Tomasino's Pizza Downtown

We got there at the right time. They filled up quick while we were there. Fantastic food. Mac & Cheese Fries are a must. My wife and I popped in for lunch on Sunday. Split the mac & cheese fries and each ordered the lunch special which was two slices and drink for $10 (you can substitute the drink for a side I believe). Our server was awesome! She was working her butt off! She deserves a raise. She is an all-star. She told us her name and unfortunately I have forgot it. That is my bad. Go get some! We will be back. Pretty sure there is some type of pizza contest I may have to look into

1st time here and the service superb. Our server Rose omg, so sweet and attentive. We got the garlic knots and 14 inch pie (pepperoni). Pie was crunchy, the cheese gooey and melted perfect, pepperoni awesome. Let's just say, this is now top on our list. We are definitely returning.

Rose was our service and she made us feel so welcomed! I was unsure if I’d enjoy the Mac and cheese with fries but when I tell you I devoured that plate. The pizza is better then New York pizza. 5 stars!

This is what they call the Mechanic with half no olives and mushrooms!! The pizza basically had one half olives only and NO mushrooms at all. $31 dollars for a horrible meal. They used to be good but really lost it… sad! Never again

I love it the food is great and the staff better I will not change the way I feel about this place even though today was a bad experience I’m going to believe it’s a minor set back on staff. Hardest garlic knots ever

This place has a very cool ambiance with the dark lighting and "mob" motif. My wife and I took advantage of the free drink with two slices deal. She got two margarita slices and I got two slices of "The Butcher" loaded with pepperoni ham sausage bacon and meatball meat. As a native New Yorker,. I'm very critical of any pizza that doesn't live up to my Brooklyn standards. The pizza is scrumptious and the meat portions generous but the crust is a tad too soft and not enough crunch to it. That said, the service is excellent the price fair and food flavorful and delicious.

I’ve been coming here for years!! The second the pizza came out, I knew that the management had changed. Can someone please explain to me why a 14 inch pepperoni pizza with a few toppings is $26? Absolutely ridiculous!!

Called in 2 pizzas at 8:45pm on a busy Saturday night. They were ready in 15 minutes, exactly as I was told. The staff were VERY inviting and courteous. The pizzas were perfect with ample toppings. The crust was still crunchy after the 15 minute ride back to the hotel!

Stopped in to grab a slice of pizza. We were in the mood for the bianca pizza, but they were out of slices. No worries there were 4 of us so we ordered a large pizza figuring we would bring home the extras. That was our first mistake since it was so good we kept eating and had no left overs and just full and happy bellies!! They have a few booths inside and the staff is very attentive for a busy as they get with those inside, pick-ups, and food delivery services. Nothing fancy to see, but clean and comfortable for some great pizza. They have lots of different specialty pizzas to try as well and will try to force myself to try something else on my next visit.

We just moved to the area so currently trying to find everything locally that would be our go to restaurant wise. We got a Greek salad and Margherita pizza. The service was great even with them being clearly slammed. The salad was on point, one of the better that I have had mixing the Italian style into the Greek. The pizza lacked a lot of flavor and we even got it with the balsamic glaze which was odd. Visually it looked great, it just didn't have anything to it that stood out. I will say the side of marinara was some of the best I have ever had. So not great, but not so bad I wouldn't give them another try with a different pizza off the menu.

Loved the mama moozarell pizza and I'm a New Yorker. It had a sweetness that wasn't expected but amazing.

Tomasinos on E. Colonial in Orlando left much to be desired with their cheese pizza. Despite purchasing two slices, I couldn't even get through one. The crust lacked the desired crispness and was disappointingly tough. The cheese tasted old, and the sauce didn't impress either. Unfortunately, this experience won't bring me back for another visit.

We had slices of the cheese pizza, Bianca pizza and the Pepperoni. All were scrumptious but our favorite of the 3 was the Bianca. Then we had an order of Pasty's Fries - pesto with Parmesan & Pecorino cheese that my granddaughters even though they were full could not stop eating. If you try anything besides the Pizza treat yourself & try the fries. WE WILL BE BACK.

Tomasino's received their 5 stars before I even walked into the restaurant. The excellent service began via direct message on Instagram. I wrote inquiring about the existence of a lunch menu. Not only did whoever is in charge of their social media respond in a short amount of time, they went out of their way to photograph a lunch menu to send me since it was not readily available online. I immediately headed their way because of this prompt service. Then I arrived to the quaint pizzeria and was pleasantly impressed with the food too. I ordered the pasta lunch special (penne and Alfredo). I added the side of meatballs. The pasta is accompanied by a generous sized salad and THE BEST GARLIC KNOTS I've had in Orlando. The restaurant has about 8 booths, limiting the number of guests that may dine in. There are a few outdoor tables. But the bulk of the patrons received their orders to go. My server (Gia I believe) was kind and took good care of all the seated tables. I'll definitely be back.

Ordered a 14" pizza with pepperoni, green peppers, and onion. Pizza toppings were sparse and the pizza was not 100% done. Payed 32.95 for one pizza... definitely not worth the money. I also purchased and Italian sub. Bread was awful, it was no more than a ham and cheese sandwich. The "special sauce" was a vinegar based hot wing sauce. Not good at all. French fries were awful. Total tab for an Italian sub, order of French fries and a pizza was $55. Will not eat there again.

Five stars for consistent flavor and my favorite pizza joint in orlando! The inside is very small so if they are busy you will wait awhile but I've only had one time where service was horrendous but I always give another shot and hasn't happened again. My go to is the white pizza aka Bianca and add bacon. It's delicious every time. Just the right amount of garlic, cheese, and other spices.

A bit of a whole-in-the-wall, was looking for good pizza in the area and this came up. Ordered takeout online, the menu is fun & attention grabbing.There's a handful of tables inside to dine-in. Delicious pizza and the garlicky cheesy knots were amazing!

Excellent pizza. Love the crust. Margherita pizza was very good. Friendly front counter personnel. Pizza was ready in 25 minutes.

They have THE BEST Bianca pizza in town. Hands down. We have never dined in, so I can't speak to that, but takeout is always speedy and the pizza fresh and hot. We have tried Bianca pizzas around town for years trying to find our favorite. Although there are many runners up, this one blows them out of the water. The size is huge too. Plenty of ricotta which is a must on Bianca pizza. The service has always been friendly when we pick up, as well, which is appreciated. If you're in the market for a good Bianca/white pizza, please give this one a try!

Great restaurant great pizza! We ordered a 14 inch white and an 18 inch mechanic. They brought out my 18 inch mechanic and said that there was a bubble in the pizza dough that it burst so it left a part of the pizza without dough underneath, they said they had just brought me this, so I'd have something to munch on until they made me a new one without me even asking. both pizzas tasted great outstanding service I recommend this place to anyone.

As a New York pizza lover born and raised, this place is pretty dang good. Pizza is awesome and definitely knocks a lot of other pizza places out of competition. If you're looking for NY style pizza done well, check this place out. The walls inside tell you such a story, I will definitely be coming back soon!

Came here on my work break and the place has Great garlic knots and pizza slice is so big Also has very friendly and fast customer service , the place is so cute and has a clean atmosphere would totally recommend and bring more of my people here

Great french fries Wish that the menu reflected the lunch prices

Best pizza around by far! I am difficult to please when it comes to pizza as I come from the Mecca of pizza - upstate NY!

People frequently ask me for my favorite white pizza spot in Orlando. Tomasinos is ALWAYS towards the top of that list. I ordered the ricotta me crazy.. Yoooo honest, look at those freaking huge balls of ricotta!! If you're a ricotta fan, this is the pizza for you. I did add peperoncino to the lest and pineapple to the right. Yes, pineapple goes on pizza. So, about the pizza... It tastes better than you'd except. Even if you expect a great tasting pizza, this would exceed it. Not too much sauce and done to a perfect temp. If I had one knock on it, it would have to be the balls of ricotta fall off if you don't pick up your slice carefully. This isn't the first time, and it won't be the last I've ordered this pizza.

Love Tomasino's! My go to is a classic cheese pizza and the bianca. Favorite pizza place in Orlando hands down.

I was craving their pizza so much I forgot to take a pic. Enjoyed 2 slices of pepperoni. Great for delivery or pickup. They also have a few booths inside for some local intimate dining.

Anytime I see fried mozzarella on the menu, I think it's a must to order! So obviously I ordered the fried mozzarella and they come out looking like empanadas. But don't get confused they taste AMAZING! The cheese is super thick and melted to perfection. Also tried the chicken Parmigiana and that wasn't too bad either. The chicken did seem a little bland but the marinara sauce helped it out. It's a pretty large sub that can be easily shared between two people. P.S If you like playing with your food, then I highly recommend trying to do a cheese pull to see how far it goes.

The first time I tried Tomasino's Pizza was back in 2011. The Chicken Tomasino... Man, oh man. That creamy Tomasino's sauce is EVERYTHING. I swear they need to bottle it, it's that good. I have gotten that dish multiple times, and I absolutely love it. The garlic knots are really good also as is the Greek salad. I've tried their pies, and they're decent. The pizza is pretty good, but in my humble opinion... the Chicken Tomasino is where it's at. If you try this place for any reason at all, you have to get at least one order of that pasta dish. You won't regret it.

Best Pizza in Orlando! I had a classic pepperoni pizza and it was the bomb.com! Will be ordering from them again

My faith in good old fashion Italian has been restored! I was craving a Calzone, but after several terrible versions in Utah I was wondering if restaurants forgot what a true Italian Calzone was. Coming back to Florida, I saw this restaurant saying they are a New York style pizza place. Once I walked in, I knew I had arrived to the real deal, you could smell they garlic and oregano in the air. The service was excellent, se hablo Español, and the food was amazing!

Wow! I love their pizza. I grew up in Queens, lived in New Haven, and also lived in Chicago. I've had my fair share of pizza and this place didn't disappoint. Great local pizzeria in my opinion.

Ayyy, one of our goto pizza spots here!! We've done them once or twice every two weeks over the last ten years or so and Love them though sometimes often enough you'll unfortunately get a three or four star pizza out of them ...but it's worth it for when it's Awesome. They used to be a little more expensive than the other guys but we found them to be worth it for the quality. You can taste the difference. Though home of the fun-sized 18" pizza we find the 14" gets cooked up better more often. They do a pretty good Greek salad and we like the garlicky knots along with that Big Shot meatball app. Yumn.

If you enjoy thin crust crust pizza then you'll enjoy Tomasino's. Honestly though they have an amazingly good meatball sub that I order quite often.

They're ok for a basic pizza I guess. They really lack on the tomato sauce. They do have a decent crust though. I wont go back not because they're horrible just there are better places to go

This establishment plays on a gangster vibe and has the servers wearing fedoras and cheesy (no pun intended) T-shirts with a tie printed on it. Maybe the fedora topped ensemble wouldn't be so bad if the servers wore dress shirts with suspenders and maybe a tie while sporting the hat. But it definitely is a definitive look, I will give it that. Coming from New Jersey, I like to think I know good pizza. So I swung by to try a slice. My opinion? This pizza is ok. It could use a bit more seasoning and maybe was a tad overcooked (I like a "well done" pizza, but I hadn't ordered it well done and this was beyond "well done," but still ok (I guess it is a nice way of saying mediocre). They did have a few options with various toppings, but I went for a plain slice. The price was ok for a slice ($2.66 out the door), but looking at their "specials," they seemed a bit high. One special was two 18" pizzas with one topping each for $37.99. The price for an 18" cheese pizza is $17.99. The "special" isn't such a special and the 18" pizza is a bit on the high side (again, only my opinion). Finally, service, while not rude, was not engaging. After placing my order, I kind of stood there for quite a bit until finally my slice was brought out. A final plus for here. The red and white checked wax paper between the pizza and paper plate was a nice touch.

Asked for the baked ziti with as much cheese as they could put on it. Ordered to go so didn't see it until we got home. When I opened the container I almost cried because it was so beautiful. I feel seen. These are my people. They understand how to load ziti up with cheese. I love this place!

So good! We LOVED the garlic cheesy knots! Would definitely recommend to anyone and want to order again soon!

I actually fell in love with this place bc of the NYC fill that you get when you enter the restaurant. The decor is what really has me intrigued. Soon as I stepped in there I felt like I was in one of the boroughs. The food was great. I think I got the ravioli dinner. Excellent!!

Ordered this delivery and really wanted to like it more than I did. The garlic knots were pretty good - perfectly baked, just too big and bready for me to eat much of. Just a suggestion but if they were to make cinnamon rolls as a dessert with those, I'll bet they would be astronomically delicious. (And I don't even really like cinnamon rolls!) I only saw the door dash menu so maybe they do serve those, not sure. The high point for me though was the marinara that came with the knots, very tasty and full of texture. I ended up using it on my pizza. I had got a side of Alfredo sauce to try too, didn't care for it, not much flavor as far as Alfredo goes, kind of oily. The pepperoni and cheese pizza was better than the mechanic/supreme, can't remember exactly what it was called. Excellent dough, tastes like they make it in house. The pepperoni pizza was cooked well, the supreme could've used a min or two more, but the toppings on both were plentiful! There wasn't really much pizza sauce on either one, so the taste was just kind of meh to me until I added some of the knots marinara. On the description for door dash it said pepperoni and sausage on the supreme pizza but this one had pepperoni and some kind of maybe ham? or maybe it was a sliced beef? Not sure but I didn't care for whatever it was. Overall it wasn't bad pizza, it just wasn't great either. It did get done and headed towards us pretty quickly tho!

Dani was an incredible waitress who lead us to a great Butcher pizza with sausage, meatball, ham, ground beef and peppers!!! The garlic knots to start were excellent as well!!!

Fantastic pizza joint. Maybe it was because i haven't had pizza for few months but man o man, that was an amazing bite of food. Located somewhere in Orlando, it's in a plaza somewhere, adjacent to a Chik-fil-a? We were supposed to go to Chik for chicken sandwich but i wanted local Orlando grub. Thank you Yelpers! The pizza was fantastic, their original Bianca pizza with eggplant was so damn good!! My friends and I were fighting over the last slice and i lost it (sad face). We also got tiramisu to go. It was also really good, the layers were (wait for it) MOIST! Yes yes, we all hate that word but it's perfect for Tiramisu. The layers were soaked with espresso and mascarpone. By far, my favorite cheat meal. I'll surely be back for more

I had this place bookmarked to try and did so tonight. We ordered delivery through BiteSquad. I love Italian food but can be picky about it. This place definitely impressed me! I ordered chicken tomasino and my boyfriend ordered cheese ravioli. I also chose a side Caesar salad and we got an order of cheesy garlic knots. Food arrived still piping hot. I thought meals came with one garlic knot and was surprised to see an entire container of garlic knots in addition to the cheesy knots we ordered. I'm not complaining; those will be coming with me to share with friends this weekend! The knots were really good and had a perfect texture. The side salad was a generous portion and included shaved Parmesan which was a nice touch. I tasted my boyfriend's ravioli. The cheese filling was flavorful and had a nice, creamy texture. My chicken tomasino was delicious. The pink sauce is very good and the fresh mozzarella melted on the chicken was also very tasty. I will definitely be trying more menu items!

My mom, who moved to Orlando from New York City back in 2003, told me about this pizza place. She said it was New York style and it was good. I was like "Sure, ma. Whatever you say." Today was my time here and she was right! I have never had pizza this good in Florida! You can feel the strength of the crust and it folds like a slice back home. Even the sauce is good! How they do it, I am not sure. I had a plain cheese slice with a glass of water. It's almost as if they use New York City water for their food and serve local water for drinking. I don't know how they do it, but they are doing it well. Mariah was our server and she was very pleasant. Her customer service is on point. I will probably come back one last time before going home in a few days. Nice job, Tomasino's!

Yummy pizza, my favorite is the white pizza, aka Bianca's pizza. We normally call for pick and it's super fast. We are there one and it's very casual place I do prefer to go.

I had a chance to try Tomasino's catering at a recent charity event and it was wonderful. It was a nice selection of food and based on this experience, I will be visiting the restaurant and also considering them when I need a tray of food for a party. We started out with the a nice side salad. I liked that it had plenty of chopped vegetables alongside the lettuce and grape tomatoes. I chose the oil and vinegar. To me it the flavor was like a tasty house iIalian dressing. We also had the penne with marinara and penne alfredo. The marinara was a nice sauce with chunky tomatoes. The standout for me was the alfredo. I am not a fan of this sauce because it can either be runny or two rich for me. This was P-E-R-F-E-C-T. Wow - it had great flavor without being cloying and not too cheesy. I would order a pan of this for a party without a doubt. We also enjoyed meatballs. These were large sized with plenty of meat but what set this entree apart was the chunky tomato sauce and the slathering of cheese. Great choice. The garlic knots were small pillows of bread brushed with butter and garlic. The dessert was a cannoli . This Italian treat was given to my husband because he did not get to come. They were sprinkled with powder sugar and chocolate chips. Very good twist on a traditional sweet. This to me seemed to be authentic New York style Italian food and I am just wondering why I have not tried this place before.

Normally the food is great here. Was very disappointed when we got home with the order and it was very burnt. We had to cut around it to make it eatable. I am very surprised that someone would let this go out the door and think this was eatable. We were only able to eat the inside of the calzones.

They use quality ingredients. We usually order a split 18 inch pizza (8 large slices) and a Greek salad. We sometimes get the cheese cake which is incredibly good. It's tons of food and usually lasts us 3-4 meals. We received a coupon booklet in the mail on NYE which expired the same day. They wouldn't honor the coupons the day afterward. But if you're able to use them, definitely great deals. One was for $10 off an order of $30 or more. One was for free garlic knots with purchase of an 18 inch pizza. We order from Tomasino's about twice per year... it's definitely one of the better pizza places in town.

Man, if you are looking for some REAL NY pizza, come here. The manager was SO AMAZING to us! He treated us like family and even threw in some free garlic bread because he has to wait a little (5 min). Such a pleasure to come to this Restaurant!! Desert was Bussin' Bussin' : Juniors Cheesecake from NY! And even if you have been to the winter springs one - this one is 10000000000000x better. From Anthony (the manager) service's to the food to the desert!!! ANTHONY is the bomb!!! Who ever is in charge of his paycheck - HE DESERVES A RAISE!!! SOOOO HAPPY!!! SERIOUSLY!

This is a little pizza joint nestled in between a deli and a Starbucks off of Colonial Drive. However, I was really disappointed to find that none of the staff was wearing gloves and all of them either had no mask on or the mask was hanging under their nose. The prep cooks weren't wearing gloves to make the pizza which turned me off. I guess they missed the memo there is a pandemic going on and food safety/guest safety should be a priority.

Good pizza. Good dough. Got the slice of the day, did not disappoint. Good sauce as well, will return.

Don't judge a place based on the location. This sweet spot is located hidden in a strip mall. Small and quaint with a few outside umbrella tables too. Not really able to accommodate a large group at a single table, since each table seat 4. We were greeted with "welcome to the family" and sat our selves like home. Our server was polite and cheerful, she was very knowledgeable about the menu, special orders are welcomed. If you don't see it, they probably can still make it. The sauce was light not chunky which is our preference and the cheese is soft and gooey. Let me add that the knots are more like rolls and available with or without cheese. Glad we tried this spot. (Delivery within 5mile radius)

I've heard a saying that goes something like "while there is really good pizza, there's no such thing as bad pizza" but unfortunately Tomasino's proved that statement wrong. We had tried them a year ago and weren't huge fans, but decided to give them another go tonight. The pizza was undercooked and doughy. It wasn't even fully cut when we received it. The cheese slid off half the pizza when I tried to pull a slice apart. There was little to no flavor in the sauce. The cheesy garlic knots came in an order of 3 and had little to no garlic flavor, and one of them barely had any cheese on it at all. Disappointed in every way. I should've taken pictures, but the pizza just made me too sad.

I have been coming here for years but the quality of the food really sucks now after a new set of people taking over this restaurant, everything has changed. I won't return here again! !

I give three stars because I frequented here before today. The pizza is good, the price is good. Today, though, I walked in and ordered the two slice special to go, paid and left with no problems until I made it where I was going. As I was eating my pepperoni slice, there were three hairs of varying lengths and colors baked into the pizza. The first one was almost like a beard hair, the second was a little longer, and the third was a long strand baked into the crust of the pizza. I was put off immediately from my appetite and threw the rest of my pizza and the second untouched slice away. The people there are good people, but that was really gross.

A pizza joint through-and-through. Serves big NY-style pies. The cheese and sauce are fresh and taste great. I honestly could've almost eaten 5 or 6 big slices of the cheese. So, yeah, I'd recommend this place when you're looking for a true slice of pizza with friends.

My new favorite pizza and pasta in Orlando! Best sauce cheese crust and everything else. Blown away with everything here. I will definitely be back.

This is not eggplant parmigiana this is a kids pasta with 1 extremely thin slice of eggplant on it. Kind of a bummer because we like the pizza here but both entrees we're pretty upsetting.