The Gem and Keystone Tavern

Came here after a hike with quite an appetite , calamari appetizer was good but the margarita tasted like there was no effort put in to mix the drink and it was packed with ice to the brim. I ordered a burger medium well and my friend a medium and both especially mine came burnt on the side and well done and dry . Server said they could not add avocado or egg on burger but said they had gravy for my mashed potatoes and then came back and said they don’t have gravy .The waiter also forgot my dressing for the burger so I sat there just waiting for a while. I was going to complain to the waiter but I was really hungry and had no time to wait for another burger for 30 minutes , it kinda seemed like it wasnt a one time thing that it’s just that way at that restaurant since my friends penne alla vodka wasn’t that good as well . Ambience is really nice but food was low quality. Server seemed new as the ordering process was not the smoothest.

We were pleasantly surprised by this restaurant. We went hungry after checking in at the Shawnee Inn. The hostess was so pleasant and so was our server. Everything was quick and efficient, the food was great, I had the steak salad which was excellent although I did change it a little from the menu because I don’t like blue cheese. I hate changing things and being a pain and they were so nice about it. My husband loved his bacon cheeseburger he actually said it was one of the top 5 burgers he’s had, I had a bite is was delicious. We had French onion soup which was delicious! Also their desserts were great. We liked it so much we went the very next day for dinner again.

Really nice tavern. We had dinner. At the ribs were amazing. We were able to bring our dog and sit outside, which was a nice picturesque setting. Our server Tommy was super friendly and attentive. Nice job guys

My wife I are out of town and waiting for our room to be ready on a mini vacation. This place was tucked in off the main roads to be quiet but close enough to be wonderful. Decent amount of parking. Walking in on our first time you can choose the upstairs dining area or downstairs tavern. It was a touch windy to sit out on the two patios they have but would be great during a warm spring day, summer time or early fall to eat, drink, talk next to the small creek. Both levels have a full bar and draft beer from Shawnee Craft with bottles of mainstream beer. We chose the spacious downstairs tavern, we were greeted by Todd the bartender and presented both food and drink menus. The food the cooks made is wonderful. Wood fired salmon with crisp vegetables was so good that my wife cleared her plate. The burger and fries I got was juicy and fresh the fries were crisp. Todd knows his drinks and is very astute in bourbon. On our way out we talked to Jamie the manager on duty and she talked to us about some of the history and general information of the venue. All the people were very polite, and extremely friendly. We will definitely be going back when we’re in the area again!!!

We came to PA for a vacation. The resort was walking distance to this place so we decided to give it a shot. (We also read positive reviews) Food was very good. Loaded Nachos was flavorful and “loaded” - french onion soup was cheesy and tasty. We also had the Mediterranean salad and cheesesteak hero. Reason not 5 stars? Service Started great but over course of the night we felt neglected. Not the kids fault, seemed place might have been short staffed. If not would have totally received 5 stars.

Food was good with a variety of options. I had the wings special and had to try the French onion soup. The soup had good flavor, the wings would have used a little more sauce but were cooked nice and crispy. Kids menus are available for those traveling as families. Wait staff seemed a little overwhelmed as evening went on and the restaurant became busier. Had to ask for drink refills several times while we waited.

Reservations STRONGLY encouraged! I popped into this "gem" on a Saturday night with no reservations. I was told the wait would be like over 2 hours, and I said I'd be happy to take a hole in the wall with no acknowledgment-- I just wanted to try the place because I was there only one night with my friend. As luck would have it, that moment a table opened up from a reservation that JUST called to cancel, and my friend and I were standing at the right place/right time to snatch it up! Staff, servers and management: spot on. SO friendly, so warm, and so helpful. Tommy, our server, was adorable and friendly. He made excellent recommendations and we loved it all. Food: so yummy. We had the whipped pistachio starter, as well as fried pickles -- and they were both so good. Dinners were the sticky buns pork belly sliders and the falafel burger. We'd order both again! Pork belly cubes were tender and tasty, and my falafel was so good. Tommy said we'd also love the Risotto, so maybe next time! Love this place. Love the staff. Highly recommend (reservations, too)!! Thanks, team! UPDATE: We just came back and sat outside, downstairs! We have three dogs, eight people, and this place was more than accommodating! Tonight we had the chicken pot pie, smothered burger, mahi-mahi, tuna, rack of ribs, and cheesesteaks! Once again, everything was amazing! The chicken pot pie is, handsdown, one of the best ever. We absolutely love this restaurant ❤️

We had good foor there . I had the fried sailfish and my daughter had the Tavern burger We were very happy with them. Service was fast , and responsive. I would refer this restaurant to friends and family , so yes you .