Theo's Midtown

First time visiting based upon son’s recommendation. He takes after me, so he has excellent taste :). Absolutely great meal and lovely waitress, Maddie (make sure to ask her about how the pizzas are cooked, she provides in depth info!). Started with Pesto Chips which were delicious! Got a half Brooklyn, half Niki pizza. Both flavors were outstanding! Try it, you’ll love it.

Great place for lunch if it's not too busy already! Ordered a sausage pepperoni calzone, so good. Probably should've ordered appetizers as it did take a while to get served. It is handmade, so the wait is definitely worth it. Wasn't too bad on the pocketbook either, so I'll be coming back, hopefully beating the rush because parking can be difficult!

Restaurant with a sports bar atmosphere. Great service and the meatball appetizer was so delicious. We ordered a gyro and pepperoni & sausage calzone with fries as a side. All of the food was really good, hubby says sausage had a really good taste in the calzone. It wasn't the best gyro I've had but it was good. Fries were also very good, crunchy with seasoning. We ordered a Greek-style pizza to go. Unfortunately, the crust was cracker-like and not our favorite. We'll definitely stop again for the meatballs!

Really nice local place. The service was helpful,food was hot and flavorful.

My fiancé and I both love Gyros. We googled where to find one and came across Theo’s Midtown. It’s a small restaurant/bar with a wonderful atmosphere. Our waitress was real sweet and our food came out fast and tasted amazing! The gyro is so filling, I couldn’t finish the last few bites.

Came in the evening for dinner. Was a bit busy and not much parking space outside. Make sure you come in hungry and you will leave satisfied and with left overs. Come get the hummus and the margarita pizza!

Had a Greek side salad and a ceaser side salad with a Bus Stop pizza. It was so good! We had it thin crust not hand tossed and it was the perfect amount of crisp in each bite!. We sat at the bar so service was good and Jasmine checked on us frequently. Looking forward to trying the extensive menu of other pizza combos and calzones!

A good Greek restaurant and Pizzeria. The service is excellent and we got our food in under 10 minutes. Great Greek Salad. Great Greek Fries. Great Gyro Sandwich with Chicken. Good 50th State (Hawaiian) Pizza. The pizza was super hot with delicious fresh toppings and ingredients. It was a typical Greek pizza that may not appeal to all, but it was good. The crust is not my favorite, but not bad. Nice atmosphere with a historic building feel. I recommend going during off peak hours (after lunch rush or after dinner rush) because it can be a little noisy during the rush. Nice outside seating area with table umbrella. Pleasant dining outside when the weather is nice. Outdoor speakers may be tuned to the ball game.