Chaunce S.
Yelp
We had high hopes. Tin Cup, on the corner of Rice and Maryland in the North End, is a neighborhood landmark, in part owing to its iconic sign (restored a few years back after lightning strike).
Apparently the previous owners took the hint from god and folded the business.
To appreciate what the new Tin Cup is like, I just need to point out what the old Tin Cup was like. A windowless concrete tub full of Michelob Light swillers and pull tabs. Depressing. I believe they offered Totino's-type pizza for the bar menu.
During the renovation, I spoke with Ray over at Mike's Texaco (who is also on St. Paul District 6 and owner of one of last full-serve service stations). He was pretty excited about the reopening of Tin Cup because he said eating at Mama's was catching up to him as he pointed to his waist.
Now Tin Cup is reopened, complete with windows. The interior is so much brighter than before that it made me smile as I walked in to think that the Rice Street redevelopment was slowly improving the quality of local restaurants.
Picky, picky, but they lack a theme, in terms of both decor and menu. Part bar, part steak house, part hamburger joint. I think a clear direction would help sort them out.
The server, who could barely keep his hands out of his front pockets, raved about the juicy lucys, so my wife ordered that and I ordered the ribs. The ribs were meaty enough and tender, albeit a tad fatty, but I suspect they use bbq sauce out of the bottle, so nothing interesting there. They served a side of homemade potato chips, and those were nice little treat. Not too greasy, yet crisp.
My wife's juicy lucy -- the one with bleu cheese -- was sadly so-so. For one thing, the bun was a soggy mess. The hamburger was over done, sort of chewy (and I know cause I stole some bites).
So, alas, we have no need to return there until we hear of how they correct course. It's no surprise to me that the owner, in this Pioneer Press article (http://bit.ly/9Eqr4P), cites his favorite restaurants as Don Pablos, Outback, and Chilis. If those are your favs, then definitely check out the Tin Cup.