Toni's Castle Store & Cafe

Grocery store · Okfuskee County

Toni's Castle Store & Cafe

Grocery store · Okfuskee County

1

371190 US-62, Okemah, OK 74859

Photos

Toni's Castle Store & Cafe by null
Toni's Castle Store & Cafe by null
Toni's Castle Store & Cafe by null
Toni's Castle Store & Cafe by null
Toni's Castle Store & Cafe by null
Toni's Castle Store & Cafe by null
Toni's Castle Store & Cafe by null
Toni's Castle Store & Cafe by null

Highlights

Hotbox foods, fresh sandwiches, catfish, fried pies, and cobbler  

Placeholder
Placeholder

371190 US-62, Okemah, OK 74859 Get directions

Information

Static Map

371190 US-62, Okemah, OK 74859 Get directions

+1 918 668 3422
weltystore

Features

payment credit card
Tap to pay

Last updated

Oct 24, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

Sterlin Harjo’s Oklahoma Dining Guide | Eater

"Driving from Tulsa to my hometown of Holdenville, I started stopping at a gas station in Castle, Oklahoma where they fry a locally sourced catfish that I’d grab from the convenience store, snap a photo of, and always caption 'Catfish is life'—that habit even became the inspiration for Rob and Cleo’s." - Monica Burton

https://www.eater.com/24226038/sterlin-harjo-reservation-dogs-oklahoma-dining-guide-tulsa-holdenville-okmulgee
View Postcard for Toni's Castle Store & Cafe

Sunny Carrol Moreno

Google
You guys, they have deep fried sliced pizza. OMG....best gas station treat ever. EVER. The store is clean, has large clean and ventilated restroom, & large drink selection. They will make you a sandwich to go. Everything is fresh and good!

Mary Ann Alsover

Google
Love it! They have the most delicious catfish dinner ever. Their chicken is equally good. It's 14 mile round trip but well worth it. It's clean and the staff there are excellent and greet everyone with a smile and friendly attitude.

Jamie Braden

Google
This store has surprisingly clean bathrooms and wide isles. The fried pies are the best and lunch options are great! The cinder block building does not do the inside justice. They have a great staff with big smiles and happy to help attitudes.

Victoria Freeze

Google
I went in during the lunch rush and placed an order. Food took a while but I didn't mind because they were very busy. They were polite and accommodating and got my food done. The one star is because they sold me burnt, overdone chicken strips with a smile on their face after such a wait. Partially my fault for not checking the food before I left but I have learned my lesson and will not be returning.

Brandon Trulock

Google
This place while although small is great! The people inside are warm and friendly. It is a family business with home baked goods and hot food in a small deli setting. They also have gas pumps and a convenience store inside. Definitely recommend getting their cobbler and cupcakes, they are awesome!

Donna Leonard

Google
My third visit to this country store. People are great. Gas reasonable. Sandwiches are good and I don't even know where else to buy pickle loaf. Overall great experience!

Daniel DeLaRosa

Google
Deli is always hot and fresh. That make pretty good sandwiches and have the best catfish around!

Coby Palmer

Google
Never open during the specified times on the door. Stopped here several times between 3-5pm on Saturday since no one else is around close by and they’re already closed even though the door says 6pm.