Jennifer C.
Yelp
I really loved this restaurant the first time I came here, which is why I travel and spend the night to come eat here. I think the menu had just changed so we were disappointed there weren't any artichokes on the menu but that's life with a seasonal restaurant. Overall the menu seemed less inspired than my last visit, which is strange considering the amount of fresh produce available.
Best Food:
*Chips and onion dip (skipped the trout roe) - no idea how they make the chips like that
*Seared Scallops with corn and bacon - delicious with 2 perfectly seared scallops, did not need so much corn
*Citrus chicken with lemon thyme risotto and seasonal vegetables - I made fun of my date for ordering this but it was flavorful, well seasoned, everything made sense presentation wise, and the chicken was so perfectly cooked with crisped skin with proper fat rendering. I would have liked the risotto cooked a minute or 2 longer, but I think that's more personal preference.
*Chocolate Bomb - chocolate cake with chocolate mousse, encased in chocolate ganache, set on top of crème anglaise, I believe. Decadent perfection!
Mid Food:
*Amuse bouche/polenta cake over smoked paprika aioli. The aioli was incredible and I'm going to make that at home, but polenta had zero seasoning, so only the part that touched the aioli had flavor. Even for a single bite, it was strangely noticeable
*Pistachio cake - excellent buttercream but cake texture was a bit dry and not intensely flavorful
Food Fails
*Burrata salad - way too many tomatoes, some underripe, balance of oil and vinegar was off, under and unevenly seasoned, not enough basil
*Short rib with smoked carrots and potato puree - beautiful piece of meat that was cooked correctly but without any seasoning whatsoever. Even trying to add salt and pepper at the table did nothing. The smoked carrots were so overwhelmingly smoky without any other flavor to balance them that they were practically inedible. Potatoes were perfect in texture, but also lacked salt, though I think this was intended because of the flavor intended to be in the meat and carrots.
*The little strawberry cookie at the end was poorly executed.
I don't post reviews like this often anymore, nor do I usually say anything to staff about food. But I opted to politely inform them of the short rib issue as that needed to be pointed out to the chef. They offered another dish but I had too much food already, they offered for me to take a dish home, but I'm staying at a hotel, they offered another short rib but I didn't want more food. Eventually they brought a bottle of wine for us to take home and that seemed very sweet. So again, I wasn't going to review.
4 things that pushed me to irritation:
*Service was super off throughout the night. Drinks and meals never synced and there was a ton of dead time where we didn't know why no one was checking in on us. Either the way they divide their process has poor communication, or they were understaffed. It wasn't super busy and the front bar was empty about halfway through the meal, so I'm guessing it was the former.
*Given that it's a pre-fixe menu, I did not like that our waiter kept pushing items without mentioning additional cost. It felt like we had to order a starter and I enjoyed the chips, but nothing was pushed on us last time. When she mentioned specials, I had to ask about upcharges. It should be standard practice to mention those. I asked about a dessert wine pairing and the one she pushed turned out to be $36. I'm sorry, but at that point in the experience, I would not have spent $36 on a dessert wine pour.
*After seeing the check and all of the additional costs, I thought, man, this better be a really nice bottle of wine considering half of my meal was subpar. When I looked at it when I got back to the hotel, it looked like it got pulled out of someone's trunk. I highly doubt this wine is on their menu. It retails from $6-20 a bottle with an average price of $10 depending on where you buy it. So if they're buying this wholesale, I got maybe a $5 "gift". Why couldn't they have just offered to comp some drinks, at least the dessert wine that was ridiculously overpriced.
I'm bummed, this was a total destination restaurant for me where I would come for a splurge. But I think this might be my last experience with The Mountain House.