Trattoria Stella
Restaurant · Traverse City ·
Farm-to-table Italian with housemade pasta & curated wine
Farm-to-table Italian with housemade pasta & curated wine
"Closing in on 21 years, Trattoria Stella has earned the title of grande dame of the Traverse City dining scene. Beloved for its house burrata, tender grilled octopus, and homemade charcuterie offerings, the restaurant is also home to one of the most thoughtful Italian wine lists in Michigan. Stella’s cavernous, subterranean dining room is as romantic as it gets and is a great place to celebrate your anniversary. Secure a table on Resy or place an order for pickup." - Stacey Brugeman
"Housed in the beloved arches of the redeveloped Grand Traverse Commons (a former state hospital), this cavernous, romantic restaurant helped define Northern Michigan’s farm-to-table movement over the past two decades. Co-owned by sommelier Amanda Danielson and chef Myles Anton, it features a daily-changing menu built around longtime partnerships with local growers—individuals like Heirloom Craig (tomatoes), Werp Farms (sylvetta arugula), and Jen Bramer’s Local Yokels Farm (celery)—and emphasizes housemade pasta and whole-animal butchery. The wine program is a standout, mixing Italian-focused selections with Michigan producers (including an anniversary sparkling called “Through the Sextant” and collaborations with Piedmont and Oregon winemakers). Community engagement is central: the team stages wine dinners, charity events (notably a picnic with a whole roasted pig, spicy Calabrian vinaigrette, cavatappi pasta salad, and local strawberry shortcake), and industry-building initiatives such as the Dirt to Glass conference and a planned teaching vineyard. With multiple James Beard semifinal nods for the chef, exceptional staff retention, and recent efforts to improve employee benefits and work-life balance, the restaurant is credited with elevating the region’s culinary and wine culture while maintaining a strong commitment to local sourcing and hospitality." - Stacey Brugeman
"The subterranean Trattoria Stella, a 15-year favorite in Traverse City, was down about 60 percent this summer after operating at roughly 35 percent of its pre-pandemic seats to achieve true social distancing; owner Amanda Danielson applied to expand seating into an adjacent interior corridor but had not received approval, a change she said could have meant six figures for the business this year." - Stacey Brugeman
"Located in the basement of a historic state psychiatric hospital, I noted that Trattoria Stella faces unique spacing challenges—thick brick alcoves limit seating so the restaurant realistically caps at about 33 percent capacity despite a 50 percent allowance—and staff have even begun manning the hostess stand themselves to enforce safety measures." - Stacey Brugeman
"I heard co-owner Amanda Danielson express cautious optimism about Trattoria Stella in Traverse City reopening on Friday given the region’s relatively few cases, while noting concern that many summer visitors come from higher-infection areas; the restaurant plans to seat only customers with reservations." - Brenna Houck
Brian C.
Tony S.
Lauren B.
Jessica H.
Bonnie D.
Will P.
Dorothy Ramirez (.
Mitch N.