Jason Colbert
Google
Comin' from New Orleans, my standards for what makes a place special are sky-high. We live and breathe good food, good music, and places with real character. A bar has to have a soul, you know? It can't just be four walls and some taps. So when I walked into The Lost Paddy Irish Pub, I had my critic's hat on tight. (Typically hate dining while traveling) And let me tell you, they didn't just meet my expectations; they blew them clean out of the water.
First off, the vibe. This isn't some shiny, corporate "Irish-themed" restaurant. This is a proper pub. It's got that worn-in, comfortable feeling of a true locals' dive bar, the kind you'd find tucked away in the Marigny or Bywater where everybody knows your name by your second visit. It's dark, it's cozy, and it feels like it's been soaked in stories and good times for a hundred years. It felt like home.
Now, the food. I ordered the Bangers and Mash, a dish that can be tragically bland if not done right. What was placed in front of me was a work of art. The bangers themselves were magnificent—perfectly grilled with a glorious snap and slight char, bursting with a savory, herbaceous flavor that was complex and deeply satisfying. The mash potatoes were the real deal—perfectly buttery and just lumpy enough to let you know they came from a real potatoes, not a box. The soul of the plate was that rich, dark onion gravy. And piled right on top of it all was a generous handful of crispy, crunchy onion strings, adding the perfect textural contrast to every soulful bite.
You can't have a great pub without a great bartender, and the lady working the bar (Heather) was nothing short of phenomenal. She was a maestro. She was pouring perfect pint after pint of Guinness with the patience of a saint for one person, cracking a jokes, and keeping pleasent convo with everyone all without missing a beat. She was making everyone feel welcome while running the bar with effortless style.
And just when I thought it couldn't get any better, the live music started. No cheesy cover band here. It was a couple of musicians playing some genuinely fantastic, foot-stomping music that filled the entire space with energy. It was the final, perfect ingredient.
The Lost Paddy Irish Pub is the real deal. It’s a trifecta of incredible food, a warm and genuine atmosphere, and top-notch service and entertainment. I came in a skeptic, and I left a loyal fan!