Andrew Keeley
Google
Service was good and the waitress was friendly. It took a while for us to get our food, but it was busy and we weren't in a rush. Food quality was OK; acceptable but also forgettable.
The price was exorbitant for the quantity of food. The menu says burgers come with 2, 3oz patties, so 6oz of meat total. Except that isn't true of all burgers. My burger had only 1, 3oz patty that was so small I couldn't even see it between the bread until I started eating (see picture). For $17, I expect more. It didn't even come with fries to fill me up, those were an extra $3. Instead it came with a bag of store-bought, single-serving chips. In comparison, the overpriced hockey stadium across the street serves "gourmet" burgers with 2, 4oz patties and waffle fries for $14.50. I could have gotten more food for cheaper at a sports game...
We also got some cheese curds, which were also $17. The portions and quality were similar to New Bohemia down the street, except New Bohemia only charges $11. Even the hockey stadium only charges $8.29 for cheese curds,, less than half as much as Eagle Street for similar portions. The menu says it comes with a sauce of choice, but then they charge you another $0.50 for it.
On top of all this there is a 3% surcharge applied for using a credit card that they don't tell you about until you get the bill. Overall, very shady business practices bordering on false advertising.