The Old Warsaw

Amazing food. Made fresh. I ordered a salad (cesar dressing homemade, croutons made in-house). The prime rib eye was made to perfection (seasoning to die for). Cheesecake was full of flavor! Yummy yummy food. Recommended for any occasion (bring the wife or girlfriend but not both at once). I asked the bartender to make me his favorite drink, and he made me an amazing old fashion. The staff were VERY welcoming, and it made me feel like I was visiting my Italian auntie. Don't be discouraged when you walk in and see it not full to capacity. This means your service will be tailored to you and your "date." We're visiting from San Diego and will definitely come back when we're in town!!

Incredible food and very attentive service. It was our first time here and we were made to feel like old friends. I ordered the peppered New York Strip and my boyfriend got the beef Wellington. Steak was melt in your mouth good! The live piano was a plus. Amazing atmosphere and food, highly recommend!

Everything was 10/10. I had the fixed menu that included an appetizer of your choice, entree of choice, and dessert. Which was a really good deal! My appetizer was the fried goat cheese which was sweet, salty, crunchy, and just so delicious! Perfect appetizer. For the entree I got a ribeye which was cooked perfectly, and the potatoes on the side were just as good. I loved all the food but the atmosphere was the best part. The building itself is really pretty, the vibes are great, and there was live piano. A really nice date night vibe.

Hands down not a single thing I could nitpick. We loved every bit of this place. The atmosphere, the food, they are cutting themselves short with the $55/person appetizer, entre, and dessert special. SO good. Give this a try if you’re looking for a nice place to eat.

My husband surprised me for a date night. I can’t say enough great things about this fabulous restaurant. Food was great, atmosphere, service all 10/10.

We had a fantastic dining experience. Ali poured the drinks, huge pours. We had the escargot to start, then paired the lobster thermidor, Steak Diane, and fillet with a nice cab. The lobster bisque was the classic recipe, absolutely fantastic. All classics served in a one of a kind historic atmosphere. This is a bucket list place for all foodies and restaurant coinsures. Highly recommended.

I recently dined at Old Warsaw and it was truly an exceptional experience. The ambiance of the place is nostalgic, evoking memories of simpler times, while the food transported me to culinary bliss. The steak I had was cooked to perfection, bursting with flavor in every bite. It's rare to find a place that not only serves great food but also provides a sense of nostalgia that adds to the overall dining experience. I highly recommend Old Warsaw for anyone looking to indulge in delicious food and a trip down memory lane!

The absolute worst meal I have ever had. I thought there was gonna be a highlight at the end of the meal (the ice cream) but after the second bite of that, bite 3 had hair in it. Starting with the ambience… What a weird environment. We felt like we were in a horror movie, All the way down to a piano player that doesn’t know how to play the piano. Our ears were too busy balancing between poor piano playing and tejano music being blared from the kitchen. The “grilled shrimp” was frozen shrimp that was overcooked and topped with what appeared to be cucumbers, iceberg lettuce and ranch dressing. Ate 1.5 of them out of 5. For entrees we got the filet, steak Diane and lobster thermidor. I am unsure where the lobster thermidor that is pictured in the previous reviews came from… take a look at the picture attached to this review. The item that looks like potato salad was the lobster thermidor 😂. That is also exactly as it was presented to us direct from the kitchen. Looks like food that was just thrown onto a plate from a mass pre-prepared meal pan. The scoop of ice cream that came with the “peach cobbler” tasted good but it unfortunately had several pieces of hair in it. The cobbler itself was just jelly with crumbs sprinkled on top. What a disappointment for a restaurant that has been around for this long. I would not have fed my dogs this food.