The Corner Slice

We stumbled upon The Corner Slice while walking around downtown Fort Collins, looking for something quick and easy that could work for our whole family—including our baby daughter—and it turned out to be the perfect spot. Right off the bat, the staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming, which always sets the tone for a good experience. They had March Madness basketball on the TVs, which added a fun energy to the place, and their selection of sodas, beer, and wine was way better than I expected for a casual pizza joint. I started off with a slice of cheese pizza and some garlic bread, and let me tell you—it was so good I had to get up and order another slice. You know a pizza place is doing something right when a single slice isn’t enough and you find yourself going back for more. The crust, the sauce, the cheese—everything was just spot on. The whole vibe of the place was relaxed and welcoming, super family-friendly, and just the kind of spot you want in a neighborhood like this. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite, hanging with friends, or bringing your kids along, it’s got everything you need. We had such a wonderful time, and I’m honestly already looking forward to coming back. Highly recommended if you’re in the area and want great pizza with great people in a great location. This one’s a gem.

So good! We went before and after the brewery tour bc it was so good! 😊 Lucas was so friendly Margherita pizza is bomb/ must try

After seeing some good reviews, I decided to try the place the next time I was in the area. I walked away very disappointed. I ordered 2 cheese slices, which totaled $6.15 with tip. I thought that was a great price until I received the slices. They were very small, maybe cut out of a 12-14" pie. The crust was okay, probably the best part of the slice, but it was kind of bland. It did have a very nice crisp to it. What really turned me off was the sauce. It was NOT a pizza sauce. It was like a marinara sauce that you would eat with pasta or get with meatballs. It was extremely overpowering and was very out of place. Much better options exist in Fort Collins, which are the ones I'd recommend, not this one.

A hidden gem! I wander Old Town Square frequently, but this is the first time I noticed The Corner Slice. Wonderful pizza, particularly the crust, and amazing people. I highly recommend grabbing a slice (or a whole pie)!

So thankful I stumbled across this place while looking for a spot to have dinner and drinks before the concert in the square tonight. From a pizza lover I can tell you this place is legit. Happy Hour is a must and the food will not disappoint. The atmosphere is incredibly laid back and chill and the staff was awesome! Thank you!

Real NY style pizza is hard to find out here west of the Pecos, and I'm one of those boomer food snobs. [I cooked in upscale restaurants when I was young]. Amazingly, I was really impressed. Excellent thin crust with high gluten flour. A+ on that. Just mozzarella and pepperoni, but good quality. Very little sauce, I would have liked enough to taste it. Served piping hot, a rare thing. Pizza overall 8+. But what a deal! During happy hour (2:30 to 5:30), I had 2 slices of pepperoni and a nice craft beer, all for $9! (Tivoli lager is $2/pint during happy hour). I doubt there is anywhere else in Old town with a deal this good. One note, we went around the block two times trying to find it. Problem is the sign is small, freestyle, and I couldn't read it, even from 10 feet away. The ambience is basic, I would have liked a couple of aging mafiosi lurking in the corners.They need a big sign with red letters saying "Hot NY Mafia Style Pizza!" I highly recommend this college vibe hole in the wall.

My husband and I came here 5 days ago! I love the cozy atmosphere, the customer service was above and beyond! I really wanted to try the margarita pizza but, they don't normally do just slices of that and it wasn't the pizza of the day. However, they were awesome and did it for me anyways! It was so good! The sodas just as nostalgic and delicious! We will definitely be coming back!

Killer new pizza spot in north old town. They serve by the slice or whole pies. Meatballs, pizza, cheese bread and especially the garlic pretzels are so good. Beer and craft sodas. Owners are from Steamboat. Excellent job!