Tony Boloney's - Atlantic City

Tony Boloney’s in Atlantic City is an absolute gem! I ordered the Lobster Trap and it completely blew me away. The portion was generous, the lobster was fresh and perfectly cooked, and the flavors were rich, creamy, and decadent without being over the top. Every bite felt like the perfect balance of indulgence and comfort food. The vibe of the place is fun and welcoming, and the staff was super friendly, making the whole experience even better. I can honestly say the Lobster Trap is one of the best things I’ve eaten in Atlantic City, and I’ll definitely be coming back to try more of their wild creations. If you’re visiting AC, do yourself a favor and make Tony Boloney’s a stop—you won’t regret it!

The food was ok. I won't go back. Area is sketchy. Watched some guys pull up their truck full of junk and off load it to a dumpster not theirs. Place has no air conditioning. Tables were super sticky. I just wanted to eat and leave. My husband did like his sandwich. My lemon wings were like chicken picatta. I ate 2 and tossed the rest. The cheese sticks were ok, but cheese was wet. I ordered a slice of cheese pizza, said slice AC..but never got it. I was told we didn't order one. Not a great date experience.

Food is tasty. Got an 18" pizza, Caesar salad, 2 subs, and mozzarella stick sampler. Reasonable priced for AC (more expensive because it's AC). Easy to order online. The gimmick is the food names and funny sayings for certain things. Some of them the random food ingredients, like Fritos, on top of our chicken sub didn't add to the enhancement and prob would have been fine without it. The pizza and 1 of the subs were slightly burnt.

We go to the stand at the Ventnor farmers market and its the best detroit style pizza around. Love the mega pepperoni one, its insanely good and loaded to the brim!

A NJ shore location offering it instagrammable pizza slices and sandwiches. The pizza was 7/10 and the insane amount of pepperoni was cute but it’s to much. If you order one, make sure to grab a sandwich that can benefit from the pepperoni. The curry chop cheese was tasty but it was lacking in the scotch bonnet that was listed in the menu description. I dunno if I’d order again, but it was def worth the visit

So after years of following and wanting to try we decided to take a trip to beautiful Hoboken to try Toney’s and it was far from a disappointment the gentleman was very pleasant he gave me the history of the establishment and also was nice enough to let us try a few slices on the house.Didn’t have to but it was amazing and the slices was bussing!!!. We also grabbed the sandwiches the trex and the beef patty sandwich(chef kiss).. it was so great if I can give 10 stars I truly will,, much love from south jersey

This was a fun adventure. Right by the beach, hole in the wall style spot with seating for maybe 10. The food is really REALLY good. We had wings, subs, pizza, elite fries. It was all amazing. We went twice while in Atlantic City. The Lobsta Trap and Teka the Shaka were my favs. Along with the Chopped Patty. If you want good munchie style food go here! It’s a little pricy, but after one bite you don’t care!

Saw it on Facebook and have been waiting. Counting down the days until I got to Jersey. While I wanted the swine fighter, the French onion sub was gods gift to man. The best thing I've ever had my entire time in Jersey.

We ordered for grub hub delivery to our marina... that worked great! We had the Cesar Gaucho salad. We had ordered garlic knots, but they were out, so a magic mushroom was a good substitution. That mushroom pizza was delicious, and I thank the employee who suggested it! But the star of the show was the Grumpy Gramps pizza... a sesame crust, Sicilian chili spicy marinara, fresh, smoked & dry-aged mozzarella, pecorino, and basil parm. This is one of the vat pizza's we've ever had... just amazing. It's a little non-traditional, but not weird. The flavors all work really well together! Although we didn't visit in person, the personality of this whacky restaurant shines through from their unique phone system to their fun packaging! Honestly, this may be the best if not the only reason we would visit Atlantic City again!

Food was excellent. Music was vulgar and loud. Cashier acted like he didn't want to be there... Pizza and sandwiches were really good! The cashier was a young man who was not friendly at all and didn't act at all like he was grateful to have a job. Next time I will take it to go as the loud, vulgar music was a real turnoff. Another turnoff was that customers are allowed to enter without wearing shirts or shoes. Gross...

I thought Tony Boloney was going to be full of baloney when I first heard of them, but this Pizzeria shatters pizza norms with over the top creations that fuse global flavors with Jersey attitude! We had the following slices: - Heart Attack - Buffalo chicken, mac and cheese, bacon, mozzarella, and ranch sauce. - Mex Corn Husker - A Mexican Jersey hybrid featuring roasted corn, string cheese, jalapeño crema, chillies, cilantro and queso. - MoonShiner -Vodka sauce, mozzarella, basil and pecorino cheese. The slices are thin and the flop is perfect. Creative slices that are delicious. We also had the Cheesesteak Hero. I had the plain version of the hero with just cheese whiz or as Tony Boloney would call it the "U lame" version. Delicious ribeye steak chopped up and as a pro tip, add mozzarella sticks in the hero for that added texture and dimension of flavor. The indoor seating is small and limited, there are outdoor benches. You can only order single slices on only the items already displayed on the counter. If it's not on display you will have to order the pie if you want that flavor If you're a traditional pizza lover, then Tony Boloney may not be your cup of tea, but if you love bold flavors, creative and over the top pizza and subs, Tony Boloney will be right up your alley.

Me and my girlfriend got the lobster trap sandwich and it was chewy and soggy just a hot mess! Then we got the wings with lemon pepper and hot honey on the side the lemon pepper was chunky and tasted off! But the hot honey bbq was good at least but the wings had no flavor like O seasoning not even salt!!! I wasted 60 dollars on this do not recommend.

Very expensive and mediocre, small, greasy sandwiches. They even charged me for items that I never received in my order. Shady.

Someone responded to me on instagram but I still haven't received that refund....shady af.

Got a pizza craving while here for the week on a work trip. Looked up pizza on Yelp and Tony's was the top result. I took a quick peak at the menu and was just in awe of the delicious, yet absurd choices! Five stars for the food; delicious, flavor bursting and so so many choices. We got the pizza with hot honey and waffles and the ones with whole burrata on it. Both two thumbs up. 4 stars overall because ambiance is lackluster and service was pretty slow. I'd definitely return next year, but opt for takeout and ordering ahead. That would make it 5 stars for me.

1st time here & wow. The steak sandwiches are not for the faint of heart. Brotherly love was full of spicy peppers & delicious. The star was the homemade white cheddar whiz. Grateful that they are not stingy with the cheese! I didn't notice until afterwards they offer gluten free bread. Will definitely be back for that. But I love the veggie & vegan options & I have to try their homemade mozzarella. There's too many reasons to return! Finally- the service was top notch, very friendly & went above & beyond to remake a sandwich (& I tried to stop them! lol) but they insisted on getting it right & I insist on giving them repeat business. Go to there!!

Stopped in again while in town. Grabbed a CBR ON ROIDS. Chicken Bacon Ranch slice, and it was real good. Definitely recommend. Just not sure how it's $6.50 for a slice in the absolute hood of Atlantic City, haha. No slice of pizza anywhere costs that much. Good food tho for sure, prices are a bit wild tho.

NINE DAYS LATER THEY TOLD ME THEY ARE TRYING TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO REFUND ME .. HOW THE HELL ARE THEY IN BUSINESS??? Food is excellent, but they are IMPOSSIBLE TO CONTACT. They have a fake mafia AI that is just annoying. They were supposed to void and refund a charge for $50 that went through 2x, but NOBODY IS HELPING I CALLED FOUR TIMES Three nobody answered after the insipid AI and once someone did and took my info and said "owner will call me back" and... NOTHING I even used the contact forum in website which took THREE attempts

The food was good.. not great... the place needs to be deep cleaned and remodeled.. it almost looked.closed.from outside.. wouldn't go out my.way.doe.the pizza or french fries that were $14

While staying in the area I drove to this pizza/sub joint one evening for dinner. I wouldn't walk here tho! Driving wasn't bad, plenty of street parking. It's worn down and dingy inside, but the service is friendly and the food in the case looks amazing. They make fresh pizzas which they display and sell by the slice. They have a large menu with some tasty-looking subs and pizzas and if you want a pizza that's not in the case, you need to buy the while pie. I tried a slice of cheese and their Brotherly Love sub. The pizza was excellent! Crust was great, cheese to sauce to crust ratio was perfect... Flavor was great also! Their Brotherly Love sub was nice! Spicy too!! It had a whole, spicy long green pepper on it, along with what tasted like Calabrian chili paste on it, smeared inside the sub roll. The meat was excellent and tho I hate wiz, this homemade white wiz they have was incredible! Overall - I really enjoyed the food. The service was friendly too. Definitely would return!

Don't be fooled by the "old school" vibe of this place. If you want traditional, head over to a place like White House Subs. But if you want some creative takes on Philly-style subs and pizza, with high quality ingredients, then Tony Baloney should be on your list.

Pizza bliss in divey comfort zone Can't wait to go back. After you finish you wish you had ordered more

Soooo... I was excited to finally make it to a spot that I had on my bucket list for quite a while. I finally had the time and opportunity to make it over and I was definitely hungry. I'd eyed up the pepperoni slice for quite some time and THAT was what I wanted to try. Not knowing what to expect I ordered 2 SLICES and added an iced tea to the mix. The total I was told was $29 bucks and change!!! Again for two slices and a drink. Now first, I'm definitely not cheap and I LOVE great pizza. But I could not justify dropping 30 bucks on that amount of food. So I proceeded to reduce my order to 1 slice (super happy I did after the fact). I sat and a few minutes later my slice was brought over and at first glance it looked delicious. I then looked a little deeper and realized that I'd probably not be able to eat all of the pepperoni (there was a ton, which I'm not mad at). However as I started popping the pepperoni slices off and eating them in isolation. I noticed that there were puddles and puddles of what looked like half melted butter just poured all over the pizza. Even dabbing the pizza with a paper napkin couldn't eliminate the loads of oil and butter that saturated the topping. The pizza was okay, but the gobs of butter did not agree with me at all. My stomach was not happy and I ultimately could not even finish the single slice. To make matters even better (and keep in mind I'm not a health nut at all) the peach tea I bought had the lowest sugar of all the bottled drinks, with some options totaling sugar levels that are almost twice the amount of what is recommended for someone to have ALL DAY. High expectations, but I was greatly disappointed. Definitely a tourist spot and I'm sure some local fans. But I think I will be a one and done. The menu is a heart attack and diabetes in the making

Absolutely Disgusting - Total Waste of Money and Time I just had what was supposed to be a "special" cheesesteak from Tony Baloney's -- the so-called Duckrown Melt -- and I honestly don't think I've ever had a worse sandwich in my life. Let's start with the meat: dry, flavorless, and literally crumbling out of the bread like it had been sitting on a skillet for days. There was absolutely nothing fresh about this sandwich. To make matters worse, the amount of grease pouring out of it was next-level repulsive -- it was dripping down our arms. Not exaggerating. And the flavor combination? Musty, weird, and just totally off. Whoever dreamed up this disaster clearly wasn't thinking about actual taste. It was borderline inedible. We ended up throwing half of it away -- and let me remind you, this thing cost THIRTY dollars. For one greasy, dry, poorly-executed cheesesteak. We drove a half hour from Galloway thinking we were in for something special -- Tony Baloney's has this reputation for being top-tier. What a joke. Save your money and your stomach. This was a huge letdown and frankly, gross.

The place is far off the beaten path but that didn't stop me from going. Pizza is our thing so we had to try it. Days later I am still trying to convince myself that I could have eaten their hot mozzarella sticks, but I chickened out. The pizza was fire.

They have a lot of seasonal items and the service here usually is upbeat and friendly. Casual spot for unique sandwiches and pizzas. I always come up to AC and get a kick out of reading the menu here. So my all time fav is called the Lobsta Trap. It's basically a big warm cheesy lobster roll.everytime I come to AC I must have one of these bad boys :) This time around it wasn't as great as it usually is, but maybe an off day. Still love this place and respect them immensely for being uniquely them and very creative. Give these guys a shot

Hidden famous spot off the end of the boardwalk. Pizzas are great but sandwiches are amazing. Cashier was friendly and suggested items. Quick service, small place. Had the Ole and it was very filling and tasty.

The pizza was so good and fresh. The girls up front were so tentative to what I was asking for. Love the ascetic of the place.

Had a burger with fries. Burger was great, fries not so great. Girl behind the counter was perfect customer service.

I've had pizza here before and it was always excellent. My friends have had cheesesteaks here before and they were excellent. But when we visited on 7/9/25 Tony's was way off the mark. The rolls were burnt and hard on two out of three of the cheesesteaks we received. One of our orders was incorrect. Even the taste of mine was not all that great. I think this may have been one of the worst cheesesteaks I've ever had.

Not bad at all! A fun, divey spot that serves great pizza. My dining companion was trying out their gluten free offerings and thought they were great. My friend ordered the GF version of the Jewish Cowboy. It was delicious! She offered some to me and I was impressed. I had the Swine fighter, an amazing amount of pork goodness. If you're in Atlantic City, try this place out! Quick counter service in an informal setting. Enjoy!

We needed something for lunch and have heard a lot about this place and never been so we decided to give it a try. Walked to it from the Hard Rock. You wouldn't even know it is there, it looks like a house. We spilt a slice a pizza, Pope Leo X, which was unique and tasted really good. Only complaint was it was really greasy. We had to order the famous Ole cheesesteak. When we opened it we were impressed with how good it looked. Unfortunately the flavor wasn't there and it didn't taste as good as it looked.

Sub par. I've ordered there twice this week. Had high hopes but the place is def overrated. The moonshiner pizza is great. The first time I ordered there I got two orders of wings and not a single flat. So I made sure to call ahead the second time just to request a mix . I also ordered the duck fat sandwich with the "make it a meal option" so I made sure to specify which drink I wanted with the meal since there wasn't an option to choose. The sandwich with fries and and a drink cost 26 dollars. I got no fries no drink. The duck fat sandwich has dried crispy short rib and it was absolutely soaked in grease. When I called to say I was missing food I was simply told "take it up with door dash" no apology for the mistake, no care. I gave them a chance. I won't be going back.

Great pizza and sandwich shop down in AC. I've been here a few times now for sandwiches and they've yet to disappoint. Can order online, limited seating available. Love the old AC decor and the specially olive oils and spreads available for purchase. House made sodas are another plus. Definitely recommend paying this place a visit

Uniquely a very cool locally owned establishment ! Easy to locate and there is street parking around this location. Staff was friendly and helpful, when we had several questions. The pizza simply rocks The food coming out all looked great ! The menu is huge with very twisted offerings ... Yes, we do recommend stopping here

We came here two years ago and I became obsessed. We came this past weekend and the food was not nearly as good as it was. It was such a bummer. And the food takes about 30 minutes to get ready. The fries basket is HUGE so share them if you get them.

This place has one of the best pizzas in Atlantic city. Yes it's located in one of the ghetto-ish part of the city but there's plenty of street parking!

Yes. Pizza is so good here is what we got: -Plain Cheese Pizza - I am pretty sure you cannot go wrong. -Fuckin Gindolune - I basically would never order a cheese pizza and just eat this one. -S#itfaced Chicken - it was good, but I would go back to the Gindolune in a heart beat. Subs: -Punjabo parm- it's spicy but tasty. Again spicy. -We had this other sub - it was broccoli and chicken and cheese (a couple of cheeses) - it was so so good. It's seasonal I think - and I can't write what the name is because of that. Service on point - they got our order right away and filled it. Ambiance -- well I would take out. The overall place is not a lot. and there literally is nothing around this joint. Overall: food is awesome, do take out.

Amazing pizza. IMO one of the best in town square pizza is insanely thick love this place

Food is really good. Different from the standard. They add very good ingredients to familiar staples like cheesesteaks, pizza, fries, wings. I highly recommend this place mainly for takeout or very informal dine-in. Staff were friendly. It is on the north end of the city near Ocean casino past where the tram car on the boardwalk runs but not far. So you could get the tram on the boardwalk and get off at Ocean casino and walk 3 or so blocks to the shop. There is plenty of parking as it is flanked by open lots. It's not the most friendly looking area of the city but you don't go there for the view. We had the buffalo and lemon pepper (Southern) wings, fries and some kind of LPP chicken sub. My daughter loved her sub and fries. The house buffalo wings were fantastic. Wings are on the large side with lots of meat. I have to say my Southern wings dit not meet my idea of what lemon pepper should taste like. I'm more used to a wing stop kind of flavor.

Food is always great and on point and The employees is always nice and friendly it's a nice place to chill and eat

Great place to try different pizza! Ordered a pizza half and half and it was amazing!

The pizza here is amazing. The menu is overwhelming so take some time to think through what you want. The location is a little off the beaten path and a little hidden (I almost drove right past it). The pizza took a while to come, but the staff is friendly. There is not a lot of seating available so ordering to go may be the best bet.

Gross. Got a cheese steak, and something was just "off" about the taste. Not sure if it was the oil they used or the seasoning, but it was bad. Didn't offer real American cheese, only American "wiz" which we weren't fans of either. Ordered cheese fries with cheese on the side, but they still put the cheese sauce on it, so that by the time we got it home, it was like something out of a John Carpenter movie, just a huge lump of cheesey potatoes. The few bits that we could peel away seemed tasty, but sadly most of it ended up in the trash.

We went here today for lunch. Cool vibe inside, only a few tables. Got two slices, garlic knots and some wings. Everything was delicious. Definitely gotta come back and try the sandwiches. Service was great here too.

Stumbled upon this gem while bike riding in AC. Shared a slice of the moonshiner with my bf. It was so good that we came back the very next day for lunch. He ordered a slice of the pinky and s#it faced chicken, while I ordered the uptown Cobb. Everything was delicious and very fresh. The pizza is perfectly thin and crisp. Cooked to perfection, not floppy and great sauce. My bf enjoyed the pinky slice the best. The salad was very filling and a ton of ingredients and flavors going on. I will definitely order this salad again next time! 2 slices + salad + tax and tip cost $30. Which is a tad bit high, but we had zero complaints about the actual food which made it worth it. Very cool hipster decor with indoor and outdoor seating. I highly recommend this spot! Plus you can check in through Yelp and get a free fountain drink!

What a cool place! I was staying at the Ocean Casino on the boardwalks and looking for a more local place. This was just the ticket! Easy walk from the boardwalk and not at all scary. I had the "Ole" which is a mexican-inspired cheesesteak with mexican flavors. One of the messiest sandwiches I have ever had, but also right up there with one of the best! Highly recommended. The dine-in experience is not much, but the weather was nice so I ate at a picnic table outside. Perfect. My only complaint is off-brand "cola" drinks! Great job, Tony Baloney!

-came for the shogun shadow boxer, but couldn't get just a slice as they only had only six pizzas available in slices. All other orders required purchasing a whole pie -got he lobster trap sub. Big mistake, as it was a ball of grease with cheese and lobster. The bread was drenched in oil and it was not a clean eat. -supreme tang slice was okay. -the food looks very good and they do a good job at marketing their product, but the items fail to live up to the hype

Got 2 OG Vegan slices in 2 minutes for $12, really good. One time I got this as a pie to go and it got soggy because of the thin crust, so this was a redemption of TB's for me. Multiple vegan pizza/sub options here too which is a plus!

I wanna go back I wanna go back I wanna go back. I had no idea about this place but my friend and I visited after he expressed interest and it was only a 9 min drive. I had the Mexican street corn and plain slice. Both were amazing. Although there was a long line, our food was ready in a good amount of time. Seats are very limited because it is always packed.

This place has so many options for vegetarians. I can't wait to go back and try more. Service was good and ambiance is grunge/hipster vibe. I got a vegan sub called Squash Tha Beef and a slice of cacio E Pepe pizza. Both were amazing. The squash tha beef sub is basically eggplant "meatballs" with tasty marinara and vegan cheese. The cacio e Pepe pizza was more low key but would eat that any day on its own, it has a focaccia-like crust. I can't wait to come back next time I'm in town and try the various buffalo cauliflower options and whatever other vegetarian creations they have on the menu!

I have wanted to stop by here for over a year now. I found out about this restaurant after they helped a local local man in Philadelphia with a fundraiser for his mother. Ever since then I had wanted to stop in the next time I was in AC. I had my chance in Saturday evening! My boyfriend and I headed to AC to see a show that night. So we decided to stop at Tony Boloney's for dinner first. We got there around 6:20. It's a small and very busy place. They have a few tables inside and outside. I'm guessing most orders are picked up to go. We decided what we wanted and placed our order. We were able to get a table inside. We waited for about 20 minutes before asking if maybe we hadn't heard our name called. We waited 35 minutes total for our order. Seemed a little long as no one was there was long as we were. Most people were in and out. I had wanted to get the Boloney Rex since I saw it! So we ordered that sandwich and another with chicken cutlet and an order of fries. When we opened up the Rex it was so messy we had no idea how to go about eating it! There is a red sauce and a white cheese sauce that is put on it. We wound up eating the meat out of the roll with forks. The meat was very good! The chicken sandwich was wonderful!! We were so glad we got to stop it and try their food!

The food I must say was not bad. Enjoyed the gluten-free options but pretty pricey for a pizzeria. One pie, fries, 10 wings and two drinks was about $72. The gluten-free options are not by slice only 12" pies with a $5 additional charge for glue free. The service wasn't bad, wait time was about 25 min for the pizza to be made. Ambiance was not the greatest. The area is off the strip and I literally missed the pizzeria because the place looks like it's connected to a house so we were a bit confused. The tables were dirty which we had to clean to EAT. Dirty spot. Not sure I would go back. The pizzas are intriguing but overall not the best for $72.

Food was mediocre. Ordered 15 items. A bunch of pizzas, a sub, some wings. Nothing was cooked how you would like it. Wings are soggy. Pizza was undercooked so it wasn't crispy and the toppings didn't taste good. undercooked pepperoni is not good. Sub was ok. The one star review is mainly for the mistake they made when delivering our food. They forgot the vegan items we ordered. We called them and asked for them to send it since they forgot the vegan items so one of our friends couldn't eat. They said we could come pick it up. We just paid for 15 items to be delivered and their solution was for us to come pick it up. Then they said it's not their fault since they use DoorDash. I asked if they're the ones to pack the food and they said yes they check it before they send out the order. So..it sounds like whoever checked it on their end messed up and they just admitted it. They told me since they use a third party we have to contact door dash. I called DoorDash and they said since we ordered from their website directly they (the restaurant) have to initiate the refund. There was never any kind of apology. My friend who ordered the vegan items couldn't eat with the rest of us. Lol just don't go here they don't care and they're not nice.

For $37 I think this sub was ok. It wasn't great and wasn't terrible. Really no seasonings that I could taste, just seafood, cheese and OIL and lots of it.

The perfect meal after a long day at the beach! Beware the line can get long, but no need to worry there is a lot of seating outside and some inside. The food takes a while to come out, but that could just be because we came at a rush time. The menus are at the counter where you order, so grab a menu while you wait in line. I wish the menus were by the door so you can think about what you want before and not have to get past everyone to get the menu The sandwiches are very filling and more than enough to split with someone! The elotes fries are very filling as well can be shared with 2-3 people. Has a kick to it, so beware. I love how cheesy the fries are, they don't skimp on the toppings! We got the oui oui sandwich and it was jam packed with meat! My only downfall is it is a tad salty and the french onion over powers the cheese taste. The ducktown melt is delicious as well! The garlic bread makes the sandwich so much better! Jam packed with meat as well! Very flavorful! The sandwiches are very messy! Going to need a lot of napkins There's a restroom there but use at your own discretion

Not a large selection. Pizza itself was just okay. Soda lids fell off easily. Spilled soda everywhere.