The Dinner Detective True Crime Murder Mystery Dinner Show - New York City, NY

We went to Carmines murder mystery dinner and had a blast! It was so much fun. The staff was so involved and charismatic. It was definitely a fun date night. The food was great along with our drinks. Definitely recommend for a fun night out.

What a great time. Came on a Saturday to celebrate a friends birthday and it was a good time. The way they set the show up its almost impossible not to have a good time. We got to know everyone at our table and it was such a fun time! Cant say that enough. The food was good but i’ll say its more about to show than the food. Its a generic meal but it is yummy. The bartender is awesome! We got 4 drinks and they were so good. 3 Aperol Spritz and 1 Paloma.

The acting was poor and boring. It wasn’t real enough. It wasn’t even funny. I would not recommend this show to anyone. Also, I was one of the people who solved the crime but I never received a prize. The staff, food and atmosphere was very good

Believe the other 2-star review here! The storyline doesn't make sense, the actors were bad, and the whole show was cringe at best. Actors trying to be quirky, screaming at you, and making weird innuendo jokes. Food was generic. Bartenders were nice. 100% NOT worth the price.

What a lovely experience! The entire staff was great. The hosts, actors, and wait staff, were all either respectful or funny. At $100 for dinner and a show, it's a great value for a birthday experience. They have a bar nearby and dinner was very tasty. Great experience and I highly recommend booking an event here!

I had an amazing experience here. The food staff and bartenders were really nice. The food and drinks themselves were pretty tasty too. The heart of the show are the actors who might even be sat at your table. The show is more very light hearted and comedic but the clues they give u to solve the mystery are woven into the show and they have great audience participation. Easy recommendation.

TOO EXPENSIVE FOR WHAT IT IS!!! For $107 per person this was definitely not worth the money. The Omni hotel is beautiful but the room the show is hosted in is quite small. The food was mediocre at best. The appetizers were awful and cold. The salad was decent (but you can’t really mess up a salad). The entree was blah. Overall, food was 2/10. The show was ok. The actors were not very good but everyone was so kind. The storyline of the murder didn’t really make sense and you could tell exactly who the actors in the room were. Cute idea but not executed well. Would NOT recommend.

We had a fantastic night. The show is hilarious, and even if it was more comedy than mystery, there are still clues to follow and mysteries to unravel. I highly recommend the "Suspect Package" if you're going with a significant other and your table is the "interactive" type. You'll have so much fun! The bar is great (gratuity is included!), the food is clearly not the star of the dinner, but you'll quickly forget about it. Actors are great, funny and clearly know how to make everyone comfortable and what buttons to push. An well worth experience!