Jason C.
Yelp
We had a reservation for my wife's birthday on a Tuesday at 7pm. We ubered so I can't comment on the parking/valet situation.
We were greeted by a couple super friendly hosts & were sat immediately in one of the main dining areas. Our waiter, Travis, was amazing the whole night. Super friendly, helpful, attentive, not overly intrusive. He even helped close off an air vent since my wife was cold. He waited til we were finished with each course before bringing out the next, & kept our waters full all night. The pace at which the food came out was very comfortable for us.
We ordered the fried calamari, the 8oz filet mignon & 16oz ribeye, & we shared the bacon-braised green beans & cream corn with Benton's bacon. The calamari was fried perfectly & was not rubbery or fishy tasting at all. It went perfectly with the remoulade sauce. Our steaks were cooked perfectly & seasoned very well. The cuts of steak were good quality as well - very tender & minimal gristle. We thought the steaks overall were on par with other top steakhouses in the area. I liked the cream corn more, wife preferred the green beans. For dessert, we got to pick a complimentary birthday dessert from the menu so we got the peach cobbler! Really good as well.
Ambiance - this is definitely what makes the restaurant so unique. We enjoyed reading about the history of the house, & our experience felt like we took a step back in time. They had Sinatra, Ella Fitzgerald, Nat King Cole playing in the background. Since we came on a Tuesday night, we pretty much had the entire restaurant to ourselves.
I was initially skeptical after reading some of the lower rated reviews. However, we personally didn't experience any of the things that people were criticizing.
Overall, great food, outstanding service, & really unique dining atmosphere. Highly recommend for a special occasion or date night!