Auntie Athena (ExploreMauiToday)
Google
I visited the Lake House Restaurant on Eagle Mountain Lake for a late lunch and really enjoyed the setting. The atmosphere is warm and lodge-like, with lots of wood, a fireplace, and a laid-back, saloon-style vibe. There’s both a downstairs patio right on the lake and a smaller upstairs one—perfect for nice weather. You can tell it’s a lively spot in the evenings, with dollar bills on the wall, beer tap handles hanging from the ceiling, and a bar area that includes a pool table, couches, and seating that feels like a cozy hangout.
The place is definitely family-friendly, with the main dining area separated from the bar. The service was great— my server was attentive and friendly, even though she forgot the silverware and napkin until it was a little late. I ordered the quesadilla because it was Cajun chicken had corn and beans inside something more than the usual quesadilla 😁 however I was personally disappointed—it lacked grill marks and texture, almost like it was microwaved or cooked on very low heat. It reminded me more of a soft burrito than a crisp quesadilla.
That said, the menu had a solid selection, and they offer cocktails, beer, and likely wine. They have drink specials as well. I was hoping to try their daily soup, but was told they stopped serving soup a while ago, even though it’s still listed on the menu. Excellent prices by the way.
All in all, a great place for the view, a casual meal, and a relaxed vibe. Would definitely return for the atmosphere and service— i’ll even order the quesadilla. I will just make sure to say I like it a bit crispy.