Kara DeMaio
Google
A truly special experience — Italian comfort with a twist
Italian Boy After Dark is something magical. By day, it's a humble Italian sandwich shop—but come nightfall, it transforms into an intimate chef’s tasting experience for just 12 lucky diners. My husband and I had the joy of sitting at the counter, watching the chef prepare each course with care, storytelling, and a clear love for food.
The entire evening felt like a nostalgic nod to the family dinners we grew up with—wine served in water glasses, shelves lined with big jars of giardiniera and peppers, and warm conversation floating through the room. But while the vibe is old-school Italian, the menu surprises you. Each course offered a classic dish with an unexpected and delightful twist. The flavors were thoughtful and exciting.
Our favorite? The sandwich course—a perfect tribute to the shop’s daytime roots. It was so good, we already plan to return during the day just to see what else they’re crafting between bread.
We can’t recommend Italian Boy After Dark enough. The food, the chef, the atmosphere—it all adds up to an experience that feels both personal and unforgettable.