Kelly J.
Yelp
I'll start by saying that I wanted to love this place. I had heard great things about it, and a low-key Germantown bar with "super reasonably priced" drinks (according to anyone you talk to) sounded great. So, I've been wanting to check it out since it opened. Finally, this past weekend I got my chance to check out The Pearl of Germantown, and the most I can say is it's an alright spot. I'm not trying to write a bad review, I don't dislike the place, I think it was just a bit lost on me. In some aspects I see the appeal, but for me it just came off as trying too hard.
The décor is definitely kitschy. I know that's exactly what they're going for, but it didn't seem to me that they had found these gems in their grandma's attic and decided to ironically use them in their bar, but rather most likely had spent hours combing flea markets in order to create a hipster dive full of cheap gaudy items. I have to say I rather enjoyed some of the pieces displayed around the bar (they have some cool signage and a neat vintage Playboy spread), but when it gets to the point that you're using glassware that's falling apart (my vintage glassware's glittery painted design was coming off the glass in my hand) to me it just seems like you're trying too hard.
We didn't eat while we were there, as there isn't a very large menu (which we knew going in, so that wasn't a problem at all); however, I did notice the menu board and it didn't seem very cheap to me. One of the draws of this place, according to everyone I've heard talk about it, is how amazingly cheap it is. On the menu board a ham sandwich is $7. Now, I didn't see the ham sandwich, but I think the point of this place is that they're serving no frills, so that price seemed a bit steep to me. The top of the refrigerator behind the bar was covered with small bags of chips ($0.75/each), a bag of white bread, and a jar of peanut butter. I have no idea if they serve peanut butter sandwiches, because that wasn't posted on the menu, but I feel like if you asked they may make you one.
I ordered a sangria, which was made from scratch (no pre-made stuff poured into a glass here), and was really tasty. I'm not sure of all of the ingredients, but when I asked the bartender did mention red wine, cinnamon syrup, and a few other things. Whatever was in there, it was great! And for $5 I think it was pretty reasonably priced, though it was served in a small glass. B ordered a Braxton Golden Cream Ale, and together our total was $11. In the age of often over-priced specialty cocktails, it is hard to beat that price in Louisville, so I've got to agree the drink prices at this spot are good.
After our drinks we headed out, because there isn't much reason to stay unless you're with a group of friends or just feel like drinking for the night, since there's not much food and there's no entertainment besides a jukebox.
I'm glad I finally got to check this place out, and that now I know what it's like, but I have to say I doubt I'll go back without reason. I have some friends who love this spot, and if they ever ask me to come join them there I definitely would, if nothing else for their lovely company and hopefully another glass of that delicious sangria.