Valaya K.
Google
I recently stayed at both The Westin Resort and Spa in Carlsbad and the Hyatt Seabird in Oceanside, both in California, and the contrast between the two was surprising.
The Westin stands out for its excellent customer service. The staff were consistently quick, attentive, and friendly—truly the highlight of the stay. The room was spacious, the bed incredibly comfortable, and the pillows were great. The overall comfort level was high. That said, the bath towels were old and had an unpleasant smell. The hotel itself isn’t particularly impressive in terms of appearance or design, but it is clean and perfectly adequate.
On the other hand, the Hyatt Seabird is visually far more impressive, with beautiful design and intentional, cozy details in the rooms. Its location near the ocean in Oceanside is a clear advantage, and the overall aesthetic is what you’d expect from a high-end destination. Unfortunately, the customer service fell short of expectations, especially for a hotel that positions itself as a five-star experience. Small touches—like offering proper bottled water—were missing. Instead of premium still or sparkling options (the kind you expect at a luxury property), they offered Costco-style flavored sparkling water, which didn’t match the brand image at all. By contrast, at the Westin I was even welcomed with champagne and a $75 credit for drinks or meals.
The Seabird also had several maintenance and cleanliness issues. There was a strong paint smell in the hallways, a foul odor in the room, and at one point, the shower handle literally came off—which would be funny if it weren’t in a supposed five-star hotel.
Overall, while the Hyatt Seabird wins in terms of design and location, the Westin clearly delivers on service, comfort, and value. If customer service and reliability matter most, the Westin is the better choice. If aesthetics and setting are your priority—and you’re willing to overlook service shortcomings—the Seabird has potential, but it has a long way to go to live up to its five-star claims.