View Postcard for The Cookie Jar

jake seagle

Google
Maple glazed yeast, glazed yeast, and chocolate cake donuts. The maple glazed and regular glazed were both delicious. The maple had a good amount of maple flavor and the donut was light and fluffy. The yeast was light and fluffy as well but I thought it could've used more glaze. The chocolate cake donut was thrown away. It was dry and lacked any chocolate flavor. We'd come back for yeast donuts.

Kate Moncada

Google
So grateful for this place! Not only are their butter crunch donuts *the best* any day of the week, but I recently ordered a birthday cake and cupcakes for my daughter's 1st birthday. The team was communicative, the turnaround was quick, and the cake was gorgeous and delicious. New go-to for event needs!

Jenny McKee

Google
So many delicious baked goods and types of Coffee by Design coffee freshly brewed! They sell cake and yeast donuts, cream horns, bagels, and more. While everything is good (we tried the cream horns and apple fritters, which were pretty tasty), their standout item is the jelly donut. They offer them with several fillings, including cream, lemon, maple cream, and raspberry jam, and they are HUGE. The maple cream was so good and the perfect sweet, fall treat! Can't wait to visit again!

Audrey “Theaudestcooper” Cooper

Google
You must go here. Even if you're nowhere near it you should still probably go ;) Amazing house made pastries including fresh Danish, huge and beautiful donuts, cookies galore, cupcakes and pies. Large shop with plenty of room to enjoy your treat. Large assortment of coffee by Coffee by Design. Helpful, friendly staff, and good prices! Just an unbelievably fantastic place.

Joel Barrett

Google
Lots of delectable baked specialties and other goodies, like Maple Syrup! Excellent selection of different coffee — you’re sure to find something you like.

Larry Green

Google
One word. AWESOME! Great donuts for a great price. I recommend the raised glazed or the apple glazed. They were both fantastic. All the items they have are made fresh in store! Staff is friendly and very helpful.

Stephen Lee

Google
Great vanilla coconut donuts! Lots of other donut varieties to choose from. Prices are a bit high, but not too bad. Very large selection of coffee flavors, too. Very friendly staff.

Chamodhi Ravihansi

Google
Best! We were there at Portland Head Light for sunrise and this was open on the way back. Blueberry bagel was out of this world! We also tried the Boston Cream Bismark and it was really nice without sweetness overpowering. Also had both hot and cold coffee. Highly recommend!