Traditas Pizza

I've been to many pizza restaurants in my visits to NYC, but these guys have by far been the best. Their pizza slices are filling, delicious and are a decent price. I had a Chicken and Bacon Ranch slice, and a BBQ chicken slice, and I have to say, I would happily go back. The customer service was great too. The guys were super helpful and polite, and I had a great conversation with them about their food and history. Tremendous guys, keep up the good work ❤️

Great pizza spot. Haven’t been since last summer but I remember their cheese slice being really solid. Today, I tried the buffalo chicken slice and the vodka parm. Buffalo chicken was a solid 4.8/5. Chicken wasn’t over seasoned and the Buffalo taste really stood out. And it’s a hefty slice. The vodka parm was good. Solid 4/5. Could benefit from a tad bit more flavor/seasoning in the sauce. All things considered, this is a 5 star pizza place for sure.

I went here curious about the pizza obviously and it was good pizza. I had the margarita and bacon chicken ranch. I personally like my pizza on the saltier side but all in all this place was good. I would come here again. But pricey slices. $6 for a chicken bacon ranch is a bit much

Good. There are places to seat and a bathroom for customers in the back. The taste of pizza is average. I like the white pizza with spinach. The price is $5 to $6 per slice. This is expensive but it is Manhattan.

I was hungry during lunch so I stopped by Traditas to get a hearty Margherita pizza slice. The sauce was a touch of sweet, the cheese was excellent, and the staff was friendly. I will be coming back for more.

Great pizza! Crispy and the sauce is balanced. Also was feeling experimental and got their sausage and peppers roll which was good too. Nothing to complain about

Solid place in FiDi for a slice, great customer service and unexpectedly, I really enjoyed the crunchy crust in my Margherita slice, will be back to try more slices. $5.20 if paying with card for Margherita

The buffalo chicken pizza is a must try. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy. Very friendly service can’t wait to come back!

Just landed in my old stomping grounds and wanted a quick slice of pizza. The truth is I didn't do much research because I was hungry lol. Bumped into this cute place, and figured it would be good. Walking in the door, I immediately knew I was in a NY pizza shop: an open display of multiple pizzas and pizza rolls with hot ovens in the background. The two gentlemen working were very kind and helpful. We ended up getting three slices: penne pasta, lasagna, and a meatlovers slice. I also ordered a side Greek salad. The food was OK. I think the crust and sauce could have had a little more flavor- maybe a little more salt? I did like the lightness of the bread though! Perfectly crisp. It was a little on the pricy side as well, at $6+ a slice and $11 for the small salad versus some of my other usual spots that sell slices for $3-$5. I do want to try their square slices as they looked delish!

grabbed a vodka slice & margherita slice here at night when we had the munchies and this spot was closeby! Slices tasted like they were made fresh and the sauce had plenty of flavor, however the crust had snapped while folding it to eat lol I get the crust is supposed to be crunchy but not that crunchy. Other than that the pizza was great and reasonably priced

We ordered a half pepperoni, half cheese pizza pie and it hit the spot perfectly. The crust had that great balance, it was crispy on the outside but still soft and chewy inside. The cheese half was simple and classic, with just the right amount of sauce and a generous layer of melted cheese that stretched with every bite. The pepperoni side brought a little extra punch: salty, savory slices that crisped up around the edges and paired beautifully with the tangy sauce. It was a great way to please everyone at the table. We got it after a night of heavy drinking so it was perfect. It's definitely something for those who love the timeless plain cheese and something for those who want a little extra flavor. Overall, it was a delicious, well made pie that I'd happily order again.

Maybe it was the choice, late at night not that hungry just wanted a slice of pizza basic not too fancy. Lots of choices, but took the meat lovers-lots of sausage and the dough was not the best. I'll try another pizza by the slice elsewhere

Nice crispy pizza with a great selection at lunch. Got a buffalo chicken slice and a meat lovers slice and they were great. Crust was nice and crisp, not too much flop and toppings were generous. Being that it's fidi and a bit more "upscale" than the $1.50 slice? It was pricey coming in at $12 for 2 slices. Service is great and you are helped immediately

Ordered a large cheese pie for delivery for $25 ($4 tip). Arrived promptly & warm (not hot). Visually the cheese color & cook (brown patches) as it outta be & looked fine. But I was suspicious when I saw the crust edge. No cornicione bubbles AT ALL! The dough was flavorless, dry and unworthy of a true NY pie. Definitely no fermentation in the dough resulting in a pretty mediocre pie. Really disappointing as I'd hoped I could find a new contender in the "quality pizza in the neighborhood"department. Traditas is a pretender. Trust me, I'm not just a native NYer but also a retired chef. The search continues...

On a cold, rainy and busy day this pizza hit the spot! Somehow between travel and meetings I had gone all day without eating and was looking for somewhere that was a short walk from my hotel to grab a quick bite. I had am amazing slice of lasagna pizza elsewhere a month prior that I couldn't stop thinking about, so when I searched for "lasagna pizza" I stumbled upon Traditas near by. They sell pizza by the slice which was what I was looking for, so it was easy to just walk in, order at the counter and wait for my slice to be heated up. When I took that first bite, I almost melted in my seat. It was so good - hot, crispy crust, flavorful and rich. Despite one slice filling me up quite a bit, it was so good it felt like a crime not to get one more slice knowing it might be a long time before I'm able to enjoy a slice from here again. Seriously, it was so good that I still think about it. Thank you for the delicious meal, Traditas!

Tried this place because it was the closest to my hotel when visiting and so happy I stumbled across this gem! Absolutely loved the variety! The Caesar Salad Pizza was novelty for me as well as the Chicken Parm one so I had to try them both. Every slice was good BUT the white slice was my favorite. Simple but so tasty. The ricotta was complementing the crispy dough of the pizza itself I was so surprised. My second favorite was the Vodka one. Another simple yet tasty option. I'm a huge fan of thin crust slices and this is definitely top 5 for me.

The best service, makes you feel like you're visiting family! Tons of selection and plenty of good service

Vibe: 4/10 Service: 6/10 Value: 6/10 Mushroom slice: 4/10 Pepperoni slice: 5/10 Overall: 5/10 (2.5/5) [To clarify our review system: 10 = we'll never have anything else as good as this in our lives (we use 10 very sparingly!) 9 = extraordinary 8 = great 7 = above average 6 = average Anything below 6 is being critical]

Amazing pizza. The Penne Vodka slice tasted like heaven! Had the lasagna pizza and buffalo chicken as well but neither compare to the penne vodka.

Great pizza and great service !!! lots of options to pick from. highly recommend. great energy here too

Came to Traditas as part of a FiDi pizza tour. It is a surprisingly large space, with quite a few tables inside and out. We shared 3 slices here- the vodka sauce slice was by far my favorite, versus the others (buff chick, chicken parm). The vodka sauce was really tasty! I wasn't as big of a fan of the chicken on the other two slices, but I did appreciate the creativity of the slices. The crust was just okay in my opinion. Would return to have their vodka slice, and maybe to try another slice too.

Arrived in NYC and needed that NYC slice of pizza! Traditas pizza was close to the hotel I was staying at so I popped in to try out the pizza. Clean establishment! I ordered 1 cheese slice. It was good. I was also able to sit inside and enjoy the slice!

Came in with high hopes based on the small but enthusiastic review sampling but left disappointed. Ordered a slice of chicken parm pizza which had too little sauce, and the chicken tasted rubbery and several days old. Wasn't reheated warm enough and crust also tasted a little bit coarse, like cardboard. Water machine was broken also so no drinks available unless you bought soda. Would be a good option most places in america as there appeared to be many other appealing slices , but my personal experience was Ok at best by NY standards

The cheese pizza was fye but on some nonchalant type shift. Margarita pizza tasted nothing like a marg the smoke show beside me had the vodka sauce for the culture, she likes it saucy overall I'd give this place maybe like a 6 or 7. Bathroom smelt like your cool aunties house.

While in route to Times Square we stumbled crossed Traditas. The pizza was fresh & yummy. The crust was airy & thin which was my favorite. Service was prompt! Would recommend!

This place is my new favorite pizza place! Excellent choice in slices. The pies are incredibly fresh! Everything from a regular pie, to the yummy garlic knot, to the Buffalo chicken and chicken Parmesan rolls! Sooo good 5/5 for slice variety and freshness 5/5 for service! So friendly and super helpful! 5/5 for cleanliness and ambiance!

My workplace had ordered in lunch from Traditas Pizza. This was my first time eating Traditas NY Pizza and it won't be my last! I ended up trying two large slices of cheese pizza. The cheese pizza was scrumptious! The dough was thin, and wasn't burnt. There was plenty of cheese on the pizza and the sauce had a sweet taste to it. I really enjoyed it and I would stop by Traditas for a slice of pizza again!

My go-to pizza spot when I'm in the area. The staff is welcoming and friendly and they are very quick. It's pricey because of the area but it's worth it! I usually get a bruschetta slice or grandma slice which are just under $5 a slice. Both are delicious and made with high quality ingredients. I'd recommend stopping by if you're in the area

I heard of Traits on YouTube from Portnoy's review and I was so excited to have realized they're just 2-3 blocks away from my employer! I stopped by one day for a lunch break and was amazed at how the beautiful presentation and organization of the pizza options. The service was fantastic, the team in there is so kind, quickly attentive and they know how to run a shop! I went with the vodka grandma and a regular slice and found both to be very pleasant and delicious. If you're into fresh mozzarella and doughy pizza, this is the spot for you! lots of drink options and a good amount of seats inside for a FiDi pizzeria. 10/10/

Great service, even got a free slice! Delicious crust and creative combinations. Would recommend for a quick slice!

The pizza was great and the customer service was even better. Very friendly. We ordered 4 slices and they only charged us for 3. When we realized and tried to pay they said it was on the house. When we ordered dessert they made fresh cannoli's instead of giving us the ones from the refrigerator.

First, this is New York pizza served at its best, we walked in and were immediately made to feel we lived around the corner (we're visiting from Houston) ordered a couple of slices even though we were snacking between meals. Nailed it. Went back and chose some more. Perfect pie. Proof to the world that this is the Home of Pizza. Oh, did I mention I left my backpack when I waddled out. These guys tracked us down to find us within an hour. When I returned they were aghast that I would think of any kind of reward. Turns out we now have friends in the Big Apple. We will be back. Texas, get up here!

I just discovered this place even after living in Lower Manhattan for over 10 years. This is now my favorite pizza place. The crust is crunchy and not thick - just the way I like it. My favorite is the vodka slice. The pizza is also more reasonably priced than others in the neighborhood.

This spot checks all my boxes for great pizza . It's a plus that it's in an area away from the tourists and it has more than ample seating , some good background music and most importantly really really good pizza . My favorite is their Margherita slice and lasagna slice . The Margherita slice was light , very flavorful especially with that sauce and basil and its perfect crust . It was just flawless. The lasagna slice was very unique to my taste buds . It felt like a meal on a slice which was a good feeling . It's on the heavier side though so maybe one is enough if you're monitoring your weight like me . A little less than stellar were the vodka slice ( too buttery) and the mushroom slice ( boring-ish) but still 4/5 solid !

FANTASTIC New York Pizza. We're die-hard fans of another FiDi establishment, but this was close and convenient for a quick snack. The crust was THE BEST crust in Manhattan and the texture was pure perfection. The variety of flavors was more extensive than most other city pizza joints. I'd include a pic of a slice, but we ate it all. There's plenty of inside seating as well as a small covered street patio. We will be back even if we are on the west side of the FiDi.

Was walking down the opposite street & the sigh caught my eye. Staff was super nice & quick to take my order. Crust & cheese were perfect. Counters & tables were clean. Also have a decent size outdoor seating space.

We needed a late evening snack after enjoying a little Prosecco, so my husband popped around the corner and grabbed an assortment of slices and an order of garlic knots. Beautifully thin crust pizza with a tasty red sauce, and all the flavors melded together like mmmmmmmmmmm. The garlic knots were a perfect texture of doughy/chewy/buttery, and the bright, tangy red sauce dip complemented them perfectly. While I reserve five stars for only extraordinary pizza, the pies here are a solid 4. We'd recommend it and would return for more.

burnt pizza , just wanted a slice of pepperoni. also the soda machine doesn't work... one slice is 4.50

Best pizza I've had in the city - don't sleep on the bbq pizza and the bruschetta pizza

Hands down the BEST in New York! Saucy,cheesy, and a crispy crust! They were quick and such a cozy spot! If I'm ever in NY again I'm definitely coming back!

The pizza was fantastic and the service matched. I definitely recommend for a quick slice.

Pizza was very cheesy, and crispy. I'm from the Carolina's and I was ready to travel to NY for a hot slice. Definitely recommend this place. Don't have any ground beef for pizza but the cheese slice was good.

If you like sweet red sauce and crunchy thin crust this place is for you. Service was ok but pizza was not fresh. Visited between lunch and dinner peak hours and pizza was reheated but not quite long enough to get the cheese hot. May he better if you get a while pie instead of by the slice. The garlic knots were good but served cold.

Whenever im feeling pizza or pasta, i come here! The men who work here are always welcoming and friendly. I've gotten regular slices, beef patties, rolls and even spaghetti vodka here. All were yummy! Place always look clean. One of my goto spots!

Ummm where has this pizza been my whole life?? I was debating between the vodka slice or the margherita slice. I ended up getting the marg. Slice & it was soo good. Tasted fresh & like it had quality ingredients. The crust was crisped to perfection, I want another slice already! Inside is clean & the workers are welcoming. Will be coming here more often

Fantastic pizza, friendly staff, above all the ambience was amazing everyone treated me nicely we had a good laugh and a good time. Definitely coming back!!

1 star - charged additional $20 for a small pizza for no reason. It didn't even taste good. The total cost of a personal pizza with one topping was $44 PLUS delivery and fees. Was a total rip off and would not recommend anyone ever order from Traditos.

Best slice in FiDi, friendliest staff. All the speciality slices are good, but the chicken parm and chicken Caesar are exceptional.

New slice joint in the neighborhood- tried the pepperoni slice and the Buffalo chicken slice. Very run of the mill, average slices of pizza. The base isn't like your typical nyc slice, it was missing the dough like texture. There are quite a few better places around.

really clean place. easy to walk in, quick service. the slice was delicious! no floppy underbelly and good flavor / texture in vodka sauce. i wish the cheese was better quality because you can dab the grease off; but some people love that. work around the corner, will definitely be returning.

Brooklyn pizza in Manhattan?! Stopped in during lunch and the pizza was great. Had a white slice and a Buffalo. There's a nice area to sit in the back with a tv. It got busy during lunch and these guys were fast w the order. Will definitely be coming back here often.

Never been to NYC, the pizza was fast, cheap, and tasty. People were friendly and the place was clean. I would go again if I am ever in the area.

Amazing pizza spot. Cheap and delicious! We were looking for a good pizza spot as we were visiting and this was the perfect spot. Great customer service as well!

Very good New York pizza. Quick and friendly service. Very affordable. We were visiting from out of state and were really pleased with our visit.

This reminded me of a west coast NY style pizza place. Not bad, just not quite what I was looking for. Service was good and the location was very clean. Went at lunch time and the wait was very short.

It's fine. Yeah fine. Cheese is good. Could use a little more sauce. The crust though, wrong flavor and texture. It's too crunchy to fold a slice. I didn't even finish my slice.

The staff were very friendly and patient with a couple of indecisive tourists. I had a couple of slices of the square pizza but the sicillian bruschetta was absolutely incredible. The decor is typical fast food joint, but clean and spacious with some comfortable seats.