Tim G.
Yelp
Fiddler's Pond at the Homestead is an overpriced 2-star hotel. Rooms were meek - and the "amenities" of the "resort" were barely worth it.
In addition, we received rude treatment from the registration desk when trying to receive clarification on some housekeeping issues we suffered from.
PROS:
1. Housekeeping staff were EXTREMELY polite, and in the several instances we walked in on them (see below), they rushed to complete our room, and always asked if there was more they could do for us.
2. The pools were beautiful, and nice. We visited two of them.
CONS:
1. Beach Access - depending on where you are located on the Homestead, you are either close or quite far from the beach. From Fiddler's Pond, was two car rides from the beach! One car ride to the "parking lot" and then another ride via an irregularly run "shuttle" to the actual beachfront. Not easy with kids and a bunch of beach stuff. frankly, we drove right up to local beaches, and parked 15' away!
2. Housekeeping Schedule - We have kids, so I asked when we arrived for the approximate time of housekeeping - we were told 11:00 am. That lasted for two days. The next time, we returned from the beach just after 5 pm- we were rushing to make a restaurant reservation, and housekeeping was in the middle of cleaning our room. The fourth day, we returned at 2:30, and we interrupted the cleaning staff again. Hard to commit to a schedule of eating and naps. Not the housekeeping staffs fault (they were super nice- see #1 above), this is a management issue.
3. Front desk staff on the afternoon of 7/23. Two condescending young women would not discuss the housekeeping issue; I just wanted an accurate time range for our last day. I was refused the opportunity to speak to a manager, and I was told - "that's just the way it is." I left. My wife returned, demanded a manager, who happily came out of a back office, and had a mature discussion with her to rectify the situation, but not before making a mountain out of a molehill by reacting immaturely and unprofessionally and really pissing my wife off!
4. Construction / Amenities Closed! - Two weeks before our visit, we received an e-newsletter discussing the construction; which was occurring right outside of our unit. Two weeks notice! No time to change our vacation time from work, and not within the the 60 cancellation policy. It was noisy, messy (insulation install left our car / lot / area plats covered!).
5. The rooms. I call it a two star hotel - mismatched towels & washcloths, poor quality beds and linens, funky smell, no microwave, little room in the restroom, and the deck WHICH WE PAID EXTRA FOR - had dirty furniture we wouldn't sit on, and garbage from the previous visitors! And by the way, the deck - WHICH WE PAID EXTRA FOR - overlooked the construction. Swell!
A resort? Hardly.
No wireless Internet access, but instructions in your room on how to connect and use the phone for your dial up carrier. Remember dial up? Yep, that was the last time they updated their towels and sheets.
They had the opportunity to up sell us, but our experience with the two snarky chicks at the front desk on the afternoon of 7/23 left us no choice - we will return to the Sleeping Bear Dunes area, but for the price, we won't stay there again.
There is potential at the Homestead, but employees have to care about the patrons in order to make this a reality.