Mikaela B.
Yelp
Okay... fair warning this is a really mixed bag here.
We stopped in around 2:00 on a Saturday fiercely hungry after a distillery tour and tasting at Mayberry Spirits. I knew the pizza was going to hit the spot. We wanted to order some snacks as well.
The lady taking our orders was not very friendly, and we'd come to find out, not very efficient either. I paced my order for the pub pretzels, shishito peppers, and a meat pizza. The pizzas are fairly small (albeit affordable) and so it's best to get multiple or get one plus some snacks if you're sharing. The pub pretzels were really good! I liked the mustard dip, but I think they could've done more with the presentation. It was just dolloped on the plate - I would've preferred maybe a bowl, and maybe have a beer cheese option! The taste was great though. The shishito peppers, I had almost identical thoughts. They served it with Gouda cheese which was tasty, but the slices were kind of messy and it just wasn't really cohesive with the peppers. I think some kind of sauce with the peppers would've been a great choice! The charcuterie was okay, but again, I didn't love the presentation. Also swap the Ritz for some artisan crackers!
On to the pizza! There was 5 of us, and we had ordered 3 pizzas. The other 2 pizzas in my group that my friends had ordered never came. One of my friends simply got a refund as we'd been there for quite some time. My other friends asked for theirs to go, but we ended up smashing it at the table because we were still hungry. The pizza they boxed up for them wasn't the pizza they ordered.... They had ordered a bbq pork pizza with jalapeños and we got a bbq chicken pizza. It was fine - it was still good and we were still pretty hungry. I honestly think it was a fluke and the person taking orders just didn't put their order in. I think that they handled our issues fairly well, and did right by us as far as correcting it goes.
I would definitely come back and give it another shot because the pizza we had was REALLY good. I like that they had some cider options and seltzers too. Convenient downtown location and plenty of parking nearby.