Courtney S.
Yelp
This (UES location) is our corner store but I would make the trip to come here even if it wasn't, for the reliability of really fresh, beautiful, organic produce and the beautifully curated selection of organic and health food products that they have. Even when we have considered moving, losing our local Health Nuts has been a (prominent) factor in not wanting to leave the neighborhood. It is that compelling of a resource for our organic produce and groceries.
We live in an area with an abundance of options: Morton Williams, Whole Foods, Grace's, corner fruit stands, recently Trader Joe's (which I love but whose nationally distributed and plastic packaged produce is still far inferior to Health Nuts). We purposefully choose Health Nuts for its consistent quality, especially the produce.
I love in particular that EVERYTHING in the produce section is organic, as opposed to every other grocery store where you have to hunt for the specific organic section, or where organics are mixed in with non-organics and you never know for sure what you are getting. I love that I can rely on my produce to ALL BE ORGANIC when I buy from here. The quality is also exceptional, especially the fresh greens selections, bursting with color and freshness. Very reliable, consistent, high quality.
I also love that the vegetables are mostly unpackaged, so you are reducing disposable waste when you shop here. Also, they have an awesome bulk foods section with canisters filled with all kinds of legumes, grains, nuts, granolas, and dried fruits--with no packaging! Plus their own peanut butter and almond butter machines to make it fresh before your eyes with the flip of a switch. Environmental efforts like that make me go out of my way to shop here, and the quality makes the (admittedly higher) prices worthwhile to me. But honestly even when I go to dirty old Gristedes the prices aren't even always lower! Non organic things will always be cheaper, so you have to compare apples to apples :)!
We can each do our share to influence climate change by voting with our dollars where we buy, what we buy, and what we don't. Paying higher for organic, non packaged items is not possible all the time or for everyone I understand, but it is a priority in the big picture that I appreciate Health Nuts gives me the option to elect. In that sense, when I can afford to pay more for organic/local unpackaged items, I will, because even if organic/local wasn't better for me, it is an attempt to make more responsible choices for our world.
The grocery section can be expensive but it is convenient and they have good products, often with weekly 30% off sales off the ticket price. And again, all the selection of organic groceries all in one place without having to question what is organic (or more responsible than mainstream) and what isn't also applies in the dry goods (and dairy and home and beauty) and EVERY section of the store. I know it is expensive, but for the most part, its existence does us a service because otherwise we wouldn't even have the option to get so many high quality organic products all in one place. No other store offers that variety and quantity of reliably organic.
I noticed a reviewer say it's a small store but actually I think it's a huge corner store for Manhattan! It's not a supermarket chain, it's a local grocer. And in that category, it takes up at least two rental spaces (they expanded awhile back) and is very spacious. I can usually find anything I need to make anything in a pinch, including Asian sauces and products. They don't have fresh meat or seafood sections, but they have frozen high quality stuff, plus packaged cold cuts, charcuterie, dairy and vegan cheeses, and grass-fed (not just pasture-raised, I learned there's a difference!) eggs and milk. And tons of vitamins and supplements, and even hydroflasks and klean kanteens. Pretty much everything you could need.
I still of course shop everywhere for different things, but this is my go-to store for most everything, especially produce! And I'm not sure about the delivery grocery service, but in person, I've only ever had really friendly encounters with all the staff, who greet me with kindness and a smile every time I go in, which has been for years now. They are really so nice, and a breath of fresh air in NYC, because it really makes you feel like your own small town neighborhood store where everyone knows you!