David R.
Yelp
Edit: dropping my review from five to three. Eight hours after checking out, I realized I'd left my $200 Philips Sonicare toothbrush behind. I call and Seth (night mgr) explains the house keeping management is not there at that point, which is understandable as it was late on a Saturday night. He'd leave a message for them to call me in the morning. No call comes, I call back Sunday afternoon. I'm told the lost & found process is housekeeping turns found items into management, management delivers items to "loss prevention", who then calls me. They'd expect that person to be calling me soon, likely Monday. Monday, no call, so I call, am put through to the loss prevention voicemail (ext 2039 with no actual greeting), so I just hope it's correct and leave a message. Tuesday, I call again, this time I'm told the loss prevention person has their weekend on Monday / Tuesday, so it'd be Wednesday. Why did Sunday tell me that person would call me Monday then? Wednesday, no call, call and am told I'd need to speak to Seth again, not sure why, so they put me to his voicemail. No return call Thursday. Friday morning, someone finally answers who can check lost & found, my item is not there. So, waste of two hours of my time in addition to the lost item. What would have happened if I'd left something even more expensive?
---
My BC experience is this property and the Park Hyatt. At the PH, if you're a globalist, you won't be paying resort fees or parking, while at the Westin, regardless of tier, you're paying $35/day for resort fee and $35/day for parking.
Both properties are easy for skiing, the Hyatt is served by a true lift (Centennial Express 6) to real terrain, until daily resort close at 4pm currently. The Westin has a gondola that runs until 5p, but its three minute ride takes you to Lower Beaver Creek Express which shuts down at 3:30p. Lower BC's 3.5 minute ride requires then jumping on Upper BC Express (also 3:30p close) which is a 9.5 minute ride, and then you're finally at a peak that has some non-bunny terrain. So, just getting to two blues and one diamond slope is going to consume seventeen minutes if there are no lines at all. Park Hyatt, walk to the Centennial and its 10 minute ride gets you to a huge part of the main mountain, including after 3:30p so you can get a few more laps in. If you were hoping to get first tracks on a powder day, the Westin is not going to make that possible as you'll be about 30 minutes behind everyone who started at the main village.
Next point of comparison, the breakfast. If you're enjoying complimentary breakfast via Hyatt or Marriott benefits, the Hyatt's is phenomenally better, served as a very premium buffet in the 8100 restaurant, compared to a few pre-planned options in Westin's Maya restaurant.
Both resorts have fantastic ski valet; the Westin valet also seemed to be staffed by the same people every day, which made me feel far better about tipping because I confirmed the communal tip jar is split among the crew I was interacting with every day. At the Hyatt, their ski valet is also excellent, but you'd see all kinds of different people inside and outside, from day to day, and it made me feel bad not being able to tip all of them.
They have self parking, Hyatt does not; costs the same, but if you don't like to hand over your keys, Westin has an advantage.
I stayed in a one bedroom residential suite which was great. The furniture and finishes were clearly more recently updated than the Park Hyatt's fireside suites, and then you add a huge six-seat dining table, full kitchen, washer/dryer, separate bedroom with its own full desk. This room allowed me to accomplish a long work/vacation stay thanks to all the room and space for my wife, my kid, and I to all have our own areas to work and school without bothering one another. There are outlets everywhere. The regular bed and its pillows were one of my best hotel beds ever, and even the pull-out sofa bed my kid slept on was surprisingly comfortable. The kitchen was fully equipped, and I mean not missing a single thing; toaster, blender, cheese grater, every utensil you could need, containers for storing leftovers, etc. The washer/dryer worked great and included detergent plus fabric sheets; we were able to pack far less for our extended stay knowing we could wash our own clothes in suite. The bathroom was well equipped with shower plus bath, and two sinks, but is en-suite, so your main room sofa sleeper guest will require access through the bedroom.
I will note that if you're an early to bed early to rise person, or coming from east coast and need to be up at 5am for work/school obligations, you may want to consider requesting a room not overlooking the pool. Parents seem to use the pool as a replacement for evening baby sitting, so you will get to enjoy teens and pre-teens screaming endlessly until about 9:30p each night when they finally tire out or are called in.