Ti Amo Eagle

Permanently Closed

Ti Amo Eagle

Permanently Closed

Italian nachos, strawberry chicken, stuffed chicken

Information

94 Market St, Eagle, CO 81631 Get directions

$30–50

@infatuation

132,814 Postcards · 3,234 Cities

Ti Amo Review - Eagle-Vail - Vail - The Infatuation

"This Italian restaurant is located in a quiet corner of Eagle-Vail, and is pretty charming once you get past the strip mall entrance. The small bar only has several seats, but it’s exactly where you want to be—if not, there are some cozy banquette-lined nooks throughout the space. The best and most unique dish on the menu is the pollo alle fragole, or strawberry chicken. While it might sound like a Chopped challenge gone wrong, the chicken tastes great with a pop of bright berry flavor, red onions, red pepper flakes, and a brandy cream sauce, all over angel hair pasta. If you need a basic Italian lesson, “ti amo” means “I love you,” so it naturally makes sense to go here for a special date night after a day of hitting the slopes." - Kim Fuller

https://www.theinfatuation.com/vail/reviews/ti-amo

Ti Amo Eagle

Inspirational G.

Google

So freagin’ great!! We came to have some family time after a long day of landscaping part of our front yard together. I had the best Italian nachos I have ever eaten!! And I try them everywhere…the flavors, the amount of food, the flavors, the toppings, did I mention the flavors!??! I want to come back and try more. BTW, my beautiful bride had the grouper pasta special amd it was top notch also!!! Mi Amo ti amo.

Jozef W.

Google

Excellent place to get some Italian food. Had a nice red wine while there that had great taste. The bread before the meal was outstanding and made fresh at their other location. I was not a fan of the Caeser salad as the dressing and cheese were subpar. I also thought it was overpriced for what you got. The stuffed chicken was excellent and the red wine sauce on it was out of this world. The Nutella crepe for dessert was pretty good but the vanilla ice cream was outstanding and I'd probably just get that for dessert next time. Service was fast and friendly and restaurant looked relatively new and was clean. Overall great experience.

Andy

Google

Wow, on par with the plaza of another mid to horrible food in Eagle. Olive Garden is cheaper and better tasting than Ti Amo Eagle. By far the smallest veal patty I’ve seen to date mixed with a lukewarm warm noodle etc. when you’re hungry you’ll eat anything, but I’ve had tastier MREs in the field. The service was nice and pleasant and the decor inside was a mixture of painting fake bricks and ancient posters in mood lighting.

Da Huaba S.

Google

Guys.......really..........Italian Nachos? Go to Italy and try to find this anywhere.... Not everything with cheese and tomatoes finally turns into Italian food. Italian is the best kitchen in the world, with thousands of flavors, dishes. But for sure Nachos are not even close to that. Leave them to Mex food. Why not just serve Italian food as Italian restaurant?

Aubrey G.

Google

Simply delicious! Amazing flavors, great service. Highly recommend. There are two locations, and make a reservation it can get busy. 10/10!!!!!

Mark R. G.

Google

Excellent service and excellent food! Hailey took great care of us. Scaloppini Di Pollo was delicious and would highly recommend it. I'd never had Vail Brewing Company's Gore Creek IPA, and even though it's in a can, it was very tasty. Very light citrus taste and a nice creamy foam. The Creme Brulee was satisfactory. Would recommend and we'd go back.

eric O.

Google

My wife and I just had a lovely date night here. Everything was wonderful. Best Italian meal I’ve had in many months. Great service. Highly recommended.

Pamela S.

Google

Good service but the food was so disappointing. We ordered a vegetarian spaghetti and a 4-meat fettuccine as entrees. The fettuccine meat sauce had no flavor distinction other than beef burger despite having 4 flavors from the menu description. I could have made this dish using Ragu and onion and saved $29. The veggie spaghetti was a salt bomb with olives, raw tomatoes and a fish oil flavor that was inedible after 4 or 5 bites due to the saltiness and fish aftertaste. That spaghetti was over $35. All salads were separate and if you wanted gluten free options they charged another $6 for already highly priced dishes. Expect to pay at least $80 and probably more like $100 for 2 people should you want any beverage or appetizer along with your meal. Sorry folks. Maybe your experience will be better.

David C.

Yelp

The oso bucco was amazing last night. This was one of the specials. I would recommend it.

Josh A.

Yelp

Randomly ended up in Eagle after a canceled flight and had a really great meal here--classic Italian fare done well, very friendly staff, and a cute ambience. Would absolutely come back!

Laney G.

Yelp

The food was mediocre and unappetizing for an Italian restaurant. Who serves green risotto on a plate? Bolognese looked like it was put through a food chopper. One thing, the eggplant parm was very good but it is not on the menu. You have to ask for it. Don't order the eggplant appetizer. All sauce with a few slices of thin eggplant. All the items are very very overpriced for the quantity and quality. The bench seats were so uncomfortable. Cheap sliced loaf bread - only 1 baguette slice per person and it was the end piece! The service was good. I would not recommend this place. It would be a waste of money.

Lisa B.

Yelp

Food was excellent. Service was the worst we have experienced in a long time Our server, Kelly, was most unfriendly unhelpful and unwelcoming. We had remembered this as an old favorite but probably won't ever go again. Customer service still matters.

Clan R.

Yelp

Huge platter which did not live up to its high price, made me feel sick. Tables and chairs were uncomfortable as well, disappointing.

Melty M.

Yelp

Food poisoning from this place I have been sick for three days, not a fan. Worst experience I have had in a long time. The waitresses were very polite but the food was not it. I recommend any other place than this, plus the tables are collapsable and cheap covered by a table cloth. For the amount of money they charge you would expect better dining. Lol.

Charles S.

Yelp

Food poisoning - sick all night after a Halloween dinner - ravioli pescatore - ugh! Disappointing.

Kreig J.

Yelp

This place has amazing Italian food. It is very cozy atmosphere with very friendly staff. I would definitely visit this restaurant over and over.

Jill S.

Yelp

I am sadly writing my first poor review in hopes that the establishment will step up their game. My son and I ordered take out tonight, Caesar salad (bitter browning lettuce), spaghetti with sausage and marinara (no complaints there) and a chicken parmesan (over cooked un breaded chicken) my worst chicken parm ever and it was 90$ with tip, not worth the money!!...this was my second attempt eating here hoping it would be better....sadly I was not. I will not recommend nor will I dine there again

Sarah W.

Yelp

This place makes their food with love! Local place worth trying out if you're looking for homemade Italian food. Didn't have chances to snap pics of when I've dined in because I eat it too fast, it's that good! Got some risotto to go the other day and it was a hearty portion worth the $. Yummy complimentary bread too

Kim H.

Yelp

All of our dishes were extremely salty. Not acceptable at all for prices of 30.00 to 32.00 a plate. Small portions also. Very expensive for just pasta and no salad. Average, not special.

Terri J.

Yelp

The clams I ordered were like rubber...all of them. My husband ordered a pasta dish that was so spicy he could only eat half of it. We sat for 15 minutes before we waved a waitress to give us our check. Used to be our favorite. Sad!

Geoffrey D.

Yelp

Good food, great staff and a nice wine list. A great local restaurant! Nice interior as well! Thanks

Melissa M.

Yelp

This restaurant is a new- found gem! We love the other location in Eagle-Vail too but this is as good or better! Dishes we tried were outstanding- - starter fried calamari with a spicy tomato dipping sauce is addictive. Pasta dishes - shrimp one and the TiAmo specialty are delish. Profiteroles! Yum. Service is warm and friendly. Plus location is easy off I70 and roomier and brighter than the other location.

Alex M.

Yelp

Tucked behind the AT&T store across from city market you will find this little hidden gem! Small restaurant with BIG Italian dishes! The food here is literally so good you will not be disappointed!

Nate S.

Yelp

Just like their location in Eagle-Vail. Best Italian in the valley. Nice intimate setting.

@infatuation

132,814 Postcards · 3,234 Cities

Ti Amo Review - Eagle-Vail - Vail - The Infatuation

https://www.theinfatuation.com/vail/reviews/ti-amo

Ti Amo Eagle

Inspirational G.

Google

Jozef W.

Google

Andy

Google

Da Huaba S.

Google

Aubrey G.

Google

Simply delicious! Amazing flavors, great service. Highly recommend. There are two locations, and make a reservation it can get busy. 10/10!!!!!

Mark R. G.

Google

eric O.

Google

My wife and I just had a lovely date night here. Everything was wonderful. Best Italian meal I’ve had in many months. Great service. Highly recommended.

Pamela S.

Google

David C.

Yelp

The oso bucco was amazing last night. This was one of the specials. I would recommend it.

Josh A.

Yelp

Randomly ended up in Eagle after a canceled flight and had a really great meal here--classic Italian fare done well, very friendly staff, and a cute ambience. Would absolutely come back!

Laney G.

Yelp

Lisa B.

Yelp

Clan R.

Yelp

Huge platter which did not live up to its high price, made me feel sick. Tables and chairs were uncomfortable as well, disappointing.

Melty M.

Yelp

Charles S.

Yelp

Food poisoning - sick all night after a Halloween dinner - ravioli pescatore - ugh! Disappointing.

Kreig J.

Yelp

This place has amazing Italian food. It is very cozy atmosphere with very friendly staff. I would definitely visit this restaurant over and over.

Jill S.

Yelp

Sarah W.

Yelp

Kim H.

Yelp

All of our dishes were extremely salty. Not acceptable at all for prices of 30.00 to 32.00 a plate. Small portions also. Very expensive for just pasta and no salad. Average, not special.

Terri J.

Yelp

Geoffrey D.

Yelp

Good food, great staff and a nice wine list. A great local restaurant! Nice interior as well! Thanks

Melissa M.

Yelp

Alex M.

Yelp

Tucked behind the AT&T store across from city market you will find this little hidden gem! Small restaurant with BIG Italian dishes! The food here is literally so good you will not be disappointed!

Nate S.

Yelp

Just like their location in Eagle-Vail. Best Italian in the valley. Nice intimate setting.

Ti Amo Eagle

Information

Postcards

Media

Ti Amo Review - Eagle-Vail - Vail - The Infatuation

You might also like

Ti Amo Review - Eagle-Vail - Vail - The Infatuation