The Pie Pizzeria - Midvale

Good mountain of meat pizza but too much cheese and not enough marinara sauce. Dough was tough or knives were very dull. A 12" pizza was plenty for 2. Service is order up front and take a seat. Then return to the front for pickup when called. Prices were good but not cheap.

The Pie Pizzeria in Murray is a no-frills spot that focuses on great pizza and fast service. Stopped in for lunch and went with the Lunch Special – a Slice of the Day Pizza and a salad – and it did not disappoint. The portions are generous, and at $8.49, it’s a rare find these days for a filling meal at a great price. The Slice of the Day was a meatball pizza, and it was tasty, with a solid crust and great flavor. The salad was fresh and added a nice balance to the meal. If you’re in the #SaltLakeCity area and craving good pizza without the fuss, The Pie Pizzeria is definitely worth a stop!

Told the cashier I was doing the 14in build your own then gave the toppings I wanted. When told the price I was shocked and asked if that was right and she said it was. After looking at my receipt I saw I was charged 4.75 for sundried tomatos which are listed under their gourmet toppings but the sign shows that gourmet toppings are 2.75 each. Had a really hard time enjoying the pizza after feeling like I got ripped off. I even looked around and there were not any signs stating the prices had changed.

I like getting light cheese on my normal cheese pizza from here; however sometimes there’s still quite a lot of cheese. This time was absolutely perfect. Please do the light cheese like this everytime! Regardless this is still by far the best pizza place i’ve ever been too. Salads are always super fresh and amazing too!

Honestly, I think this is the best pizza I have ever eaten. The specialty pizzas are creative and amazing. The amount of toppings in the pizza was superb. We got the wise guy pizza and I wish I lived here so I could try them all. This will now be added to the list of usuals for when we visit SLC. $20 for the 14 inch was well worth it with the amount of toppings on the pizza. 10/10 recommended.

I was scrolling for a restaurant close to where we were staying and was more than pleasantly surprised the I saw The Pie! I haven’t been to a pie since college at the U. Thank you for the great memories and amazing pizza!

This visit I have to only give a 3 there was a few things to discuss. I want to say the lady who rang me up was nice and professional and the place was clean. BUT I paid almost $60 plus tip for two pies 14's so smaller size and small salad. The salad was proportioned well but I had a lake at the bottom of water so wasn't drained well at all when made and my pies were doughy yuck :( the bottoms were not even hard very floppy and doughy. The cheeseburger pie had way too much seeds all over it and had no flavor except onions and bacon and seeds. If I pay that kinda money I want cooked pizza and a salad not watered down, Better visits in the past. This one was disappointing :(

When the Midvale The Pie was opened, we were so excited. We have eaten there since it opened because we would go to the U location. This is a good pizza and a great atmosphere. The people that work there are kind and helpful. The pizzas are one of the best in Utah and there is a variety. We usually go for the Chicken bacon ranch an Wiseguy. Their bradsticks are great too.