Grace N.
Yelp
Let me start off by saying that I'm not a huge fan of baked fruit pie. That being said...
Come here to buy their pie. Apple pie. Peach apple pie. Rhubarb apple pie. Strawberry rhubarb apple pie. Blueberry apple pie.. just buy their damn pie. Specifically the ones baked in the bag. Let me explain why.
The fruit is perfect. Not to sweet, not too tart, not overly spiced, not too soft, not too wet. Just perfect. Now, that crust.. their crust is like a sugar cookie. Sweet, crispy, caramelized, buttery, chewy in certain places. Put them together and it really is the perfect baked fruit pie!
My favorite is the strawberry rhubarb apple pie. It's more tart than the other pies and it's perfect warmed up with a bit of ice cream. My husbands favorite is the peach apple. Honestly, you can't go wrong!
I recommend getting the mini pie because there is more crust to filling ratio. Also, if you buy the mini pie, you can buy multiple without feeling too guilty.
I also tried their strawberry rhubarb crisp, but the crisp topping can't compare to the pie crust for me.
Sweet pie is not your thing? That's fine.. their chicken pot pie is a winner too! Plenty of filling, sauce, chicken, all in a crispy flaky crust. So comforting to eat. They offer their savory pies frozen as well so I'm excited to see how they bake up.
Honorable mentions: their seasoned pretzels.. addictive and delicious! The honey mustard flavor is my favorite.
Finally, let's talk about their customer service. The weekend I discovered Elegant Farmer and their pies, I came back three times in three days. On the third day, I bought a pie for my in laws. To our disappointment, it was under baked. I reached out to Elegant Farmer and they were so kind and thoughtful in their response. They made sure I got a replacement pie the next day! The pie was PERFECT and my in laws were so happy.
Overall, Elegant Farmer is a must visit. You'll leave with a smile as big as the one on their barn!