Fred J
Google
The hotel definitely makes a strong first impression (the lobby gives off that Great Gatsby vibe they’re known for. The lighting, the scent, the furniture), all very elegant and atmospheric. Check-in was smooth and quick, even though it was a busy Friday afternoon. I appreciated how the valet handled our car efficiently during arrival.
That said, the room was a letdown. I booked a premium king (around 400 sq ft) for a birthday weekend getaway and expected something more aligned with the hotel’s stylish lobby. It felt flat and unfinished, like it was renovated without an interior designer. Sparse decor, awkward lighting, and an overall bland vibe. The closet was tiny, the mini fridge was almost hidden, and the room just didn’t feel special, especially for the higher price point. There were a few functional annoyances too: hot water took several minutes to heat up, which became frustrating.
The room was clean and quiet, and housekeeping did a nice job when we requested service. I also appreciated the little touches with folded towels and tissues.
Staff inside the hotel were mostly friendly and helpful, but valet service was inconsistent. One night I waited nearly 30 minutes for my car, and during checkout (while handling dogs and luggage), no one offered to assist. It didn’t feel like the level of service I’d expect from a historic hotel charging premium rates.
Also worth noting: the hotel can get crowded, and when it does, it’s clear that the infrastructure (elevators, valet) gets overwhelmed. For example, during what seemed like a wedding event, the elevators were backed up and we couldn’t find an accessible stairwell to go up. Thankfully, the front desk eventually let us use a service elevator.
Overall, some standout moments: but the room and service inconsistencies made it feel less luxurious than expected.