Noel K.
Yelp
The setting is wonderful. We were there on a gorgeous sunny, cool fall day We sat outside on the deck. There was only one other couple, and the whole vibe was calm and relaxing.
Here's where the good news ends. My husband ordered the curried chicken salad. The overflowing sandwich with pickles and chips looked amazing. Unfortunately, he said it was just fair. Very bland. I had scrambled eggs, English muffin, home fries, and ham. The eggs were cooked perfectly. Unfortunately, the home fries which looked great, were also bland. Too bad. IMO, it doesn't take much to make home fries tasty.
Service: Here's what really annoyed me: I wanted to order Eggs Benedict. I love eggs benny and order it frequently at many restaurants. The one change I always make is asking for scrambled rather than poached eggs. Think what you will about my choices, I have never had a problem. Never.
Yet, our Flying Fish waitress was utterly thrown by my request, and after she spoke with the cook, I was told "We can't do this." WTF? It was 1pm on Sunday and there was only one other couple in the entire restaurant. No reason given, just that the cook wouldn't do it. This strikes me as inane. They offer scrambles eggs on the menu, and it's not like this is some fine dining experience where scrambled eggs will ruin the chef's creation. Give me a break.
So instead, I ordered: scrambled eggs, English muffin, ham, and a side of hollandaise sauce. Apparently, they didn't have any problem with that. In fact, when all was said and done, I ended up getting home fries with my order of eggs, which I wouldn't have gotten with Eggs Benedict.
What really irritates me though, is this: What I ordered cost .50 more than the Eggs Benedict. Oh brother!
Be forewarned though, there is a $2.00 charge to substitute an English muffin for toast. My order of ham looked liked a very thin slice of grilled deli meat. It was a triangle about 2" on all sides. Also tasteless. My side of hollandaise was roughly the quantity of a tablespoon. Maybe they DID have a problem with what I ordered and decided to stick it to me?
Flying Fish probably doesn't have to worry about repeat customers. There will always be a steady stream of patrons during Wellfleet summers. That said, it's too bad. They should strive to do better. If you are looking for a nice place to order a coffee and sit, this might be your place. If you are looking for good food or good service, I agree with other reviewers: Go elsewhere. Too bad. Flying Fish has potential.
Oh, and also, there were two of us, not one as the receipt says.