Tom Q.
Google
Written in September 2018: today, we mourn the end of our long relationship with Trattoria Al Forno.
I pose the following question to the restaurant here: How many of you have been at Al Forno long enough to remember me and my girlfriend dang near moved to tears by your original offerings?
During one trip, we ate at Al Forno nightly for three straight evenings and couldn't get enough.
Sadly, over the last year, quality has declined well below the price point. What happened? Was it the departure of Chef Rumpler or manager Athena?
The calamari now has a heavier breading, greasier and laden with heavy sauces. The lasagna was overcooked and bland; tasted like a thawed frozen meal from the supermarket.
The Pasta alla Bolognese tasted like it came from a Chef Boyardee can.
It did not help when our waitress kept walking away when we were still in conversation with her. She was not very attentive during the meal either, and unhelpful in making the evening any better.
Overall, a general downward trend over the last 12 months.
Silver lining: The olive oil is still good, let's see if they can manage to keep that going. The insalata caprese is also still a noteworthy dish ever since they brought back the heirloom tomatoes. How long before Al Forno screw those up? Let me know.
And, to you people who offer some half-hearted response here to try and somehow woo us back, please, save your energy and focus elsewhere. We are done talking, no one at the restaurant has listened over the last 12 months, so there is nothing YOU can do to make things any better, don't fool yourselves.
Updated on 25 December 2025: after a 7-year break, we decided to give Trattoria Al Forno a peek to see if anything has improved.
Bottom line up front: none.
We had a reservation for 6.10p, we arrived and checked in at 5.50p but was not seated until 6.20p. The waiter, Todd, did not show up until 6.32p.
Todd from Natick MA, had zero personality and looked like he didn't want to live anymore. No smiles, no pleasantries, no soul, dead inside. Looked like we were an inconvenience to him. Maybe his dog died. He was also a touch bit creepy with my girlfriend. Simply added very little value to our experience that night.
Manager: if someone is not in the mental state to elevate the guests' experience, send them home; they are doing more damage to the brand than the revenue is worth.
Olive oil was stone cold and flooded with cheap garlic pieces.
Burrito had tiny slivers of basil... what? Running low on basil leaves?
Short ribs were dry. Not worth eating. The accompanying Pilanta was decent.
Shrimp pasta was decent but nothing memorable.
Shiny exception: Hostess Hailey from Birdsboro, PA was helpful, charming and sets the standard for everyone else.
We continue to not return no matter what the social media people say below. 👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻