The Piefather

Hands down probably one of the worst pizzas I have had in my life- do not waste your time or money. I ordered a Margarita, they gave me a flat piece of dough that did not rise, not only that it was completely raw when I took a bite. I sent it back and instead of making a new one they just cooked this one longer, so it was crispier on the outside but still a bit raw inside. They hardly put tomato sauce and put so much cheese that I had to scrape it out. I can truly make better pizza at home- I thought I was being punked when I opened the pie box from how terrible it looked and later tasted.

Good luck here. I’ve fortunately received pizza here 1 out of 3 times. They were so gracious enough to allow me to buy a pie ONCE. Hard to order and bad customer service.

Very greasy but good pizza, they have mikes honey hot which automatically takes any pizza to the next level! Had both the margarita pizza as well as the pepperoni pizza! I’ll take the pepperoni smothered with honey hot on any drunk night!

Fresh and delicious! After having a very disappointing brunch with my friends we headed to the wharf and since we were still hungry decided to try the pizza. I was not disappointed at all crust had a slight crunch but still soft, the sauce was perfect and complimented to gooey cheese and salty pepperoni! We played it safe with pepperoni but i will definitely being going back to try other pies!

This place makes you scan the qr code to order your food and then requires you to leave all your info in their system even doesn't let you process a credit card payment without providing your email address in addition to your phone number. We were never notified via text or email that our pizza was ready and by the time we retrieved it, it was cold! Pizza was decent but not worth it. I won't order here again...

Don’t even try to order with the person working there!? All is online and there is a mandatory %18 for making your pizza. When it’s ready they do not text you even though you put your phone number and email in their system to order. Dystopian future crap. Don’t bother. Pizza is average. Very impersonal staff.

A great place for some deviously good food. The Piefather will make sure you're taken care of for your eating needs. The Piefather pizza will take care of you hunger.

The pizza itself is delicious. My partner and I have gone all the way there just to have it. The Don Corleone is our go-to. We’ve also tried pepperoni and short rib. Both are also very good but Don is still #1. Only knocking a star because you don’t get notified when your order is ready, which is quite annoying.