Wendy F.
Yelp
We haven't been to Red Drum since my pre-Yelping days and decided to give it another try. Though last minute, we secured a table with Resy and dropped the car off at the valet station. (Red Drum offers walk-in dining room seating but encourages reservations).
The dining room is large and dimly lit with the best option for light, a table in front of the glass door leading into the porch. Unfortunately, this was the server's path to outside diners and after 5 nerve racking minutes of that heavy door opening and closing, Joe asked for us to be moved, albeit, to a table with poor lighting.
Our meal was straight forward ... drinks, two starters, two entrees. My Bloody Mary was juicy; Joe's Red was fine; portions were generous and the pricing was, for the most part, competitive. While each dish had the makings of 'fabulous' nothing stood out.
Joe's Tortilla Soup was missing the bite he expected and seemed lacking ingredients to bulk it up. I've tasted better just about everywhere and for $9.00, we agreed it was overpriced and downright disappointing. My peppery Arugula Salad ($13.00) should have been insanely delicious ... loaded with chunks of tart Granny Smith apples, thickly cut, diced bacon, bits of crunchy toasted pecan and pinches of creamy goat cheese ... but again, the dish missed the mark. It was heavily tossed in a dressing, described as honey thyme vinaigrette, but all I tasted was oil. Ugh.
Joe's salmon ($29.00) was prepared as ordered and was a generous portion, perhaps 7 ounces. Served over a corn cake (there was corn, too), it was fine ... but perhaps a bit overpriced, compared to similar dishes/set-ups all around town. My Bucatini ($19.00) with scallops and clams was photo-shoot worthy but again, was underwhelming. The pasta was a perfect al dente and the amount of shellfish was adequate; however, the scallops were clearly not seared and the red chile corn broth was missing the corn and the chile punch anticipated per the menu.
We were actually considering sharing a dessert as I noticed one of my faves, peanut butter cheesecake, but again, I was disappointed when our terrific server, Eric, returned to tell us that it was sold out. Bummer.
I noticed another diner devouring what looked to be juicy burger, plated with a large order of fries and would consider coming back for lighter fare, or maybe, as a brunch option for out of town guests, but for entrees, we'll pass.