The Sandwich Man

Sandwich shop · Doneys

The Sandwich Man

Sandwich shop · Doneys

1

612 S Yearling Rd, Whitehall, OH 43213

Photos

The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null
The Sandwich Man by null

Highlights

Philly cheese steak, Sloppy Joe, and chili dog favorites  

Placeholder
Placeholder

612 S Yearling Rd, Whitehall, OH 43213 Get directions

whitehallsandwichshop.com

$10–20 · Menu

Information

Static Map

612 S Yearling Rd, Whitehall, OH 43213 Get directions

+1 614 230 2501
whitehallsandwichshop.com

$10–20 · Menu

Features

wifi
payment credit card
Tap to pay
reservations

Last updated

Sep 28, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@infatuation

The 20 Best Sandwiches In Miami - Miami - The Infatuation

"This broccoli and cheese sandwich answers the question on everyone’s mind, “What would happen if broccoli cheese soup saw a shooting star and made a wish to become a sandwich?” It has chunks of roasted broccoli, white cheddar, and mozzarella between two crispy slices of bread. There’s also a sun-dried tomato pesto that acts as a condiment. It is crunchy, cheesy, and also a good way to trick yourself into eating broccoli (even if you think you hate broccoli)." - ryan pfeffer, virginia otazo, mariana trabanino

https://www.theinfatuation.com/miami/guides/best-sandwiches-miami
View Postcard for The Sandwich Man

Alpine7907

Google
I went with the Philly cheese steak (add lettuce, tomatoes and jalapeno) and it was one of the best cheese steaks I've had in awhile. There was plenty of steak on the sandwhich, and I could tell that all the veggies were fresh. I also went with a side of Mac and cheese, which was the real deal! Hats off to B for making such a strong 1st impression, where it's a no brainer that I'll have to come back to try more of the items on his menu

Keshana Jones

Google
This my first time visiting this spot! I’m new to the East side area and as soon as I walked in the door I felt the warmth! Once you’ve ordered and the food is ready they are able to bring it to your car or you can’t wait inside (which is a huge plus)! The woman at the front counter was so sweet! The chef was amazing as well! I got a warm turkey sub with fries and a drink and it hit the spot!! I willl be returning again and bring friends 🤗

MRBARBQ 1

Google
Update: Happened to be nearby and decided I would check The Sandwich Man out again. Coincidence that Brian was working by himself again. LOL!! This time I ordered the Sloppy Joe and the Chili Dog again. This time I got Baked Beans and Greens for sides. He deep fries the Hot Dog and then grills it and adds the sloppy Joe mix on top. It makes for a nice slightly crunchy hot dog with a slight crunch to it. The Sloppy Joe was on a premium bun and had great flavor to it. Yummy!!! The baked beans had a slight sweetness to them. Now on to the star of the show which was the Greens. They had a slight bite to them, so tasty with a bit of pork thrown in for extra goodness. This is the type of small business we have to support. Making great food with homemade goodness. Check them out, no disappointment here. Decided to drop in on this place today. It is a really small place but don't let that fool you. I met the owners Brian and Crystal. They have been open for around 3 years. Super friendly people. Brian is a barber by trade but he and Crystal decided they wanted to do something different. They have a small menu that covers a little of everything. I ordered a Sloppy Joe, a Coney dog and Onion Rings. The Sloppy Joe had a good amount of meat on it and the sauce was just a very little sweetness to it, super delicious. The coney dog was deep fried a bit and had some coney sauce and cheese and onion on it. Loved it, very tasty. Also got the onion rings which were outstanding. Love of going to these small places off the beaten path. They are there for the community. Everyone should definitely go check this place out and meet some super nice people.

Quincy Wilkins

Google
The Sandwich Man treated me like I was family. The couple that runs this joint are super friendly and hardworking. The Cheesesteak and Cheeseburger were delicious, they even season the fries perfectly.

P Reviews

Google
This place picked a good name because it caught my eye from my love for sandwiches. It is hidden away within Whitehall, so I can see it being a decent travel for many people. All of the items on the menu looked appealing to me, but the menu needs work. It has items on it without any description of the items. For example, my turkey sub had banana peppers on them. I like banana peppers, but I know a lot of people who don’t and can see that being an issue. I ordered online through the business DoorDash partnership, which created a cold interaction with the person working there. He kept telling me to show him that I accepted the order on DoorDash, and asked if it was my first day since I couldn’t find the button. I then told him that I ordered the food for myself and his demeanor changed completely and was extremely nice and gave me the order. I have heard of DoorDash people scamming businesses so I understand his caution, but it could have been handled better. It would probably be best if he just asked if it’s a carry-out or a DoorDash order. I ordered a turkey sub, coney, and a side of coleslaw. The order was completed in 9 minutes, so keep that in mind if you have a far drive. The food was very good. Probably one of the best conies I have had. It was all very warm and flavorful and had the right balance of everything. If I’m in the area I’d like to try more of their menu.

Ak Allen

Google
A great service with a smile there's multiple option to chooses from to eat. I'm having the cheese coney dog with fries and chicken Wings no sauce.

Bailey V

Google
I found this place randomly on Google.. Wow what a massive win!! My entire family was drooling over every item we ordered. We ordered a lot. How could we not?!?! The menu is simple but large enough to give great options. The staff was kind and smiling. After placing our order we waited in our car. Soon after a staff member brought out our food. When we got home we opened it all up and tasted each thing. The food was amazing. Everything was prepared perfectly, the burgers were cooked thoroughly, the hot food was hot, the cold food was cold. Nothing spilled on the drive home. We ordered the Rams burger, bacon cheeseburger with everything, onion rings, chili cheese fries, sloppy joe, jumbo coney dog with cheese and onions, and a garden salad. We are pretty picky about food and none of us had any complaints. Instead, we can't wait to go back. It will take some time to finish our leftovers 😅 the portions were extremely generous, especially for the $ tag.

Anthony Grandison

Google
Food was great! I had perch and catfish, both were fried perfect and delicious. Sides were good, cabbage and greens were good and potatoe salad tast like moms. Pound cake melts in your mouth. Service was great. Try it you will like it.

Thomas J.

Yelp
Excellent food- the Collard Greens were the best I have ever tasted . The Sloppy Joe was very very good. I can't wait to try so many new things they offer. The service was absolutely wonderful, HIGHLY recommended- AAA+++ Thomas
google avatar

Barry H.

Yelp
Happened to be nearby and decided I would check The Sandwich Man out again. Coincidence that Brian was working by himself again. LOL!! This time I ordered the Sloppy Joe and the Chili Dog again. This time I got Baked Beans and Greens for sides. He deep fries the Hot Dog and then grills it and adds the sloppy Joe mix on top. It makes for a nice slightly crunchy hot dog with a slight crunch to it. The Sloppy Joe was on a premium bun and had great flavor to it. Yummy!!! The baked beans had a slight sweetness to them. Now on to the star of the show which was the Greens. They had a slight bite to them, so tasty with a bit of pork thrown in for extra goodness. This is the type of small business we have to support. Making great food with homemade goodness. Check them out, no disappointment here.
google avatar

Pavel V.

Yelp
This place picked a good name because it caught my eye from my love for sandwiches. It is hidden away within Whitehall, so I can see it being a decent travel for many people. All of the items on the menu looked appealing to me, but the menu needs work. It has items on it without any description of the items. For example, my turkey sub had banana peppers on them. I like banana peppers, but I know a lot of people who don't and can see that being an issue. I ordered online through the business DoorDash partnership, which created a cold interaction with the person working there. He kept telling me to show him that I accepted the order on DoorDash, and asked if it was my first day since I couldn't find the button. I then told him that I ordered the food for myself and his demeanor changed completely and was extremely nice and gave me the order. I have heard of DoorDash people scamming businesses so I understand his caution, but it could have been handled better. It would probably be best if he just asked if it's a carry-out or a DoorDash order. The inside is essentially just a giant kitchen and counter, so carry-out is also the only option. I ordered a turkey sub, coney, and a side of coleslaw. The order was completed in 9 minutes, so keep that in mind if you have a far drive. The food was very good. Probably one of the best conies I have had. It was all very warm and flavorful and had the right balance of everything. If I'm in the area I'd like to try more of their menu.

Kenny R.

Yelp
Great meatball sub,,, as always. Also, love the double meat sub. Always fresh and hot.
google avatar

Ronald ..

Yelp
Has the best sides in town fish on Thursday and Fridays customers service is friendly I believe the ladies name is crystal very nice
google avatar

Min S L.

Yelp
Met the owner of this restaurant, Ms Crystal when placing my order. Location is in a strip mall type area with other businesses, parking can be hard and I went towards the end of the day. Ordered 2 Coney Dogs, onion rings (nothing specular or to write home about-basic onion rings) and cole slaw. Although they have an option for a slaw dog, got it on the side just incase I didn't like it- it is decent . Ms Crystal advised that I call ahead next time and she'd have the order ready, been that it was my first time there (came across this place on Yelp! and I wanted to go in). There is no room to sit/eat in this place. Basically place your order and thats it. they have two reserved spots outside of the location for parking, b/c again- parking can be limited. I may go back and try a sub sandwich just to see what its taking about.

Nathan B.

Yelp
I like small places and this place fit the bill. Nice people, they really paid attention to my needs. The portions though were small for the price, and even though the sandwich bun was toasted it still got soggy.

Tonya S.

Yelp
I was scrolling through yelp trying to find new food spots. And Omg I am so thankful I found this place! They make and I mean the BEST FETTUCCINE CHICKEN ALFREDO W/BROCCOLI I have ever tasted besides my own! And I make Delicious Alfredo O.K! It's 10 all across the board! Only problem is they make it only on Thursday This dish needs to be made on a daily...The workers are so nice the service was fast. This place is Definitely a

Shay E.

Yelp
Absolutely the best spot in the city for comfort food!!! I'm trying to put into words but when I tell y'all everything I've ordered (sloppy joe, walking taco, onion rings) tastes like grandmas cooking!! Very polite workers as well every time I go in; if you can catch them when their open definitely give them a try!!!
google avatar

Anna S.

Yelp
You gotta go to The Sandwich Man! I had the pleasure of meeting THE sandwich man on my visit and he is amazingly nice and friendly. I ordered a slaw dog with cornbread and mac and cheese. Everything was great and super flavorful! I'll definitely be back.

Heather P.

Yelp
Everything we ordered was great! Collards and yams were surprise items on the menu that we enjoyed. Five + stars for friendly service!! Parking options and no indoor seating are only negatives.

Mary Jane M.

Yelp
The owner and his wife are the best! Went in to order for the 1st time and they were amazing! They have a Great menu of items and are adding dinners next month. I can't wait!
google avatar

Ken L.

Yelp
Small little joint by the airport. Oddly fair amount of competition in the area. However the shop stands out of making sandwiches made to order withSalad ingredients. These folks clearly love what they do. I went for the turkey on rye basic sandwich. However piled high. Good bread which we all know makes the sandwich!!!
google avatar

Kenny R.

Yelp
Nice little shop. Had an Italian Sub. Fresh made, fresh ingredients. Not much of a sign, Sets in a small row of shops directly across the street from the Whitehall School Administration Building, just South and across the street from Save-A-Lot.