Mark B.
Yelp
The Silver Darling is located on Pocra Quay with one glass wall facing the North Sea and the other facing the mouth of the River Dee/shipping canal into Aberdeen Harbor and the Nigg Bay Golf course. Either way you have a spectacular view.
We came for lunch on a blustery April day. The tide has just started going out and a pair of porpoises was fishing in the shipping canal. For our lunch, we went straight to the mains and had the "Deep fried haddock in beer batter with homemade chips, roast cherry vine tomatoes, mushy peas & wasabi mayonnaise" and the "Fillet of cod poached in red wine infusion with tender cabbage, smoked pancetta, celeriac potato mousseline & old grain mustard sauce". The server recommended to pair the cod with the "Picpoul de Pinet- Coteaux du Languedoc Domain de lauriers 2011 " and indeed this matched quite well.
Well, the cod was perfectly poached in the red wine, the smoked pancetta added some rich notes along with the cabbage. This was great little dish. The haddock had a tasty crispy crust to got with the very fresh haddock and the wasabi mayonnaise was excellent with the fish and the chips. The mushy peas were a nice break from peas overcooked peas -these still had a little texture and a bright, fresh pea note in the taste.
The Silver Darling (here is the website so you can see the interiors and views: http://thesilverdarling.co.uk/) is clearly aspiring for excellence. Unfortunately, our visit had one major flaw. The servers, confused by which order was supposed to go to what table, set part of our order down in front of another set of guests. Then, after a minute or so realizing their error, the picked the order back and proceeded to just set the same dish in front of us. Well, I don't view this as an adequate level of service from this level of restaurant. They really need to work on their staff training, particularly how to handle rather fundamental mistakes such as this. Hopefully, this was an isolated error in judgment.
Summary:
Excellent Food
Stunning, Unique Location
Service - well, I'll will update my opinion on this if I return. For now, I will just leave the simple report of the problem for your own information as you select where to dine. Certainly, this lapse is why they are not currently getting five stars from me.